Skip to main content

So Many Formations

So Many Formations

Joined
Feb 13, 2013
Messages
104
While our upwardly mobile progress this season has been built around a rock solid defence, I’ve been impressed with SG’s willingness (and his confidence in the playing squad) to frequently alter his tactical approach to games to take account of the opposition’s strengths and weaknesses. More to the point, the players appear to have shown that they can readily adapt to changes in formations without it causing confusion and affecting the team’s performance. When 442 is so often the norm the various permutations may also help to keep opponents planning off balance.

So I think the manager’s ability to get his technical ideas across to the team and for them to take it on board is quite impressive as I suspect most other teams would struggle to understand why so many permutations are considered necessary and would find it difficult to cope with consequential negative impact on performances and results.

There again maybe I'm over estimating the relative importance of this.
 
While our upwardly mobile progress this season has been built around a rock solid defence, I’ve been impressed with SG’s willingness (and his confidence in the playing squad) to frequently alter his tactical approach to games to take account of the opposition’s strengths and weaknesses. More to the point, the players appear to have shown that they can readily adapt to changes in formations without it causing confusion and affecting the team’s performance. When 442 is so often the norm the various permutations may also help to keep opponents planning off balance.

So I think the manager’s ability to get his technical ideas across to the team and for them to take it on board is quite impressive as I suspect most other teams would struggle to understand why so many permutations are considered necessary and would find it difficult to cope with consequential negative impact on performances and results.

There again maybe I'm over estimating the relative importance of this.

Agree with you, our versatility & adaptation in games has been superb, but I wouldn't exclude a major factor in all of the above... Thompson!
It can't be a coincidence that we've looked so much more assured (particularly at the beginning & end of games) this season, since he has been involved. I imagine Grayson is the sort of manager who takes on advice from those around him as well as making his own decisions.
As good as we were last season in some parts, we were equallly as bad in others - especially conceeding late goals & a fair few sloppy starts.

Was a great appointment Thompson! Bravo so far!
 
To be honest I think the days of 4-4-2 being the standard default formation for most teams are long gone and the ability to change shape is pre-requisit for most clubs. If a player didn't understand the need to be tactically flexible these days, I wouldn't expected them to be plying their profession at this level for very long.
 
Interesting comments. For too long in this country we have got bogged down with tactical naivity and almost ignore set up, patterns of play and fluidity of formations.
I actually believe that we are 1 of the closest teams I've seen to Total Football in England. You may scoff at this but often we make subtle changes throughout games... its simple adaption to the game. What I would add is that Glynn Snodin shouldn't be discounted as a positive input on tactics. He has all the coaching badges, and I would agree that Thompson is a good addition but would also say that the higher up the leagues you go, the more tactics come into play, especially when competing against supposedly better sides.
 
I think you'll find 4-4-2 is the best formation. It worked for us and Leicester 2 years ago as we both destroyed teams week after week with that formation and it's working for us currently in 2nd.

And let's not forget the Foxes are top of the PL with their 4-4-2 formation.

It's Wenger and co. who are the ones left behind.
 
I would add that the North End faithful seem a lot more patient with tactical formation than in the past. The obsession for Craig Brown to revert to 4.4.2 was ridiculous. But then again he wasn't getting the results which is all that matters ultimately.
 
I think you'll find 4-4-2 is the best formation. It worked for us and Leicester 2 years ago as we both destroyed teams week after week with that formation and it's working for us currently in 2nd.

And let's not forget the Foxes are top of the PL with their 4-4-2 formation.

It's Wenger and co. who are the ones left behind.

Nothing wrong with 4.4.2 but the best formation is the 1 that gets the result. Your blinkered attitude is systematic of English football and Leicester do not play a traditional 4.4.2; look more carefully.
 
And 4-4-2 gets results for us as we got promoted at a canter last time and are doing well once again. Two years ago we barely had to break sweat in matches as teams who played a 5 man midfield couldn't live with us. With Vokes and Ings up front we simply tore apart teams with them getting nearly 50 goals between them.
 
I think you'll find 4-4-2 is the best formation.

We can't play 4.4.2 because other than Reach for the left we don't possess suitable players. Neither Gallagher nor Johnson have the presence to be part of central duo - one or other of them might if we had someone like Gregan to play alongside them but the two of them together would just be brushed aside. Pearson and Browne might be able to win a central midfield battle but then what would we do with Gallagher and Johnson? The players we have work in either the wing-back 3.5.2 or a 4.3.3 and that suits us fine - one a more defensive counter-attacking formation and the other more all-out attacking. Even though it stuttered in the first half on Tuesday - as it usually does against 'poor' opposition - we will probably revert to the wing-back line-up on Saturday and hopefully it will perform as it usually does in such games.
 
And 4-4-2 gets results for us as we got promoted at a canter last time and are doing well once again. Two years ago we barely had to break sweat in matches as teams who played a 5 man midfield couldn't live with us. With Vokes and Ings up front we simply tore apart teams with them getting nearly 50 goals between them.

You hit a winning formula with Trippier supplying Ings and the rest were solid... well done. It worked for you but not sure you'll remain 2nd this time. I wouldnt say you were promoted at a canter but enjoy looking bavk through rose tinted specs and see how the rest of the season plays out.
What I would say for now is that we are only 9th due to individual player quality not because of formation. On the flip side we are above teams with better squads due to our tactics and attitude.
 
And 4-4-2 gets results for us as we got promoted at a canter last time and are doing well once again. Two years ago we barely had to break sweat in matches as teams who played a 5 man midfield couldn't live with us. With Vokes and Ings up front we simply tore apart teams with them getting nearly 50 goals between them.

No but you broke a sweat against us and lost. Yes, you are second but 9 million spent on a striker and he hardly got a sniff against us. You got promoted to the prem and bored everyone to death with your negative tactics - I fell asleep a few times watching you on sky. Hopefully you don't get promoted so you don't bore everyone this time as well.
 
And 4-4-2 gets results for us as we got promoted at a canter last time and are doing well once again. Two years ago we barely had to break sweat in matches as teams who played a 5 man midfield couldn't live with us. With Vokes and Ings up front we simply tore apart teams with them getting nearly 50 goals between them.


So what you're saying is 4-4-2 works really well when you've got two shit-hot forwards.

News: not everyone has that (particularly us at the moment).

The best formation is the one that best suits the players you have available at the time and is best able to hurt/withstand whatever the opposition put in front of you.
 
For the record Dyche has said Andre cost £56 million. Seriously though he cost £6 million with an additional payment of £3 million to Brentford if we go up. So what if he had a poor game earlier in the season. He'll be a decent striker in the PL, along with Jay-Rod, Austin, Ings etc. Our production line for strikers will go on and on and on. As for negative tactics, that couldn't be farther from the truth as being too open meant we lost too many games.
 
And to add, it would be great if you got promoted. Obviously not at our expense, but seeing PNE v Burnley on MOTD would be something to behold. I'm sure Lawro would be gushing with pride and would be full of praise.
 
I'm stuck in the world of 2-3-5, anything beyond that is way over my head. It used to be a lot more exciting to watch than many of these variants, but of course it's results that matter, not entertainment. :'(
 
I actually believe that we are 1 of the closest teams I've seen to Total Football in England. You may scoff at this but often we make subtle changes throughout games... its simple adaption to the game.

You're right, I will scoff at this
 
Last edited:
You're right, I will scoff at this

Oh dear... i think i had too many wines when i wrote that. Plus getting carried away with results. Back to reality... but has the play off push come to an end or can we dust off and go again?

Total football is too far but flexible in our set up with flexible perso nel is accurate.
 
Back
Top