Based on actually seeing them - I was there, for once, on Friday.
Now that performance was written into the formation - neither Kilkenny nor Brownhill can really impose themselves as ball-winners and neither is much good at playing defence-splitting through balls, while neither Reid nor Humphrey can keep possession for long so we were always going to playing a sort of tip-tap sideways football interspersed with the odd punt forward. But with just Beckford upfront by himself neither were we going to be able to hold the ball up - despite the fact that he played quite well - he won some flick-ons but when he had the ball at his feet with his back to goal he was easily dispossessed. It was an atrociously bad selection and SG must recognise that if we are going to get back in the hunt for an automatic spot - which is still possible.
There is also the question of Gallagher because though he was clearly a class above everyone else SG patently has not yet worked out how to use him properly. Remember last season after early experiments with a 4.4.2 SG hit on this 3.4.1.2 'wing-back' formation - call it what you like - with Gallagher behind the front two and in front of the midfield four. But that is the point - Gallagher did not have to be a striker because we already had two others doing that job or a midfielder because there was a solid midfield behind him. Now that worked brilliantly as an away formation but it consistently failed to get more than draws at our place - the main reason being that the wide players Humphrey and Laird while still effective defensively lacked the ability to get past packed opposition defences that sat back whereas in away games when the opposition pushed up Humphrey at least could at times use his pace to exploit gaps they left at the back.
We could play that way because we only had three at the back but this season SG has reverted to a back four. Fair enough but that means something has had to give further upfield and that has been one of the strikers and while there may be a case for playing that way at times in away games - and with a striker who can actually play that role e.g Davies - Friday showed conclusively and surely finally that that policy is utterly bankrupt for home games. So from now on we have to go out at home with a proper strikeforce and if Gallagher is not used as a striker then from current resources that has to mean Beckford with either Davies or Ebanks-Blake.
But what do we then do with Gallagher? On Friday he actually did more as a wide attacker than either Humphrey or Reid and so you could do something like this:
Johnstone,
Wiseman/Woods. Clarke, Huntington/Wright, Laird
Humphrey, Welsh, Browne/Kilkenny, Gallagher
Beckford, Davies/Ebanks-Blake
That would work better than what we saw on Friday - Humphrey wouldn't actually contribute much as an attacker but would help out defensively - but it would inevitably morph into that 'wing-back' formation again. So is there a way of playing a back four, two strikers, Gallagher and a midfield with enough bite to win the ball in the first place? Yes, something like this:
Johnstone
Wiseman/Woods, Clarke, Huntington/Wright, Laird
Browne, Welsh, King/Kilkenny
Gallagher
Beckford, Davies/Ebanks-Blake
OK there are no 'wingers' there but Reid has hardly justified a starting position - he played well for 20 minutes on Friday - and Humphrey... well how many times have I said this flat and wide of the central midfield where the ball is passed to him when he is stationary with the defence in front of him he poses no real threat because he lacks the trickery and imagination to get past a packed defence. If you want to use Humphrey as an attacker he needs to be in line with the strikers and a bit more in-field with a supply of through balls to run onto in a sort of 4.3.3. That would be a tactical option for later on against tiring opposition, as would bringing on Reid. But at the start the mix of Gallagher in a free role, the fullbacks getting upfield and Browne who has the energy to run around would have to give us the width we need. I just don't see that that would be worse than what we saw on Friday and frankly until we have a central midfield pairing with enough strength and creativity to support two wide attackers and/or another wide player with both attacking skill and defensive strength - a mix of the best of both Humphrey and Reid - there is just no point.
Anyhow that's how I see it. If SG sees it a different way and wants to continue with the failed policy of Humphrey and Reid starting in the wide positions, a weak central midfield, a single striker who is not appropriate for the role and Gallagher running around trying to compensate for all the weaknesses around him then it will cost us the chance we still do have of an automatic place and possibly him his job.
Now that performance was written into the formation - neither Kilkenny nor Brownhill can really impose themselves as ball-winners and neither is much good at playing defence-splitting through balls, while neither Reid nor Humphrey can keep possession for long so we were always going to playing a sort of tip-tap sideways football interspersed with the odd punt forward. But with just Beckford upfront by himself neither were we going to be able to hold the ball up - despite the fact that he played quite well - he won some flick-ons but when he had the ball at his feet with his back to goal he was easily dispossessed. It was an atrociously bad selection and SG must recognise that if we are going to get back in the hunt for an automatic spot - which is still possible.
There is also the question of Gallagher because though he was clearly a class above everyone else SG patently has not yet worked out how to use him properly. Remember last season after early experiments with a 4.4.2 SG hit on this 3.4.1.2 'wing-back' formation - call it what you like - with Gallagher behind the front two and in front of the midfield four. But that is the point - Gallagher did not have to be a striker because we already had two others doing that job or a midfielder because there was a solid midfield behind him. Now that worked brilliantly as an away formation but it consistently failed to get more than draws at our place - the main reason being that the wide players Humphrey and Laird while still effective defensively lacked the ability to get past packed opposition defences that sat back whereas in away games when the opposition pushed up Humphrey at least could at times use his pace to exploit gaps they left at the back.
We could play that way because we only had three at the back but this season SG has reverted to a back four. Fair enough but that means something has had to give further upfield and that has been one of the strikers and while there may be a case for playing that way at times in away games - and with a striker who can actually play that role e.g Davies - Friday showed conclusively and surely finally that that policy is utterly bankrupt for home games. So from now on we have to go out at home with a proper strikeforce and if Gallagher is not used as a striker then from current resources that has to mean Beckford with either Davies or Ebanks-Blake.
But what do we then do with Gallagher? On Friday he actually did more as a wide attacker than either Humphrey or Reid and so you could do something like this:
Johnstone,
Wiseman/Woods. Clarke, Huntington/Wright, Laird
Humphrey, Welsh, Browne/Kilkenny, Gallagher
Beckford, Davies/Ebanks-Blake
That would work better than what we saw on Friday - Humphrey wouldn't actually contribute much as an attacker but would help out defensively - but it would inevitably morph into that 'wing-back' formation again. So is there a way of playing a back four, two strikers, Gallagher and a midfield with enough bite to win the ball in the first place? Yes, something like this:
Johnstone
Wiseman/Woods, Clarke, Huntington/Wright, Laird
Browne, Welsh, King/Kilkenny
Gallagher
Beckford, Davies/Ebanks-Blake
OK there are no 'wingers' there but Reid has hardly justified a starting position - he played well for 20 minutes on Friday - and Humphrey... well how many times have I said this flat and wide of the central midfield where the ball is passed to him when he is stationary with the defence in front of him he poses no real threat because he lacks the trickery and imagination to get past a packed defence. If you want to use Humphrey as an attacker he needs to be in line with the strikers and a bit more in-field with a supply of through balls to run onto in a sort of 4.3.3. That would be a tactical option for later on against tiring opposition, as would bringing on Reid. But at the start the mix of Gallagher in a free role, the fullbacks getting upfield and Browne who has the energy to run around would have to give us the width we need. I just don't see that that would be worse than what we saw on Friday and frankly until we have a central midfield pairing with enough strength and creativity to support two wide attackers and/or another wide player with both attacking skill and defensive strength - a mix of the best of both Humphrey and Reid - there is just no point.
Anyhow that's how I see it. If SG sees it a different way and wants to continue with the failed policy of Humphrey and Reid starting in the wide positions, a weak central midfield, a single striker who is not appropriate for the role and Gallagher running around trying to compensate for all the weaknesses around him then it will cost us the chance we still do have of an automatic place and possibly him his job.
Last edited: