Skip to main content

Some perspective on today

Some perspective on today

Joined
Aug 5, 2009
Messages
1,150
I thought Walsall were excellent today. Some may claim they had nothing to beat (and there may be some truth in that), but I thought they were organised at the back, hard working front to back, calm and assured in possession as well as being inventive and dangerous in attack with pace and trickery aplenty. No long balls, no chucking themselves to the floor, no time wasting, just a really tidy and bright football side.

We have had alot of excuses from our football club in the past 12 months. With a manager who has probably signed somewhere in the region of forty players since he arrived, as well as bringing with him his own staff, removing any player he didn't want, spending roughly £400,000 and having a wagebill that will be the envy of at least 80% of the sides in this division, I think Walsall today can put that into perspective.

Out of curiosity I've done some research on them tonight and here's a few bits and bobs from one of their fans that to me highlights what a load of crap we have been served up in this past year.

Their average attendance is roughly 3,300 and their yearly wagebill is believed to be about 850k, or for a 20 man squad, roughly £850pw per player.

On transfer money spent:

None. All free's or youth players. We've just made a deal for Sam Mantom from Albion permanent which was 'apparently' undisclosed, but considering they didnt give a toot about him and had told him they weren't extending any deal for him at the end of the season, i'd be surprised if it was £10k+. James Baxendale had barely played a minute of professional football before joining from league 2 relegated Hereford in the summer (he scored the 3rd goal today), Nicky Featherstone came from the same place as did full back Ben Purkiss (who played at right back today and crossed the ball for the 2nd). I'd imagine they are all comfortably on 3 figures PW wages. Ashley Hemmings came from Wolves after he'd been released. Paul Downing a free from the Albion after being on loan at Barnet last season. Dean Holden came in from relegation Rochdale. Febian Brandy had been playing football in the Greek 2nd division and hadn't played more than 2 games all last season. So yeah some fairly cheap, strange signings on paper that have been given the boot and then boasted to high heaven about.

On the youth products:

Will Grigg, Jamie Paterson, George Bowerman, Malvind Benning, Richard Taundry. Grigg, Paterson and currently Benning play every week, Paterson and Grigg are in the top 3 goalscorers with 7ish goals I think. Paterson has been subject to interest from Sheffield United and Wolves in recent weeks, Bowerman started the season on fire with 6 goals before late October but has faded since performing poorly in our 16 winless run. Benning is a left back and just started getting first team football, he signed a new 2 year deal last week after impressing in his first 3 or 4 1st XI games. Taundry is gash, but came through the youth.

And despite Walsall being surrounded by the likes of Villa, Brum, Wolves, Albion etc they have also produced the likes of Scott Dann, Troy Deeney and Danny Fox in the last few years.

Apologises if I've lost some of you along the way, but really the point I wanted to make was this is a real football club with problems, with real financial struggles, who despite all that, play good football, don't result to dirty tactics, give their young players a chance and basically do their town proud against the odds.

So next time you hear another string of excuses from Graham Westley, or god forbid our chairman/not chairman Peter Ridsdale, don't swallow it. We're 16th in League One because of their incompetence and nothing else.

Expect better.
 
I thought Walsall were excellent today. Some may claim they had nothing to beat (and there may be some truth in that), but I thought they were organised at the back, hard working front to back, calm and assured in possession as well as being inventive and dangerous in attack with pace and trickery aplenty. No long balls, no chucking themselves to the floor, no time wasting, just a really tidy and bright football side.

We have had alot of excuses from our football club in the past 12 months. With a manager who has probably signed somewhere in the region of forty players since he arrived, as well as bringing with him his own staff, removing any player he didn't want, spending roughly £400,000 and having a wagebill that will be the envy of at least 80% of the sides in this division, I think Walsall today can put that into perspective.

Out of curiosity I've done some research on them tonight and here's a few bits and bobs from one of their fans that to me highlights what a load of crap we have been served up in this past year.

Their average attendance is roughly 3,300 and their yearly wagebill is believed to be about 850k, or for a 20 man squad, roughly £850pw per player.

On transfer money spent:



On the youth products:



And despite Walsall being surrounded by the likes of Villa, Brum, Wolves, Albion etc they have also produced the likes of Scott Dann, Troy Deeney and Danny Fox in the last few years.

Apologises if I've lost some of you along the way, but really the point I wanted to make was this is a real football club with problems, with real financial struggles, who despite all that, play good football, don't result to dirty tactics, give their young players a chance and basically do their town proud against the odds.

So next time you hear another string of excuses from Graham Westley, or god forbid our chairman/not chairman Peter Ridsdale, don't swallow it. We're 16th in League One because of their incompetence and nothing else.

Expect better.

Cracking post.
 
Whilst we have no right to beat Walsall and deserved nothing from today I would expect that most football supporters would place us higher up the pecking order of the 92 clubs.

Money is not everything in football but it should provide a massive advantage if you have 2 or 3 times more of it than some of you opposition.

If Walsall had any interest in laird Keane Huntington cansdell-sherif Buchanan welsh wroe Amoo monakana Byrom mousinho Holmes simonsen trundle Beasley or king then they would have had no chance of signing any of them just like most of the clubs they left Stevenage tranmere Yeovil Shrewsbury Luton and Woking.

Whatever the reasons/excuses we have brought together a group of players and failed to make something of them.

As gates plummet we will have to trim our squad and allow people to leave we might prefer to keep to stay within the fair play rules.

Maybe a few lads on £850 and some youth team players will come in to bolster the squad.

Our recent ability to make Crewe Doncaster and Walsall look like brazil is a real concern
 
I thought Walsall were excellent today. Some may claim they had nothing to beat (and there may be some truth in that), but I thought they were organised at the back, hard working front to back, calm and assured in possession as well as being inventive and dangerous in attack with pace and trickery aplenty. No long balls, no chucking themselves to the floor, no time wasting, just a really tidy and bright football side.

We have had alot of excuses from our football club in the past 12 months. With a manager who has probably signed somewhere in the region of forty players since he arrived, as well as bringing with him his own staff, removing any player he didn't want, spending roughly £400,000 and having a wagebill that will be the envy of at least 80% of the sides in this division, I think Walsall today can put that into perspective.

Out of curiosity I've done some research on them tonight and here's a few bits and bobs from one of their fans that to me highlights what a load of crap we have been served up in this past year.

Their average attendance is roughly 3,300 and their yearly wagebill is believed to be about 850k, or for a 20 man squad, roughly £850pw per player.

On transfer money spent:



On the youth products:



And despite Walsall being surrounded by the likes of Villa, Brum, Wolves, Albion etc they have also produced the likes of Scott Dann, Troy Deeney and Danny Fox in the last few years.

Apologises if I've lost some of you along the way, but really the point I wanted to make was this is a real football club with problems, with real financial struggles, who despite all that, play good football, don't result to dirty tactics, give their young players a chance and basically do their town proud against the odds.

So next time you hear another string of excuses from Graham Westley, or god forbid our chairman/not chairman Peter Ridsdale, don't swallow it. We're 16th in League One because of their incompetence and nothing else.

Expect better.

Must admit after seeing how good they were on the ball earlier in the season I again expected us to lose today. They seem very impressive and play nice football. What's puzzles me though us why they aren't higher up in the table. And more worryingly so why they look so good in contrast to us.
 
I was very impressed with Walsall.

I don't want to discuss Westley at the moment because I'm not sure what I think.

However, I don't think the state of our club can be as a result of the incompetence of Peter Ridsdale. He is quiet in the press for a good reason, but you can't expect him to change the entire nature of a heavily mismanaged club in just over a year. We're in a better place than we were 12 months ago (if not in the league). Patience is required with him, whether you would say the same about Westley or not. Whether GW manages to turn it around or not, I think it is an encouraging sign that we haven't panic sacked yet another manager.
 
like I have said earlier on today, we started the season with one of the better squads in this division, and from the games I have managed to see this season the majority of which has been shown in our general play. These games all came early doors in the season. I saw an Internet stream on thursday night Vs Coventry and thought, WHAT THE FUCK HAS HAPPENED TO THIS TEAM? the last game I saw was away at Tranmere, compare the two performances and it's fucking scandalous, and like I said earlier today, my only guess would be that these players came as good players and Westley's system has worn them down. Hence the shit you guys witness week in week out. A good manager get's the best out of the players in front of him,much like the OP suggests the Wallsall manager has managed to do. Graham, it's time to stop blaming your tools just because your a shit workman.
 
I firmly believe someone could come into this club and turn our current group of players into a top 6 side in this league.

- Our defence is changed week in, week out and their confidence is on the floor.

- The midfielders don't seemed to know their job

- We have two good strikers who are starved and just asked to chase

- We have a winger (monakana) who was ripping teams apart at the start of the season but again his confidence is on the floor

- The Right back issue still isn't dealt with and King is being asked to play there and he stands out like a sore thumb

- Our keepers have been rotated all season and dropped for the slightest mistake putting them on edge
 
Whilst we have no right to beat Walsall and deserved nothing from today I would expect that most football supporters would place us higher up the pecking order of the 92 clubs.

Money is not everything in football but it should provide a massive advantage if you have 2 or 3 times more of it than some of you opposition.

If Walsall had any interest in laird Keane Huntington cansdell-sherif Buchanan welsh wroe Amoo monakana Byrom mousinho Holmes simonsen trundle Beasley or king then they would have had no chance of signing any of them just like most of the clubs they left Stevenage tranmere Yeovil Shrewsbury Luton and Woking.

Whatever the reasons/excuses we have brought together a group of players and failed to make something of them.

As gates plummet we will have to trim our squad and allow people to leave we might prefer to keep to stay within the fair play rules.

Maybe a few lads on £850 and some youth team players will come in to bolster the squad.

Our recent ability to make Crewe Doncaster and Walsall look like brazil is a real concern

Ill happily do a job up top for us, 19, raw talent, scored 11 in 8 for uni in fife league and 8 in 7 in BUCS league before christmas. Id do it for 50 quid a week let alone 850! Plus i have a point to prove because they didn't offer me a scholorship contract when i was 16, gutted!
 
I thought Walsall were excellent today. Some may claim they had nothing to beat (and there may be some truth in that), but I thought they were organised at the back, hard working front to back, calm and assured in possession as well as being inventive and dangerous in attack with pace and trickery aplenty. No long balls, no chucking themselves to the floor, no time wasting, just a really tidy and bright football side.

We have had alot of excuses from our football club in the past 12 months. With a manager who has probably signed somewhere in the region of forty players since he arrived, as well as bringing with him his own staff, removing any player he didn't want, spending roughly £400,000 and having a wagebill that will be the envy of at least 80% of the sides in this division, I think Walsall today can put that into perspective.

Out of curiosity I've done some research on them tonight and here's a few bits and bobs from one of their fans that to me highlights what a load of crap we have been served up in this past year.

Their average attendance is roughly 3,300 and their yearly wagebill is believed to be about 850k, or for a 20 man squad, roughly £850pw per player.

On transfer money spent:



On the youth products:



And despite Walsall being surrounded by the likes of Villa, Brum, Wolves, Albion etc they have also produced the likes of Scott Dann, Troy Deeney and Danny Fox in the last few years.

Apologises if I've lost some of you along the way, but really the point I wanted to make was this is a real football club with problems, with real financial struggles, who despite all that, play good football, don't result to dirty tactics, give their young players a chance and basically do their town proud against the odds.

So next time you hear another string of excuses from Graham Westley, or god forbid our chairman/not chairman Peter Ridsdale, don't swallow it. We're 16th in League One because of their incompetence and nothing else.

Expect better.

Absolutely spot on.
 
Compelling post Cryuff. I've given GW some slack because of the major cost base reduction he has overseen plus the unfortunate injuries we've had.
 
Agreed they looked a decent side at the Bescot as well. We were level in the table before yesterday but it looked we were going in completely opposite directions.
 
I was very impressed with Walsall.

I don't want to discuss Westley at the moment because I'm not sure what I think.

However, I don't think the state of our club can be as a result of the incompetence of Peter Ridsdale. He is quiet in the press for a good reason, but you can't expect him to change the entire nature of a heavily mismanaged club in just over a year. We're in a better place than we were 12 months ago (if not in the league). Patience is required with him, whether you would say the same about Westley or not. Whether GW manages to turn it around or not, I think it is an encouraging sign that we haven't panic sacked yet another manager.

How so we are in fucking meltdown ! ! Cruyff superb post.
 
Agree with Cruyff, was very was impressed with Walsall. Their midfield was fluent, Brandy played well behind the main striker and moved out to the left to give them more width when required.
But to think they went 16 games without a win until just before Christmas.
 
Walsall have traditionally always given us a good game especially in the 70's. From kickoff thought they looked a little nervous but after 5 mins they knew we were there for the taking so relaxed and played some cracking football.
 
Superb OP.
Agree with everything.

The team surrenders possession continually by booting the ball in the air. Fact. It was always a long hoof, often just a 25 yard hoof. But the result was the same. There is no enough movement to permit a pass to feet, hence the airborne route.

Other point. Last time we got out of this division at the back we had (I think) : Alexander, Jackson, Murdoch, Edwards. Or maybe Lucetti instead of Murdoch as first choice.

Foster to pick on one player, is operating at a lvl way below say Jacko. The Walsall RB was twice the player of any of our back 4.

Effort, application blah blah blah. Bottom line: players are lacking in guile and skill. Tactics are shocking.

Even if they could by some miracle get promoted, there would be nothing to build on in the Championship.

Yesterday was my worst day as a Pne fan. I left the ground with any last shred of blind optimism squeezed out of me. It makes watching PNE lose at Stoke on a Boxing Day under Pa Brown pale into insignificance.

Truly shocking.
 
Back
Top