Skip to main content

Something missing

Something missing

Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
17,366
Location
The desert
This isn't meant as a negative thread as currently 4th having only lost 4 all season and currently set for 5th spot in a competitive top 6.

I think SG has done a great job in 12 months but I feel their is something missing but I can't really put my finger on it.

Having played the other teams in the top 6 on 8 occasions and winning only one I'm a little apprehensive of the playoffs but to be there after the past two seasons is a great achievement:

I was trying to figure out what it is we are missing as have a great goalkeeper, good full backs, centre halves and experienced midfielders along with a good selection of strikers including red hot Garner.

Our home form is a concern having won 7 in 17 but our away form compensates for that.

I am not sure if it's a quick winger, quick striker, attacking midfielder or experienced centre half we need but I feel we could do with one or two signings (obviously a loan) to get us over the line.

I know you don't need to beat teams convincingly as long as you win but something just seems to be missing and SG admitted it be nice to kill teams off.

We seem to struggle against teams who have runners coming from midfield and tracking them. Maybe that's what we need and may have it in Brownhill.

I also don't feel we look at solid with Kilkenny in the side as he sits back to dictate play which means Keane or Welsh advance further forward and don't cover the back 4 like they did earlier in the season. However Kilkenny is a very good player to SG has a conundrum.


Before people have a go I am happy with this season but with 12 games to go I feel we are one or maybe two key loan signings away from a real playoff winning contender and on paper the current squad plus additions is a top two side so the draws at home especially are causing us an issue.
 
This isn't meant as a negative thread as currently 4th having only lost 4 all season and currently set for 5th spot in a competitive top 6.

I think SG has done a great job in 12 months but I feel their is something missing but I can't really put my finger on it.

Having played the other teams in the top 6 on 8 occasions and winning only one I'm a little apprehensive of the playoffs but to be there after the past two seasons is a great achievement:

I was trying to figure out what it is we are missing as have a great goalkeeper, good full backs, centre halves and experienced midfielders along with a good selection of strikers including red hot Garner.

Our home form is a concern having won 7 in 17 but our away form compensates for that.

I am not sure if it's a quick winger, quick striker, attacking midfielder or experienced centre half we need but I feel we could do with one or two signings (obviously a loan) to get us over the line.

I know you don't need to beat teams convincingly as long as you win but something just seems to be missing and SG admitted it be nice to kill teams off.

We seem to struggle against teams who have runners coming from midfield and tracking them. Maybe that's what we need and may have it in Brownhill.

I also don't feel we look at solid with Kilkenny in the side as he sits back to dictate play which means Keane or Welsh advance further forward and don't cover the back 4 like they did earlier in the season. However Kilkenny is a very good player to SG has a conundrum.


Before people have a go I am happy with this season but with 12 games to go I feel we are one or maybe two key loan signings away from a real playoff winning contender and on paper the current squad plus additions is a top two side so the draws at home especially are causing us an issue.

I agree with this.
 
Totally agree , nice post and in my opinion we seem to lack dimension to our play at times and also ( may be the personnel / system ) but we appear to lack real pace and the ability to change gears in games

Mortis
 
This isn't meant as a negative thread as currently 4th having only lost 4 all season and currently set for 5th spot in a competitive top 6.

I think SG has done a great job in 12 months but I feel their is something missing but I can't really put my finger on it.

Having played the other teams in the top 6 on 8 occasions and winning only one I'm a little apprehensive of the playoffs but to be there after the past two seasons is a great achievement:

I was trying to figure out what it is we are missing as have a great goalkeeper, good full backs, centre halves and experienced midfielders along with a good selection of strikers including red hot Garner.

Our home form is a concern having won 7 in 17 but our away form compensates for that.

I am not sure if it's a quick winger, quick striker, attacking midfielder or experienced centre half we need but I feel we could do with one or two signings (obviously a loan) to get us over the line.

I know you don't need to beat teams convincingly as long as you win but something just seems to be missing and SG admitted it be nice to kill teams off.

We seem to struggle against teams who have runners coming from midfield and tracking them. Maybe that's what we need and may have it in Brownhill.

I also don't feel we look at solid with Kilkenny in the side as he sits back to dictate play which means Keane or Welsh advance further forward and don't cover the back 4 like they did earlier in the season. However Kilkenny is a very good player to SG has a conundrum.


Before people have a go I am happy with this season but with 12 games to go I feel we are one or maybe two key loan signings away from a real playoff winning contender and on paper the current squad plus additions is a top two side so the draws at home especially are causing us an issue.



Agree one of our own ! However,i think the fact we have a poor record against the top lot (win wise) really doesn't matter,West Ham proved that in THAT game !
 
Agree with the op. IMO the thing that could cost us promotion is lack of an fire striker scoring for fun. Our good on paper strikers at the start of the season have for whatever reason failed to deliver.
 
Agree one of our own ! However,i think the fact we have a poor record against the top lot (win wise) really doesn't matter,West Ham proved that in THAT game !

Spot on!

They key thing for me is that we hit the play offs ( if thats where we end up) on good form.

I trust Grayson over two games against anyone and the final its who turns up on the day.

If we dont go up this year i fully expect us to add further qulaity and get automatic next year.

All we can do in the meantime is pick up as many wins as possible with the squad we have and see where it takes us.

Still plenty of points to play for!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This isn't meant as a negative thread as currently 4th having only lost 4 all season and currently set for 5th spot in a competitive top 6.

I think SG has done a great job in 12 months but I feel their is something missing but I can't really put my finger on it.

Having played the other teams in the top 6 on 8 occasions and winning only one I'm a little apprehensive of the playoffs but to be there after the past two seasons is a great achievement:

I was trying to figure out what it is we are missing as have a great goalkeeper, good full backs, centre halves and experienced midfielders along with a good selection of strikers including red hot Garner.

Our home form is a concern having won 7 in 17 but our away form compensates for that.

I am not sure if it's a quick winger, quick striker, attacking midfielder or experienced centre half we need but I feel we could do with one or two signings (obviously a loan) to get us over the line.

I know you don't need to beat teams convincingly as long as you win but something just seems to be missing and SG admitted it be nice to kill teams off.

We seem to struggle against teams who have runners coming from midfield and tracking them. Maybe that's what we need and may have it in Brownhill.

I also don't feel we look at solid with Kilkenny in the side as he sits back to dictate play which means Keane or Welsh advance further forward and don't cover the back 4 like they did earlier in the season. However Kilkenny is a very good player to SG has a conundrum.


Before people have a go I am happy with this season but with 12 games to go I feel we are one or maybe two key loan signings away from a real playoff winning contender and on paper the current squad plus additions is a top two side so the draws at home especially are causing us an issue.


We are missing some quality, some cohesion and consequently a bigger wage bill. That's probably why we are fourth and not top... For some reason though I think we'll win the playoffs... No idea why, just a feeling.
 
We are missing some quality, some cohesion and consequently a bigger wage bill. That's probably why we are fourth and not top... For some reason though I think we'll win the playoffs... No idea why, just a feeling.

I suspect the wage bill is significantly higher this season with the addition of Wiseman, Kilkenny, Gallagher, Craig Davies. Anyone I missed?
 
A leader who can not only put pressure on the lads on the pitch to lift there game but direct and dictate play from the middle , a Gregan type or Russ Wilcox .
 
I suspect the wage bill is significantly higher this season with the addition of Wiseman, Kilkenny, Gallagher, Craig Davies. Anyone I missed?

Kevin D ?........... And the wage bill will get higher still with the arrival of more quality. I suppose it's a balancing act. As long as we don't revert back to spending 150% of income on wages we'll be fine.
 
We are missing some quality, some cohesion and consequently a bigger wage bill. That's probably why we are fourth and not top... For some reason though I think we'll win the playoffs... No idea why, just a feeling.

Oh god, I hope you are right !!!!

we have waited a lot of years to bury the hoodoo..........
 
The odd thing about this season is that we are doing well while defying what is usually one of the preconditions for doing so - having a settled, obvious first choice team selection. Instead we are varying between different formations - sometimes three at the back but sometimes four, sometimes just two central midfielders but sometimes three - without ever really seeming to fix on any particular line-up for too long.

What seems evident is that the most consistently reliable set-up is three at the back with Humphrey and Laird in those wide positions that are half winger and half fullback. Frankly I don't think SG intended to play that formation at the start of the season - he was probably thinking in terms of a conventional 4.4.2 but couldn't find the two consistently reliable wide players he needed out of Humphrey, Holmes and Hayhurst. As it is that 3.5.2 or 3.4.1.2 - whatever you want to call it - once it was improved with the additions of Kilkenny alongside Welsh and Gallagher behind the front two to give it a bit more invention has proven tough, consistent, difficult to break down and ideal for grinding out results away from home when the aim is first containment and then hitting the opposition the break.

But it still lacks flair and dynamism and when used at home against teams trying the same tactic against us then it has all too often proven inadequate. Hence the pattern of impressive away victories followed by frustrating home draws.

Personally I think the root cause is that neither Humphrey nor Laird can provide enough attacking threat when used as 'wing-halves' - yes, I'll use that word again. Humphrey does astonishingly well at the defensive side of the role but as an attacker he needs to be played well forward with a supply of through balls to run onto and the support of a fullback behind him - something that just does not happen when he is played in that role. Meanwhile on the other flank Laird - who is a superb attacking left-back in a back four - is similarly OK at the defensive side of things but is simply neither fast enough nor tricky enough to be an attacking threat. If we had two players such as, say, Coutts for the right and Eyres - who could tackle back - for the left things might be different.

As it is I don't see how we can improve things from existing resources. I don't think Keane would be any worse than Humphrey on the right but Holmes on the left would leave us dangerously vulnerable if there was no fullback behind him. That is why the apparent failure of Hayhurst to progress is so disappointing - he would be ideal for that left-sided role and I would like to see him brought back and given a crack there.

So basically the nut that SG still has to crack is finding a team that can attack with flair and invention at home. I still think the best option for doing that is the formation we saw over last 30 minutes against Notts Forest - four at the back with Wiseman and Laird as attacking fullbacks, three across the middle, then Gallagher, then two strikers. But one of those three midfielders needs to be Brownhill - he is plainly the most stylish midfielder we have got and we need to use him - with the others being Kilkenny and Welsh. The alternative is a conventional 4.4.2 with Humphrey and Holmes on the flanks and Brownhill or Kilkenny and Gallagher on the bench.
 
Last edited:
Spot on!

They key thing for me is that we hit the play offs ( if thats where we end up) on good form.

I trust Grayson over two games against anyone and the final its who turns up on the day.

If we dont go up this year i fully expect us to add further qulaity and get automatic next year.

All we can do in the meantime is pick up as many wins as possible with the squad we have and see where it takes us.

Still plenty of points to play for!


If we fail to go up this season, it won't be any easier next time. Sheffield Utd will have got their act together as will Bristol.The teams coming down will always be in with a shout and there may well still be one of the current top 3 kicking about. Add to the mix, MK, Coventry, Swindon and maybe Posh then I can't see it exactly being a strole in the park.
 
This isn't meant as a negative thread as currently 4th having only lost 4 all season and currently set for 5th spot in a competitive top 6.

I think SG has done a great job in 12 months but I feel their is something missing but I can't really put my finger on it.

Having played the other teams in the top 6 on 8 occasions and winning only one I'm a little apprehensive of the playoffs but to be there after the past two seasons is a great achievement:

I was trying to figure out what it is we are missing as have a great goalkeeper, good full backs, centre halves and experienced midfielders along with a good selection of strikers including red hot Garner.

Our home form is a concern having won 7 in 17 but our away form compensates for that.

I am not sure if it's a quick winger, quick striker, attacking midfielder or experienced centre half we need but I feel we could do with one or two signings (obviously a loan) to get us over the line.

I know you don't need to beat teams convincingly as long as you win but something just seems to be missing and SG admitted it be nice to kill teams off.

We seem to struggle against teams who have runners coming from midfield and tracking them. Maybe that's what we need and may have it in Brownhill.

I also don't feel we look at solid with Kilkenny in the side as he sits back to dictate play which means Keane or Welsh advance further forward and don't cover the back 4 like they did earlier in the season. However Kilkenny is a very good player to SG has a conundrum.


Before people have a go I am happy with this season but with 12 games to go I feel we are one or maybe two key loan signings away from a real playoff winning contender and on paper the current squad plus additions is a top two side so the draws at home especially are causing us an issue.

I agree. We don't look the finished article yet. Probably a mixture of everything you've stated. But how can we expect to be given where we have come from in 12 months I suppose? Another point I'd make is that while our record is poor against the top teams (to the point that automatic promotion is rarely achieved with such a record) it is irrelevant in the play-offs. We beat West Ham twice (maybe three times - can't remember if there was a cup match too) the year they beat us in the final.

I think Wolves will win the league and i'd fancy us to be at least in with a mathematical shout going in to the final match of overtaking Orient or Brentford or both. Which I would have snapped anyone's hand off for last year.
 
I suspect the wage bill is significantly higher this season with the addition of Wiseman, Kilkenny, Gallagher, Craig Davies. Anyone I missed?

Also Hume, in effect, as he came back to the club after the loan spell at Doncaster, and is on "Championship" wages.
 
I think the fans are looking for something that will not happen under Grayson, at least not in this League. Look at the comments from Lashers, Leeds and Huddersfield fans when he was appointed, all frustrated by the style of football played but ultimately all grateful for the success he brought the respective clubs.

Grayson is doing the necessary to get out of this division, it may not be pretty but his brand of football is successful. You cannot argue with his pedigree in League 1.
 
Back
Top