Skip to main content

Squad Breakdown

Squad Breakdown

Joined
Oct 30, 2004
Messages
120
I can't believe what I'm reading on here, have you forgotten what it was like under Westley & Ferguson?

I agree Grayson didn't get his tactics right last night and we have not performed in the big games when it really matters this season:

Wolves (A)
Brentford (A)
Rotherham - both play-off games

HOWEVER, what he has done to turn us around in the time he's been here and for us to be disappointed going to places like this is almost miraculous. Our squad isn't as good as most on here believe in my eyes. He's done an excellent job in his first full season by making us hard to beat, efficient and a solid top 6 league one side, from what looked at some drab points as potential relegation fodder, only last season!

This attitude some fans have "we're a bigger club, so we should steamroll them" I really don't understand, yes we might have a bigger following and better fans, who last night I thought were fantastic (viva Tom Finney ringing around the New York from 3-1 down until the final whistle) but games are won on the pitch & Rotherham were a far better side in my eyes. Well drilled, organised, hardworking & a few very good players for this division particularly Pringle, Tavernier & Agard. I'm not saying they are world beaters, just better than us physically, defensively and far more balanced. The amount of joy their strikers got from just simple percentage channel balls was frightening in comparison to ours!

Despite this, I think we could of run them much closer had Grayson known his best 11 both tactically and personnel wise. Then we would of had the opportunity to punish their weaknesses in defence and had our own game plan rather than trying to counter-act theirs; to defend him though could any of us name our best 11?

He's done extremely well with the squad to get us in this position but I just think we are a couple of quality players short of Wolves, Brentford & Rotherham. We're probably as good as/if not better than Orient & Peterborough, then there is a small drop down to the likes of Swindon, Sheff Utd & MK Dons and a much bigger gulf with the rest of the league, which I believe is a very weak division. We are just that bit short when it really matters, but it's far from doom and gloom, if we have a positive transfer window & pre-season the only way is up!

To sum up the squad & probably the reason why Grayson still doesn't know his best 11, here's my thoughts, my thoughts after finally calming down from last night. Trying to give an honest and balanced view as to, who's good enough and who isn't.....

League One Rating (out of 10)

Rudd - excellent goalkeeper, if we can retain his services for another season I'd be more than happy. (9)

Wiseman - poor game last night, but was thrown in at the deep end after being out injured, I rate him, good with ball, has to play RB rather than wingback to impress for me though. (8)

Clarke - our best defender by a country mile for me, solid every week whichever position. (9)

Bailey-Wright - was excellent until being arrested and hasn't been half the player since, really hope he can regain the form he had earlier in the season. (8)

King - squad player at best. (6)

Laird - decent footballing left back but hasn't been half the player since he broke his leg. (7)

Buchanan - very similar to Laird, in my eyes not quite as good. (6)

Keane - solid enough when selected, not amazing technically. (7)

Welsh - solid ball winner, breaks up play well and puts in a good shift most weeks. (8)

Browne - looks a very good prospect, exciting player. (8)

Brownhill - very good technically, hope he continues to improve. (8)

Holmes - good left foot, just very rarely performs with it. (5)

Kilkenny - in my eyes our best midfielder, dictates play and very good on the ball. (9)

Humphrey - flatters to deceive, has potential but never beats the left back. (6)

Gallagher - very good player, been inconsistent of late but on his day at this level, unplayable, don't think we will be able to afford his wages, big miss. (9)

Kevin Davies - really not impressed me, slows down play too much and the team resorts to long balls when he plays, useful sub. (7)

Craig Davies - looked great at first, attitude very questionable though not someone I'd look to sign. (7)

Garner - fantastic goal-scorer at this level, knows where the net is, however I don't rate him as highly as some, wouldn't be worried if a big bid came in like I was back in the day with the likes of Fuller, Nugent & Macken. Great goal-scorer but not irreplaceable in my eyes, would love to keep him though don't get me wrong, just need to find a striker to really compliment him as his link-up and hold up play can let him down. (9)

Beavon - Think he played really well in his late run in the side and unlucky not to feature more, good movement, work rate and a nice first touch. Deserves a run in the side to prove himself in my eyes. (8)


This leads me back to my summary and the reason I believe Grayson doesn't know his best 11, we are so weak out wide in midfield that he has to find a way to combat that. I really believe if we keep hold of the players, who have taken us to a very good league one side this year and add a little bit of quality, preferably with pace and flair, so we have someone as an outlet, to beat a man (something we are drastically lacking) that we could take league one by storm next year.

Yes, we fell short, yes we bottled it but we need to look at the bigger picture and see where we came from just last year. This side has potential, a wide man like Pringle, who's delivery is excellent or a pacey winger who really gets at full-backs is all we are short. Other areas would be nice but this is where I feel we really need improving.

We have nothing to fear from the teams coming down and only Sheff Utd & Mk Dons are the 2 sides that you think would really improve, as I said before this is a weak division and next year could really be our year, let's stop picking out players & Grayson for criticism and realise if we improve half as much this year we will be promoted!

Up the Whites!
 
You're a generous individual. The inconsistency in this team literally makes rating them impossible. There inconsistent nature itself should take a point of most of the ratings.
 
They were judged on the full season, as a League One player, which really isn't that good but I respect your opinion, potentially I was generous but I'm trying to be optimistic when all I see is negativity!
 
They were judged on the full season, as a League One player, which really isn't that good but I respect your opinion, potentially I was generous but I'm trying to be optimistic when all I see is negativity!

You say negativity.

I say realism.
 
If all these players are that bad though, why did we finish 5th out of 24, that's why my scores are much higher than most would go for, a 10 in League One doesn't make you a great player! It's a poor division and we have better than most!
 
They were judged on the full season, as a League One player, which really isn't that good but I respect your opinion, potentially I was generous but I'm trying to be optimistic when all I see is negativity!

Whilst I appreciate you tryna bring positive vibes I can't help but feel deflated about the team as a whole.. I truly believe some of the players we have are excellent (Craig Davies could be prolific if he wasn't such a lazy fuck), but they haven't stepped up and proved it.. To be considered an 8 or a 9 you have to turn up in the big games and not go shirking.
 
If all these players are that bad though, why did we finish 5th out of 24, that's why my scores are much higher than most would go for, a 10 in League One doesn't make you a great player! It's a poor division and we have better than most!

There's something to be said for that.
 
"This leads me back to my summary and the reason I believe Grayson doesn't know his best 11, we are so weak out wide in midfield that he has to find a way to combat that."


Yes - the fundamental weakness in the squad all season has been a lack of quality and depth in the wide midfield positions, which meant that last night we had two players Wiseman and Buchanan who were utterly inadequate for the roles they were being asked to play. Humphrey and Laird, though also both limited in those roles, at least have some experience there though again neither can consistently provide the mix of attacking and defensive capabilities that are required.
 
Yes - the fundamental weakness in the squad all season has been a lack of quality and depth in the wide midfield positions, which meant that last night we had two players Wiseman and Buchanan who were utterly inadequate for the roles they were being asked to play. Humphrey and Laird, though also both limited in those roles, at least have some experience there though again neither can consistently provide the mix of attacking and defensive capabilities that are required.

Yes yes yes yes yes.

All season we've been crying out for attacking midfielders and flair, strong powerful, quick. People who run at people and beat people, go watch the highlights from last night. The way Rotherham counter-attacked I go to bead dreaming about..

Grayson tried to fix probably every fans criticism in Jan by bringing in Gally and Humphrey but especially the latter are not up for the job. I'm not going to criticise the squad or the manager this season because compared to the last what a job Grayson has done. Top manager, and I can't wait for next season already!!
 
League One Rating (out of 10)

Rudd - excellent goalkeeper, if we can retain his services for another season I'd be more than happy. (9)

Wiseman - poor game last night, but was thrown in at the deep end after being out injured, I rate him, good with ball, has to play RB rather than wingback to impress for me though. (8)

Clarke - our best defender by a country mile for me, solid every week whichever position. (9)

Bailey-Wright - was excellent until being arrested and hasn't been half the player since, really hope he can regain the form he had earlier in the season. (8)

King - squad player at best. (6)

Laird - decent footballing left back but hasn't been half the player since he broke his leg. (7)

Buchanan - very similar to Laird, in my eyes not quite as good. (6)

Keane - solid enough when selected, not amazing technically. (7)

Welsh - solid ball winner, breaks up play well and puts in a good shift most weeks. (8)

Browne - looks a very good prospect, exciting player. (8)

Brownhill - very good technically, hope he continues to improve. (8)

Holmes - good left foot, just very rarely performs with it. (5)

Kilkenny - in my eyes our best midfielder, dictates play and very good on the ball. (9)

Humphrey - flatters to deceive, has potential but never beats the left back. (6)

Gallagher - very good player, been inconsistent of late but on his day at this level, unplayable, don't think we will be able to afford his wages, big miss. (9)

Kevin Davies - really not impressed me, slows down play too much and the team resorts to long balls when he plays, useful sub. (7)

Craig Davies - looked great at first, attitude very questionable though not someone I'd look to sign. (7)

Garner - fantastic goal-scorer at this level, knows where the net is, however I don't rate him as highly as some, wouldn't be worried if a big bid came in like I was back in the day with the likes of Fuller, Nugent & Macken. Great goal-scorer but not irreplaceable in my eyes, would love to keep him though don't get me wrong, just need to find a striker to really compliment him as his link-up and hold up play can let him down. (9)

Beavon - Think he played really well in his late run in the side and unlucky not to feature more, good movement, work rate and a nice first touch. Deserves a run in the side to prove himself in my eyes. (8)

League One Rating (out of 10)

Rudd - (9)
Good keeper, and has kept us in some games.

Wiseman - (6)
Jurys not out even after last nights mistake, was thrown to the dogs by Grayson IMO.

Clarke - (10)
Awesome defender so consistent and never gets beat in the air or on the deck.

Bailey-Wright - (8)
Was really good for us earlier in the season, CB pairing should be him and Clarke they will learn from last night

King - (7)
Good back-up CB a toss up between him and Wright to partner Clarke.

Laird - (6)
Needs to put this season behind him, he gets picked to attack and support something that hasn't happened much this season.

Buchanan - (5)
Thrown to the dogs as well, but gives nothing going forward solid LB but I think Ben Davies should be promoted.

Keane - (6)
Good squad players, can pick a pass now and then but is mid table standard at best.

Welsh - (7)
Wore his heart on his sleeve last night and I thought he had a decent game, but it has to be either him or Kilkenny if you play 442 or 3-5-2, neither are creative enough in that formation unless we play a 451 which is way to negative at home.

Browne - (6)
Big prospect but you have to remember he played well against the league 1 fodder of Shrewsbury and Carlisle.

Brownhill - (6)
A prospect but I don't get the love for this kid, he has scored some good goals but needs to develop a bit more before he can be considered a starter.

Holmes - (5)
Lacks too much pace for a winger and is inconsistent maybe should change his position to CAM.

Kilkenny - (7)
Keeps the game moving and links up the back 4 and midfield, but like I said its either him or Welsh the midfield is very uncreative with those 2 in there.

Humphrey - (5)
Only 1 or 2 good games, would have him in when playing opposition with dangerous players out wide to put in the shift and make sure the RB isn't isolated. Maybe him and Wiseman might form a decent partnership.

Gallagher - (8)
Has been good since he signed, I think with him being towards the back end of his career and wanting to stay local he will take a wage drop to sign for us. Goes missing in the big games though, albeit the free kick. Set pieces too inconsistent.

Kevin Davies - (4)
We are so one dimensional when he plays and some of the misses this season have been laughable, better, younger and faster players available at a snip of the price. Garner can play a better target man than him.

Craig Davies - (6)
All the talent but has been feeding off scraps because there is no creativity from our midfield. Better with the ball at his feet, never wins headers in and around the box. People slated him in the home leg, but he had no support, absolutely nothing, people can't expect him to do it all by himself.

Garner - (9)
This season has shown us what he can do, if he gets a decent strike partner who can feed of his knock downs they would be a decent partnership. Will be here next season unless someone pays big money, can only be considered a one season wonder at this point.

Beavon - (6)
I like him and he works hard, but strikers have to score goals and his record is really poor. Time to replace for me.
 
League One Rating (out of 10)

Rudd - excellent goalkeeper, if we can retain his services for another season I'd be more than happy. (9)

Wiseman - poor game last night, but was thrown in at the deep end after being out injured, I rate him, good with ball, has to play RB rather than wingback to impress for me though. (8)

Clarke - our best defender by a country mile for me, solid every week whichever position. (9)

Bailey-Wright - was excellent until being arrested and hasn't been half the player since, really hope he can regain the form he had earlier in the season. (8)

King - squad player at best. (6)

Laird - decent footballing left back but hasn't been half the player since he broke his leg. (7)

Buchanan - very similar to Laird, in my eyes not quite as good. (6)

Keane - solid enough when selected, not amazing technically. (7)

Welsh - solid ball winner, breaks up play well and puts in a good shift most weeks. (8)

Browne - looks a very good prospect, exciting player. (8)

Brownhill - very good technically, hope he continues to improve. (8)

Holmes - good left foot, just very rarely performs with it. (5)

Kilkenny - in my eyes our best midfielder, dictates play and very good on the ball. (9)

Humphrey - flatters to deceive, has potential but never beats the left back. (6)

Gallagher - very good player, been inconsistent of late but on his day at this level, unplayable, don't think we will be able to afford his wages, big miss. (9)

Kevin Davies - really not impressed me, slows down play too much and the team resorts to long balls when he plays, useful sub. (7)

Craig Davies - looked great at first, attitude very questionable though not someone I'd look to sign. (7)

Garner - fantastic goal-scorer at this level, knows where the net is, however I don't rate him as highly as some, wouldn't be worried if a big bid came in like I was back in the day with the likes of Fuller, Nugent & Macken. Great goal-scorer but not irreplaceable in my eyes, would love to keep him though don't get me wrong, just need to find a striker to really compliment him as his link-up and hold up play can let him down. (9)

Beavon - Think he played really well in his late run in the side and unlucky not to feature more, good movement, work rate and a nice first touch. Deserves a run in the side to prove himself in my eyes. (8)

Both Davies' 7?! Beavon 8?! Gallagher 9?! Jesus I'll have whatever you're on!

If all those players were as good as you suggest, we'd have won the league!

Rudd - 8
Wiseman - 5
Clarke - 8
Wright - 8
King - 5
Buchanan - 6
Laird - 6
Keane - 6
Welsh - 6
Brownhill - 7
Browne - N/A (still too early to say IMO)
Kilkenny - 7
Humphrey - 6
Gallagher - 5
Holmes - 5
K Davies - 5
C Davies - 4
Beavon - 6
Garner - 8

This isn't just based on this season btw. But their potential etc.
 
Last edited:
If all these players are that bad though, why did we finish 5th out of 24, that's why my scores are much higher than most would go for, a 10 in League One doesn't make you a great player! It's a poor division and we have better than most!


Answered your own question.......... All the teams below 6th place are pretty grim and that's why the top 6 ( collectively ) got so many points..
 
Answered your own question.......... All the teams below 6th place are pretty grim and that's why the top 6 ( collectively ) got so many points..

This is my point though, League One is that bad they are actually decent players for League One.
 
Both Davies' 7?! Beavon 8?! Gallagher 9?! Jesus I'll have whatever you're on!

If all those players were as good as you suggest, we'd have won the league!

Rudd - 8
Wiseman - 5
Clarke - 8
Wright - 8
King - 5
Buchanan - 6
Laird - 6
Keane - 6
Welsh - 6
Brownhill - 7
Browne - N/A (still too early to say IMO)
Kilkenny - 7
Humphrey - 6
Gallagher - 5
Holmes - 5
K Davies - 5
C Davies - 4
Beavon - 6
Garner - 8

This isn't just based on this season btw. But their potential etc.

Gallagher 5? He is our 2nd highest goal scorer and I bet the highest assist maker.
 
Back
Top