Skip to main content

Strength In Depth

Strength In Depth

Joined
Dec 5, 2004
Messages
2,481
I mentioned this on another thread. It strikes me that we have real options in our 3-5-2 formation, in most areas we have players who can come in and do a job.

GK: Rudd, Stuckmann

RCB: Clarke
CB: Huntington
LCB: Wright

RWB: Humphrey, Nicholson
LWB: Laird, Buchanan

CDM: Keane, Welsh
CM: Byrom, Wroe, Mousinho

ACM: Hume, Holmes

FW: Davies, Beardsley
FW: Beavon, Garner

The defence is the area of the pitch that concerns me the most. If we lose one of our three centre backs then I'm not sure we have the right personnel to replace them. Laird and Buchanan are too small to be central defenders, as is Keane. Therefore we would have to make do or revert to a back 4.

At wing back it is pretty straightforward, we have two excellent left-sided defenders who can both perform at the top level in this league. On the right, Nicholson should be good cover for Humphrey (Grayson wouldn't have had him training with us for 3 months if he didn't want to use him in the squad).

The same goes for the midfield. Welsh is being kept out of the team by Keane, and Byrom has earned his starting place ahead of Mousinho and Wroe. Wroe is the more likely replacement due to his attacking instinct, and he performed well last season.

The deeper striker or attacking midfield area which Hume currently has could easily be given to Holmes. This would allow Hume to play upfront with Davies or Beavon, replacing whichever got injured. Then we have Garner who gives his all on the pitch, making up for any lack in talent.

I have even mentioned King who is to come back!

What this highlights is that we posses the necessary cover to mount a serious promotion challenge this season, in most areas of the pitch. I just think to loan out SCS after getting rid of Robertson may be our undoing, as it leaves us short of centre backs to cover for the three excellent first choices we have. I wouldn't like to go back to the 4-4-2 formation which saw us draw a number of matches earlier in the season.
 
I mentioned this on another thread. It strikes me that we have real options in our 3-5-2 formation, in most areas we have players who can come in and do a job.

GK: Rudd, Stuckmann

RCB: Clarke
CB: Huntington
LCB: Wright

RWB: Humphrey, Nicholson
LWB: Laird, Buchanan

CDM: Keane, Welsh
CM: Byrom, Wroe, Mousinho

ACM: Hume, Holmes

FW: Davies, Beardsley
FW: Beavon, Garner

The defence is the area of the pitch that concerns me the most. If we lose one of our three centre backs then I'm not sure we have the right personnel to replace them. Laird and Buchanan are too small to be central defenders, as is Keane. Therefore we would have to make do or revert to a back 4.

At wing back it is pretty straightforward, we have two excellent left-sided defenders who can both perform at the top level in this league. On the right, Nicholson should be good cover for Humphrey (Grayson wouldn't have had him training with us for 3 months if he didn't want to use him in the squad).

The same goes for the midfield. Welsh is being kept out of the team by Keane, and Byrom has earned his starting place ahead of Mousinho and Wroe. Wroe is the more likely replacement due to his attacking instinct, and he performed well last season.

The deeper striker or attacking midfield area which Hume currently has could easily be given to Holmes. This would allow Hume to play upfront with Davies or Beavon, replacing whichever got injured. Then we have Garner who gives his all on the pitch, making up for any lack in talent.

I have even mentioned King who is to come back!

What this highlights is that we posses the necessary cover to mount a serious promotion challenge this season, in most areas of the pitch. I just think to loan out SCS after getting rid of Robertson may be our undoing, as it leaves us short of centre backs to cover for the three excellent first choices we have. I wouldn't like to go back to the 4-4-2 formation which saw us draw a number of matches earlier in the season.

To be honest mate I think that post is quite worrying. Buchanan can't play that wing back role and Nicholson I've never seen play so can't judge. There is no cover at all in the centre defence as you say.

Midfield I don't think Wroe and Moose would add anything and would weaken the midfield in the format we are playing.

If we lost Davies then id be worried as Beardsley is shit. Garner could do a job in a game or two but any serious injury to Hume or Beavon and we'd need a new striker.

King I like but what position is he?
 
To be honest mate I think that post is quite worrying. Buchanan can't play that wing back role and Nicholson I've never seen play so can't judge. There is no cover at all in the centre defence as you say.

I think Buchanan can play that left sided role. We know he is good defensively, and is being kept out of the side by Laird for his attacking ability alone. Agree about Nicholson.

Midfield I don't think Wroe and Moose would add anything and would weaken the midfield in the format we are playing.

Neither Wroe nor Mousinho would be in the team before Byrom at the moment, but Byrom is there for his technical ability. Wroe, as we saw last season possesses similar qualities (apart of from set piece taking) in terms of the ability to pick a pass and bring others into the game. I only put Mousinho into that category as I can't see where else he would fit.

If we lost Davies then id be worried as Beardsley is shit. Garner could do a job in a game or two but any serious injury to Hume or Beavon and we'd need a new striker.

Beardsley is shit, but as I wrote if we lost one of Beavon or Davies we would put Hume up top and play Holmes in Hume's position. If we lost both then Garner could be brought in to partner Hume. Beardsley doesn't get a look in, and rightly so.[/QUOTE]

King I like but what position is he?

He's the utility man, the player to fill a gap short-term. Can't really place him in a permanent position as with Mousinho, but then he is more adaptable.
 
SG has already said if we lose another defender either by injury or suspension & by letting SCS go out on loan we will get a another defender in on loan.
 
I reckon king could do a job at centre half. Definitely good in the air, not sure if Westley used him there last season but he did play right back. Ultimate utility man though!
 
I think Buchanan can play that left sided role. We know he is good defensively, and is being kept out of the side by Laird for his attacking ability alone. Agree about Nicholson.



Neither Wroe nor Mousinho would be in the team before Byrom at the moment, but Byrom is there for his technical ability. Wroe, as we saw last season possesses similar qualities (apart of from set piece taking) in terms of the ability to pick a pass and bring others into the game. I only put Mousinho into that category as I can't see where else he would fit.



Beardsley is shit, but as I wrote if we lost one of Beavon or Davies we would put Hume up top and play Holmes in Hume's position. If we lost both then Garner could be brought in to partner Hume. Beardsley doesn't get a look in, and rightly so.



He's the utility man, the player to fill a gap short-term. Can't really place him in a permanent position as with Mousinho, but then he is more adaptable.[/QUOTE]

Buchanan gets a nosebleed when he enters the oppositions half. Very good left back at defending but not as a wing back.

I don't think Wroe is that technical. He times his run in to the box well at times and has a good shot on him and yes in a 442 but don't think he has the vision of Byrom or as good as spreading play.

I feel we'd be in a bad position if lost Davies for any period of time.

We have cover yes but I feel most of this depth would unfortunately weaken the team.

I think King looks composed on the ball and could play centre mid where Byrom plays and can hold it up but a very poor mans Davies. Centre half I don't know
 
Everyone's getting too caught up in the 3-5-2/3-4-1-2 we are playing, we don't have to stick with it all season. If changes need to be made to the system, they will be made.

Buchanan can play left wing back, the way we play, without the ball, Laird drops into full back and the centre halves shift across, with Clarke effectively moving to full back, so he will fit in easily to that system. Bringing in the likes of Wroe, Mousinho, King etc would weaken the team, that's why they aren't playing right now, but everyone in the squad is capable of and will play their part this season.

From the sounds of things Nicholson is an attacking full back, so he should fit in well and SCS is only at Burton until Christmas, if someone needs to be brought in they will be and if Grayson needs financial backing in January I believe the money will be there to get us over the line.

There's 4 players out on loan right now, Jeff seems to be on the way out, but Ben Davies will return in January, early if need be and 6 months of regular football at York will have done him the world of good, so he will be able to slot in at centre half if need be. SCS could well go in January if we bring someone in and Cummins will be back then after getting his first proper run of games in professional football and at any level for 2 years, so hopefully if needed we will see the best of him if we haven't seen it yet.
 
Everyone's getting too caught up in the 3-5-2/3-4-1-2 we are playing, we don't have to stick with it all season. If changes need to be made to the system, they will be made.

Buchanan can play left wing back, the way we play, without the ball, Laird drops into full back and the centre halves shift across, with Clarke effectively moving to full back, so he will fit in easily to that system. Bringing in the likes of Wroe, Mousinho, King etc would weaken the team, that's why they aren't playing right now, but everyone in the squad is capable of and will play their part this season.

From the sounds of things Nicholson is an attacking full back, so he should fit in well and SCS is only at Burton until Christmas, if someone needs to be brought in they will be and if Grayson needs financial backing in January I believe the money will be there to get us over the line.

There's 4 players out on loan right now, Jeff seems to be on the way out, but Ben Davies will return in January, early if need be and 6 months of regular football at York will have done him the world of good, so he will be able to slot in at centre half if need be. SCS could well go in January if we bring someone in and Cummins will be back then after getting his first proper run of games in professional football and at any level for 2 years, so hopefully if needed we will see the best of him if we haven't seen it yet.

It's the formation that has changed us from drawing all our games to winning all of our games.

When we went 2-0 up Laird dropped back as did Hunphrey. So what you are saying is Buchanan can play in a 4 man defence. That's the point people make. He hasn't got the attacking threat. I just couldn't see Buchanan threading the balls through in an advanced position like Laird did to set up Davies goal and cause the own goal.

I might be wrong but wasn't Cummins even struggling to get a game at Rochdale
 
I think it comes down to understanding who our key players are and how easily they can be replaced.

To me, they are Laird, who is almost the ideal wing back in terms of his style of play, Davies, who's general quality and vision links our attacking play together and Rudd. I think Laird could be replaced in the short term by Holmes but a longer term replacement would be needed ideally. Obviously we have Stcukmann also to replace Rudd although he seems to be one who does better off a run of games.

Davies is pretty much a one-off in League 1 terms. There probably isn't a player in this league, and maybe even the league above, who could fulfill his role as well as he can. Losing him would necessarily lead to a change of formation/style of play. Since its working at the moment its best not thought about...
 
Back
Top