Skip to main content

Striker values?

Striker values?

Joined
Jun 8, 2004
Messages
9,893
Location
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Lookman, Charlton Athletic, aged 19, 7 goals in League One in 25 games, 11m to Everton.
England u/19 international, but I don't mind admitting I had never heard of him and wonder how many on here had?

So what value would we put on:

Robinson..........21, 6 goals in approx 28 league appearances? (often played as a wide player).

Hugill...............24, 6 goals in approx 27 league appearances? (limited skill but 100% effort type player).

Johnson...........24, 4 goals in approx 28 league appearances? (from midfield but possible defensive doubts)

I realise that it is not just goals that determine price tags, and know nothing about Lookman, maybe he has Ronaldo tendencies, but Robinson does have versatility, and Johnson good skill and creativity.

I don't care how good Lookman is, at 19, and with only a half season in the Championship last season and same in League One this season, 11m has to be a gamble.

That is the big problem in football today, big clubs can 'gamble' 11m, clubs like PNE may take the best part of 2 years to bring that through the turnstiles.
 
Last edited:
For me, currently, I think Johnson is our main asset. We have other good players, Cunningham is probably my favourite (if that's allowed at my age!) and Pearson is up there and still improving but right now if someone wanted to come and take a player from us who is only going to get better and better and better it would be Johnson. His potential is huge and I would be gutted if he left.
 
I'd heard of Lookman, he burst onto the scene last season with 2 goals at Brighton last season if I remember correctly. £11m is the reported fee, but I've seen elsewhere that it's £7.5m with the potential to reach £10m with add-ons - either way it's good business for Charlton, and the whole thing can only help their finances and get them back out of that league where they don't belong.

Johnson for me out of those 3 would be the most expensive. He has very little defensive capabilites but a hell of a left foot and a knack of scoring goals. To me, he's like our Ozil - defensive quality just isn't what he brings to the team. When we got promoted he had a free role with 6 defensive outfield players behind him and that's when he looked at his best. In recent times, particularly when Gallagher was playing in a regista role in our wingback formation, he performed so badly because he isn't suited to doing the leg-work for someone else. Johnson is not the player you fit in the team, he's the player you fit the team around, and there aren't many players like that.

Robinson is probably the next most valuable - he has pace, likes being direct and has a great attitude towards the game. He is a huge contrast to some of the wingers who might have had more ability but were less effective because of their lack of application - Monakana for example. I couldn't put a price on either of these two because it would be very much be based on form and things that they haven't done yet.

Hugill - as is well-noted on here - is still raw and perhaps not as skilled as others, which isn't exactly inspiring at the age of 24. But he still is our joint-top scorer in all competitions, to his credit he does get into the positions to miss them, which shows some intelligence is there, and does all the running he can. I'd say whatever price Omar Bogle goes for from Grimsby, we can expect a few hundred grand more for Hugill.

IMO Pearson, whilst he's not a striker, is going to be a multi-million pound signing in the next couple of years, he's been playing recently like he's far above this level. But frankly, I wouldn't want us to sell any of the younger talent from this squad, and equally they shouldn't be in a rush to leave yet - they have more to offer the team and we, as a club, have a lot more to offer them too.
 
Last edited:
For me, currently, I think Johnson is our main asset. We have other good players, Cunningham is probably my favourite (if that's allowed at my age!) and Pearson is up there and still improving but right now if someone wanted to come and take a player from us who is only going to get better and better and better it would be Johnson. His potential is huge and I would be gutted if he left.

It shows the value of signing young players who don't quite make the grade at Premiership clubs.

Pearson from Man Utd, Robinson and Johnson from Villa (when Villa were there).

Those three along with several others in our squad have developed their skills at top clubs and continue to do so under our good coaching set up.
 
The reason Lookman has gone for so much is because he's absolutely rapid. Robinson is quite quick but nowhere near as fast as Lookman, that's what they look for.
 
Didn't lookman play against us at deepdale last season? Lightning quick but not much else if it was him.
 
Robinson £17 million
Johnson £12 million
Hugill £24 million ( although unproven)

I am not sure that a striker who has not scored since the 5th November has a great value in the Transfer market. North End have 14 goals since Hugill last scored.
 
I agree Johnson is probably our most valuable asset - a midfielder who can score goals is usually highly sought after. Robinson- no where near a million quid yet. Pearson - priceless to us of course, but possibly at the moment near a million due to his lack of experience but I'm sure if we sold him, he would get moved on again to another club for massive money - we would defo have to insist on a 25 percent sell on fee if we sold him. Look what mk dons would get if dele Alli went to Real Madrid or PSG for 45 million.
 
Hugill - 1m
Beckford - 250k
May - 1.5m
Doyle - 500k

We bought May for 800 thousand. He hasn't even scored a goal yet for the club and has had a shocking injury, so I'm not sure how his value has increased in your opinion, especially with only 18 months left on his deal too.

I'd be shocked if anyone paid a penny for Beckford too.

Personally I think our most valuable assets aren't strikers. Johnson and Pearson probably are.
 
Back
Top