Skip to main content

Strongest 11

Strongest 11

Liberation

Forum Patron
Joined
Jan 14, 2012
Messages
42,947
Location
Plungy
Prior to yesterdays game quite a number of posters ( including myself) stated that they felt that the lineup chosen against Stevenage was ( on paper at least) our strongest. Assuming there's a miracle and we have no injuries or loss of individuals form then what are others thoughts as regards our chances of promotion with that formation and starting 11 ?
 
The line up maximises our goal threat yet contains some strong and resolute defenders and a decent goalie.

A tasty recipe indeed.

We'll need to keep winning, not drawing, to keep pace with the likes of Posh.
 
Too early to say just enjoying each day as it comes and the pleasant Saturday evening feeling again and being able to read the Sundays with both eyes open , why spoil it with worry over what next year will bring .
 
We shouldn't get ahead of ourselves, we only beat Stevenage and there will be much tougher tests between now and the end of the season. The problem with this team is that we can't keep hold of the ball. Our short range passing is appalling, and nobody seems to have the confidence and/or ability to beat a man.

We were solid enough yesterday but the midfield still needs work, more of a tempo to our passing and better pressing when we haven't got the ball. I worry that we're going to get caught by the tinkering of formations and selections that the manager insists on doing, but for now we're just doing enough.
 
I'd still rather have Welsh instead of Keane but other than that I'd say yes we could push top 6 with that

Keanes too good to be dropped and they don't seem to be effective together so to my mind Welsh instead of Keane would mean Keane reverting to right back, the team reverting to a 4-4-2 ( with Laird at LB ) and the dropping of either Clarke, Wright or Hunts. Clarkes a Grayson man and Wrights too good so Hunts gets the heave ho..... And we lose our height ! Who'd be a football Manager eh? 🙂
 
Keanes too good to be dropped and they don't seem to be effective together so to my mind Welsh instead of Keane would mean Keane reverting to right back, the team reverting to a 4-4-2 ( with Laird at LB ) and the dropping of either Clarke, Wright or Hunts. Clarkes a Grayson man and Wrights too good so Hunts gets the heave ho..... And we lose our height ! Who'd be a football Manager eh? 🙂

Na I'd swop Keane for Welsh that would be my only change
 
Welsh is technically a better footballer. Keane has started the season well but Welsh has more discipline.

Not when he comes on from the bench he doesn't. He gives away daft free kicks left right and centre.So that would cement your argument about him starting.... But I still think Keanes the better player. 🙂
 
Not when he comes on from the bench he doesn't. He gives away daft free kicks left right and centre.So that would cement your argument about him starting.... But I still think Keanes the better player. 🙂

It ain't easy picking up the pace of play coming on for the last 10-20 mins but overall I think he'd win on top trumps. I feel he will be the main centre mid for the majority of the season
 
It ain't easy picking up the pace of play coming on for the last 10-20 mins but overall I think he'd win on top trumps. I feel he will be the main centre mid for the majority of the season

Fair enough.. But in which case Keane will be playing next to him/ the formation will change or Keane will be dropped.
 
Keane is better than Welsh in the defensive role. Both are pretty crap technically. The team with Keane in rather than Welsh is winning. Therefore it is currently our best option.
 
Keane is better than Welsh in the defensive role. Both are pretty crap technically. The team with Keane in rather than Welsh is winning. Therefore it is currently our best option.

Agreed I was told the same when I said play Laird instead of Buchanan when not conceding and was also told the same when said Holmes wasn't working behind the front two as needs to play on the wing. The thread is about the strongest XI not necessarily the change I'd make this minute. But the cream always rises to the top and I'm confident on this one to. Keane was moved to right wing back yesterday when Welsh came on which is how we should have gone the other night when Humphreys was not available
 
Agreed I was told the same when I said play Laird instead of Buchanan when not conceding and was also told the same when said Holmes wasn't working behind the front two as needs to play on the wing. The thread is about the strongest XI not necessarily the change I'd make this minute. But the cream always rises to the top and I'm confident on this one to. Keane was moved to right wing back yesterday when Welsh came on which is how we should have gone the other night when Humphreys was not available

I agree about how we should have used Keane the other night in Humphrey's absence. However, I simply don't see any reason why Welsh is rated so highly. He is honestly just a very average player who while doing nothing particularly wrong, doesn't do much that is good. I believe Keane is the better of the two.
 
Back
Top