Stuckers
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2005
- Messages
- 111,060
Second goal mmm sucked and it was partially his fault. I like him but that hurt tonight.
He was setting for a deflection off rooney, hence why it should have been offside.
- Joined
- Oct 30, 2011
- Messages
- 2,482
Second goal mmm sucked and it was partially his fault. I like him but that hurt tonight.
I think you are being harsh on him. He wasn't a weak link tonight. Thought he was strong, just not as brilliant as we'd like him to be.
He was setting for a deflection off rooney, hence why it should have been offside.
Agreed, and ask yourself this - if the boot was on the other foot and it was Garner blocking de Gea in identical fashion, do you think Dowd would have allowed the goal for PNE?
He was setting for a deflection off rooney, hence why it should have been offside.
That was the first goal wasn't it?
Should have been disallowed as well ! Fellaini shoved Tom Clarke over before he headed the ball at stuckers
Totally agree it was terrible keeping
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2005
- Messages
- 111,060
I'm on about second goal that we conceded
aye apologies, he really struggles to get down to low shots, the problem of his size.
Totally agree it was terrible keeping
He should be hung, drawn and quartered and then really be given a good going over.
The first one should've been disallowed, purely because Rooney was interfering with play in an offside position. Stuckmann prepared for the deflection only for Rooney to move at the last second.
There's no doubt he should've done better with the 2nd, but again did Phil Dowd not see the push?
The penalty... Well it was a blatant dive from Rooney, thus it was never a penalty. Whilst Stuckmann was reckless no contact was made. Rooney should count himself lucky.
Shouldn't dwell too much on Stuckmann's performance tonight as all three goals were dubious.
On another night with a competent referee we would've witnessed a totally different outcome.
There's no doubt he should've done better with the 2nd, but again did Phil Dowd not see the push?
The penalty... Well it was a blatant dive from Rooney, thus it was never a penalty. Whilst Stuckmann was reckless no contact was made. Rooney should count himself lucky.
Shouldn't dwell too much on Stuckmann's performance tonight as all three goals were dubious.
On another night with a competent referee we would've witnessed a totally different outcome.
I'm on about second goal that we conceded
Stuckers' fault? You are kidding aren't you?
No he deflected a shot on too their player to score from. He could of deflected away or bloody kept hold of x
Which game were you watching?
Fellaini's header from a yard out was textbook - downwards into Stuckmann's feet. What d'ya expect Stuckmann to do - trap it and flick it up into his arms.
Deflected a shot my arse.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
Which game were you watching?
Fellaini's header from a yard out was textbook - downwards into Stuckmann's feet. What d'ya expect Stuckmann to do - trap it and flick it up into his arms.
Deflected a shot my arse.
He should have held Fellaini's header and her was totally reckless for the third goal even though he didn't make contact.