Skip to main content

Stuckman, just some thoughts.

Stuckman, just some thoughts.

Joined
Oct 25, 2004
Messages
4,922
Bizarre this but just my thoughts, Stuckman is a massive frame of a guy, almost filling the centre of the goals ideal penalty stopping stature. Yet last night despite his 'heroics' I was concerned as he crouched so low and almost fell to his right at each penalty.
No movement, no arm waving and nowhere near 8 of the penalties. A definite change in his approach to Pens.
Harsh, but he also fluffed a simple looking catch and parried a tame shot for an Oldham goal. Such mistakes from Jones would have filled the boards.
 
Everyone is entitled to make a couple of mistakes, it seemed like Jones made way too many, and therefore cost us points, and because of that people have gotten onto Jones' back critising everything he does wrong, there was a time period where Stuckmann was out of favour with the fans (when we conceded 2 vs Burnley in the Capital 1 cup and when we lost to Oldham either last season or the season before and he got wrong footed). After the clean sheet vs Bristol and the penalty winning shot vs Oldham he has since come back into favour and the good which has has done massively outweighs his few mistakes.
 
I thought he was a little unlucky in that he got his hands to several of the pens but they were very well struck. His pen was superb too given the pressure.

On the two goals, I tend to share your view that he didn't do anything exceptional and that Jones would have been slated for the same. However, as we know from experience, once our supporters have a goalkeeping scapegoat in their sights, rationality and fairness tend to slide down the agenda.
 
You didn't state the piss poor defending yet again by us. Oldham hit us with pace whilst we just dollied the ball about slowly then when there is no one to pass to we just lump it up front as Tom Clarke did prior to their second goal. We are woeful at the back at times. How to beat Pne you will score just after gals time as we are slow to get going and we usually concede in the last 10.

We were lucky last night and nearly snatched a defeat from the jaws of victory.
 
Bizarre this but just my thoughts, Stuckman is a massive frame of a guy, almost filling the centre of the goals ideal penalty stopping stature. Yet last night despite his 'heroics' I was concerned as he crouched so low and almost fell to his right at each penalty.
No movement, no arm waving and nowhere near 8 of the penalties. A definite change in his approach to Pens.
Harsh, but he also fluffed a simple looking catch and parried a tame shot for an Oldham goal. Such mistakes from Jones would have filled the boards.
I think you missed the bit where Stuckmann saved one penalty and scored the winner.
 
Bizarre this but just my thoughts, Stuckman is a massive frame of a guy, almost filling the centre of the goals ideal penalty stopping stature. Yet last night despite his 'heroics' I was concerned as he crouched so low and almost fell to his right at each penalty.
No movement, no arm waving and nowhere near 8 of the penalties. A definite change in his approach to Pens.
Harsh, but he also fluffed a simple looking catch and parried a tame shot for an Oldham goal. Such mistakes from Jones would have filled the boards.

How good were the penalties? A decent penalty should not be saveable.
 
Bizarre this but just my thoughts, Stuckman is a massive frame of a guy, almost filling the centre of the goals ideal penalty stopping stature. Yet last night despite his 'heroics' I was concerned as he crouched so low and almost fell to his right at each penalty.
No movement, no arm waving and nowhere near 8 of the penalties.

The goal is 8 yards wide - the notion of a keeper filling the goal when he's stood on the line is bollocks unless he has a serious obesity problem. As for crouching - much better he does that and get the extra spring than jump about and get his weight distribution all wrong.

I think Stuckmann has saved more penalties in his time here than any of the other keeper in my 28 years of watching North End, so he can carry on doing what he's doing as far as I'm concerned.
 
Wasn't having a rant more an observation on this apparent change in style, possibly coaching. Never said he filled the goal but certainly the 'centre' of it when upright and standing tall. This crouched style was strange to see as he almost made himself look smaller.
On a similar note I suggested his overall performance was no better imo than Jones'. All that said For now I'd stick with Stuck, without going overboard. UTW.
 
Back
Top