Skip to main content

Stuckman or Johnstone

Stuckman or Johnstone

Joined
Jan 26, 2013
Messages
287


Should Stuckman keep his place ahead of Johnstone? No brainer for me, Stuckman every time. If that upsets Man U, then send Johnstone back.
 
Stucky has only conceded 12 goals in his 17 appearances this season - and managed 9 clean sheets.

The least the club could do is use some of the Man Utd money and offer him a one year extension til June 2016.

Very unlucky to find himself out of the team this coming Saturday.
 
Johnstone for me. Stuckmann is a decent keeper at this level. He's made some great saves, but he's also made some bad mistakes as well. Yesterdays goal, and build up to Walsall's 1st goal are recent examples. Stuckmann is also out of contract this Summer, and he may have given the club notice that he's going back to Germany. Think he's 34 now, so can't blame him.

Johnstone has yet to show top form yet. But he's young, highly rated, Doncaster fans think he should be playing in the Championship, and is a long term option. The club deserve some credit looking long term, rather than hoping for a quick fix.
 
Johnstone for me. Stuckman is far too slow at distributing the ball back out. We never counterattack because by the time he's decide who to throw it to the opposition have got back and are ready to defend.
 


Should Stuckman keep his place ahead of Johnstone? No brainer for me, Stuckman every time. If that upsets Man U, then send Johnstone back.

Stuckmann has to be applauded for his attitude. Dropped like a stone and out of the picture on a couple of occasions over recent seasons but has done really well when he's played. Personally I think Johnstone will play against Coventry. Although it is fitting that Stuckmann will play against United.
 
Stuckmann's positives:
-good shot stopper
-domineering and does not flap at corners
-commands the defence very well and seemingly gives them confidence

Stuckmann's negatives:
-immobile and slow
-kicking and provision is terrible
-makes the odd gaff of late (although we could excuse this down to his own confidence taking a dint after being dropped after 1 mistake)

comparing this (maybe unfairly) to Johnstone who i've only seen play live a couple of times, latest being crawley away, he doesnt seem to offer any positives over Stuckmann, other than he is more mobile.

Stuckmann needs a run and not to be dropped when he makes one mistake. We went on a defensively great run when we weren't chopping and changing.
 
Johnstone hasn't been brought in to warm the bench, however there's a very good case for same again for the team this weekend.
 
Back
Top