Skip to main content

Stuckmann Expects To Start

Stuckmann Expects To Start

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
After listening to the interview on PNE player, Stuckmann states that he expects to start most matches.

I personally would rather have Rudd in goal because the way he performed towards the end of the season was brilliant, but I think Stuckmann is a cracking keeper and character and am really torn between him and Rudd, but it seems Rudd edges it because of his under 21 pedigree.

Could Stuckmann become unhappy if he doesn't play.

Thoughts?
 
Stuckmann is a cracking keeper and character and am really torn between him and Rudd, but it seems Rudd edges it because of his under 21 pedigree.

He played 1 game for the U21's - 2 years ago. He was a back up player in the current U21's squad, who are generally regarded as the most useless bunch of players ever to leave these shores representing the 3 Lions. Hardly a sparking U21 pedigree.

I'm not having a go at the lad, or his ability, but people need to be realistic with their expectations of him. To say Rudd is the better keeper because he has played a game for England U21's is just as ludicrous as saying Stuckmann must be a better goalie because he's German.
 
He played 1 game for the U21's - 2 years ago. He was a back up player in the current U21's squad, who are generally regarded as the most useless bunch of players ever to leave these shores representing the 3 Lions. Hardly a sparking U21 pedigree.

I'm not having a go at the lad, or his ability, but people need to be realistic with their expectations of him. To say Rudd is the better keeper because he has played a game for England U21's is just as ludicrous as saying Stuckmann must be a better goalie because he's German.

Whilst you are right in what you say, 8 clean sheet in 14 games FOR US is enough to raise my expectations.

I quite like Stuckmann but he is nowhere near as good as Rudd imo. Stuckers is a good shot stopper, but quite often palms the ball out to someone following up to score. That is where Rudd is the better keeper. He is always aware of players around him, and if he pushes a ball away he often palms it away to safety.
 
I see nothing wrong with this whatsoever and would hope that everyone in the squad has the same attitude. Let's face it we've had plenty of players in recent times who didn't seem to give two shits whether they were in the side or not and were happy to pick up a wage for sitting on their arse or on the treatment table.
 
Whilst you are right in what you say, 8 clean sheet in 14 games FOR US is enough to raise my expectations.

This is the important point for me. When Rudd plays we often keep clean sheets and he was a big part of the side that was so strong defensively at the back end of last season.

The last 4 games of the season saw Rudd and Stuckmann alternate between the sticks from game to game. When Stuckmann played we conceded in both, when Rudd played we kept clean sheets in both. A coincidence? Maybe not but I think the stats show that when Rudd is selected, North End do better. Rudd is worth extra points over the season to us I reckon and it would be daft not to play him.

This doesn't make Stuckmann a bad keeper, far from it in fact and he may well be the best understudy in the division. I'm sure he will get playing time as well, the cup competitions aren't really priority so he may feature in all of these. Rudd may also get injured, be out of form etc.

The reality is we have 2 keepers and can only select 1. Someone has to sit on the bench!
 
Rudd is the better keeper for my money and of the 50-55 competititive games we play I expect Rudd to start in at least 36 of them ...injuries apart of course

Agreed.

I think Stuckers will be our JPT keeper, and had the league cup not been the lashers, that too.

However I'm delighted that Stuckers says he expects to be number one. This means he will push Rudd all the way and not planning on getting splinters up his arse like a certain Carlo Nash.
 
Last edited:
With no disrespect to Stuckmann who was a colossus for us when he first arrived my vote goes to Rudd whom I think is more athletic and a better all round keeper. That said it is always a good thing to have healthy competition for the gloves and I feel sure that Kell will bring out the best in both of them.
 
i'm happy that we appear to be a couple of additions/departures from having a squad were everyone is capable of competing for a place in the 1st XI, hopefully with such strong competition for places it will lead to great performances on the pitch because as SG showed when he first came into the club only injuries will force him change a team that is playing well.
 
I think Stucks will know that Rudd is number 1 at the moment, all hes doing here is trying to show us that if he is needed he is more than keen to be our number 1.
 
Back
Top