Skip to main content

Stuckmann found out?

Stuckmann found out?

Joined
Jul 24, 2009
Messages
5,436
I know this thread might seem 'knee-jerk' and upset a few of his fans, and don't get me wrong I've also been an advocate for Stuckmann returning to the team for a while and I was happy to see Jones dropped. And I don't want Jones returning by any means, but the question is, has Stuckkers been found out?

He's rarely been tested (apart from that effort vs Barnsley) but has always looked a bit rusty and slow off his line. Didn't look like he'd get anywhere near their free kick that hit the post in the first half, looked in no mans land when they put ball across the box in the first half that was cleared, his distribution throughout was terrible (never went past the half way line), his mistake that led to the free kick was horrendous, he should have done better for that free kick goal and was nowhere near getting close to their second goal. I just think that our clean sheets have been more down to a settle defence and lack of chances against, and being better at commanding the box and settling those defenders than Jones can't be a hard job. He's an average league one keeper and could be found out more as the games get tougher. To truly compete at the top, we need the best in every position, and unlike last season with Rudd, I don't feel he's anywhere near the best in the league (Walsall's keeper proved that).

On the topic of Rudd, why don't we try and get him back now they have no manager? I'm sure he'd love to be playing games again, especially when they don't even play him against us in the cup!
 
Last edited:
Knee jerk? Surely?

Just as much as knee jerk as the people calling him the 'messiah'... what has he done of particular greatness other than that Hourihane save? Just seems so slow to get down to chances. A decent striker like Garner would have a field day against him, I reckon.
 
I know this thread might seem 'knee-jerk' and upset a few of his fans, and don't get me wrong I've also been an advocate for Stuckmann returning to the team for a while and I was happy to see Jones dropped. And I don't want Jones returning by any means, but the question is, has Stuckkers been found out?

He's rarely been tested (apart from that effort vs Barnsley) but has always looked a bit rusty and slow off his line. Didn't look like he'd get anywhere near their free kick that hit the post in the first half, looked in no mans land when they put ball across the box in the first half that was cleared, his distribution throughout was terrible (never went past the half way line), his mistake that led to the free kick was horrendous, he should have done better for that free kick goal and was nowhere near getting close to their second goal. I just think that our clean sheets have been more down to a settle defence and lack of chances against, and being better at commanding the box and settling those defenders than Jones can't be a hard job. He's an average league one keeper and could be found out more as the games get tougher. To truly compete at the top, we need the best in every position, and unlike last season with Rudd, I don't feel he's anywhere near the best in the league (Walsall's keeper proved that).

On the topic of Rudd, why don't we try and get him back now they have no manager? I'm sure he'd love to be playing games again, especially when they don't even play him against us in the cup!

no the Free Kick was bad set piece defending, No one on the line, everyone in a wall together with a free kick that close was suicidal and we paid the price. Our Strikers couldn't strike a match tonight. Bad Tactics, Bad defending, Seriously shocking finishing. I don't like Davies, but the game changed when he went off and when Ebanks came on it was game over, because we never got the ball forward or held on to it long enough. Don't blame the Keeper.
 
His first sub-par game of the season and i'm glad it was in the JPT.

I don't even think he was that poor. Not compared to our front two anyway.
 
no the Free Kick was bad set piece defending, No one on the line, everyone in a wall together with a free kick that close was suicidal and we paid the price. Our Strikers couldn't strike a match tonight. Bad Tactics, Bad defending, Seriously shocking finishing. I don't like Davies, but the game changed when he went off and when Ebanks came on it was game over, because we never got the ball forward or held on to it long enough. Don't blame the Keeper.
Yeah not denying the rest of the team was shite. I just thought I'd highlight something that had gone unnoticed. Stuckmann looks shaky under pressure, and this was the first game he's been under any pressure. A little bit of worry considering we're heading into a four horse promotion race, and perhaps 3 pressure games in the play offs (yet again)...
 
Stucky has been great since his recall and deserves his place but he could have done far better with both goals imo.
 
I also hope this game finally settles who's better out of Laird and Buchanan. Buchanan hands down IMO.
 
To truly compete at the top, we need the best in every position, and unlike last season with Rudd, I don't feel he's anywhere near the best in the league (Walsall's keeper proved that).

On the topic of Rudd, why don't we try and get him back now they have no manager? I'm sure he'd love to be playing games again, especially when they don't even play him against us in the cup!
Didn't Rudd make two bad mistakes against Peterborough last season which resulted in 2 goals to them?

At the moment Norwich wouldn't let Rudd go anywhere until a) Bunn is fully fit after being out for so long injured and b) until they have named a new manager and see what he wants to do. Also, would it be fair on Stucks to drop him for Rudd at this moment in time, he has only made 1 bad mistake tonight I don't think he could do much with the 2nd goal
 
Stuckmann is a good keeper at this level, Jones would have let in every shot Stuckmann did tonight... Plus every single corner they had would have been a goal.
 
Didn't Rudd make two bad mistakes against Peterborough last season which resulted in 2 goals to them?

At the moment Norwich wouldn't let Rudd go anywhere until a) Bunn is fully fit after being out for so long injured and b) until they have named a new manager and see what he wants to do. Also, would it be fair on Stucks to drop him for Rudd at this moment in time, he has only made 1 bad mistake tonight I don't think he could do much with the 2nd goal
Mistakes are one thing, and happen in football. It's just that he looks shaky and very slow for a keeper. Rudd was astute, confident and admittedly still learning (he can only get better). And I wouldn't drop him as such but give him more competition than Jones, and if his form continues to drop, replace him with whoever we got to replace Jones.
 
Back
Top