Skip to main content

Stump Up

Stump Up

I don't know any of the answers, but if he were available for a similar fee to that which we got Johnson for, it's a no-brainer.

If they rate him higher (which it would seem Lambert did, to an extent - who know's about Sherwood), then he may not be attainable, and if he were could cost anything up to a million. Which, clearly, we won't spend.
 
1 - If dj was 50k, can't realistically see it being more than £500k
2 - Yes, unless they go down
3 - Yes, if we go up
 
1. With dj 50k, then 40k would be a good first offer 😉. Not seen enough of him (saw Hatrick, and a couple of other games including brief appearance with Utd) . I wouldn't want to break the bank max £250k .
3. Yes
 
1. Whatever it took within reason (I.e. Not millions at this stage of his career)
2. I think so
3. Definitely
 
I reckon a few hundred grand at most. Probably with some add ons for any future sale by us. I don't think he's a very serious option for villa in the prem.

Having said that, if they go down it could all change.
 
1) £150k plus Add On's.

2) Yes, they require proven, not gambles. Grealish is better than Robbo and he is only in the 18 as Sub.

3) No brainer, of course. He can only improve which adds value - see Trader Concept TM Voldemort.
 
Difficult to say whether they would let him go or not in the summer. My guess is Sherwood will want to call everyone back in so he can properly evaluate their squad.

However, I would like us to sign him definitely.

And I have no idea what we would spend on him tbh.
 
3 Questions

1. How much do you think we would have to pay to sign Callum Robinson permanently?

2. Would Villa let him go?

3. Would you stump up the cash for him from question 1?



When are you going to " stump up " the patron fiver ?

Edit....... I'd pay the same for him as we did for Johnson.
 
We should really look to sign him either way. Brownhill, Browne , DJ, Bailey Wright. for the first time in a while we have a team with kids who have potential with a sell on value. Something PNE have missed since we were relegated.
 
This forum never ceases to amaze me!

Someone starts a 'thread' with a totally random suggestion and there is a rush of people who eagerly dive in volunteering their barmy and equally random responses which have no base in knowledge or understanding.
 
This forum never ceases to amaze me!

Someone starts a 'thread' with a totally random suggestion and there is a rush of people who eagerly dive in volunteering their barmy and equally random responses which have no base in knowledge or understanding.

That's what forums do....... So what do you reckon?.. How much should we pay( if anything) ?


Addition: And I notice that you make plenty of comments but don't stump up the 5 nicker either..Hypocrisy at it's finest.
 
This forum never ceases to amaze me!

Someone starts a 'thread' with a totally random suggestion and there is a rush of people who eagerly dive in volunteering their barmy and equally random responses which have no base in knowledge or understanding.

Questions were asked, answers were given.

What's your problem with this?
 
Forums and opinions eh? That's what forums are for. They're essentially debating societies. At one time before the inter web, you could only debate in the pub. This platform of an exchange of ideas, views and opinions is fantastic and even tho at times I feel like punching some lights out, I wouldn't have it any other way.
 
Like any market, it depends on what other buyers there are in the market. Villa might be willing to accept 250K... but if Bristol City go and offer 500K then it's going to cost us at least that much.
 
This forum never ceases to amaze me!

Someone starts a 'thread' with a totally random suggestion and there is a rush of people who eagerly dive in volunteering their barmy and equally random responses which have no base in knowledge or understanding.


To be fair Ron started a thread at weekend taking everyone to task for wanting Grayson out and was shown to him he had wanted Grayson out too , its things like that i guess that make people not know if its just another Ron wind up thread .
 
To be fair Ron started a thread at weekend taking everyone to task for wanting Grayson out and was shown to him he had wanted Grayson out too , its things like that i guess that make people not know if its just another Ron wind up thread .

I don't think Ron sets out to wind people up.

He just, as is human nature from time to time, contradicts himself, a fault that everyone on here is guilty of.
 
I don't think Ron sets out to wind people up.

He just, as is human nature from time to time, contradicts himself, a fault that everyone on here is guilty of.


Couldn't agree more JD but it was just a couple of days ago so i think people can be forgiven for not taking him serious at times
 
Back
Top