Skip to main content

Subs

Subs

Joined
May 30, 2014
Messages
4,821
Why the fuck does Grayson make poor substitutions? Tonight he takes Robinson off who sounded our best player. Then waits til 7 minutes to go to bring Davies and Blake on.
A) bring ineffective players off (Gallagher Johnson) not players having a good game.
B give the subs at least 20 mins to affect a game or don't bother.
 
to me at 2-1 up that's when you bring Davies on to keep things calm and keep hold of the ball. But hey I'm not a manager, but I don't think we have utilized him enough lately
 
Kilkenny worked wonders against Bradford, he should have been brought on for Welsh and Davies for the very ineffective Beckford.

All said in hindsight which some PNE fans think SG should possess.

He shouldn't possess hindsight, but he's paid to make important decisions and at the moment he's not quite getting them right, hence 3 draws on the spin.

Anyone could become a manager and just say afterwards they needed hindsight!
 
He shouldn't possess hindsight, but he's paid to make important decisions and at the moment he's not quite getting them right, hence 3 draws on the spin.

Anyone could become a manager and just say afterwards they needed hindsight!

Unfortunately the man is not and never will be perfect.

As long as he is not perfect some PNE fans will find something to moan at him about.
 
Kilkenny worked wonders against Bradford, he should have been brought on for Welsh and Davies for the very ineffective Beckford.

All said in hindsight which some PNE fans think SG should possess.
Hindsight he's the fuckin manager. Surely he can work out the best way to play against 10 men. He's our manager and deserves kudos when he's right but criticism when he's wrong. In my opinion the team he has is the strongest in the division yet it's his tactics are costing us not the teams ability.
 
Unfortunately the man is not and never will be perfect.

As long as he is not perfect some PNE fans will find something to moan at him about.

But you've just stated he should have brought Kilkenny on yourself - am I allowed to say the same or would it be classed as moaning if someone else does it?

Robinson was playing well and leading their full back a merry dance, I'm honestly struggling to remember anything positive Humphrey did. It's all right talking about hindsight but Kilkenny on was totally the obvious and correct change - keep the ball and keep the 10 men moving.
 
But you've just stated he should have brought Kilkenny on yourself - am I allowed to say the same or would it be classed as moaning if someone else does it?

Robinson was playing well and leading their full back a merry dance, I'm honestly struggling to remember anything positive Humphrey did. It's all right talking about hindsight but Kilkenny on was totally the obvious and correct change - keep the ball and keep the 10 men moving.

You can say the same, I'm saying he should have brought Kilkenny on but I am saying that in hindsight and I am not going to use it as a weapon to beat the man because I know he isn't going to get every game right.

He will be ostracised for his substitutions in this game and it will be constantly used against him, but its very quickly forgotten how his ambitious halftime subs against Bradford won us the games 3-0. (Bet someone says they weren't ambitious).

I just feel some PNE fans and posters complain then get there own way, then move onto the next complaint and then get their own way and then move onto the next complaint.

Humphrey for me nullified the threat of there winger that was really growing into the game.

Is no one going to mention the factor which is out of Graysons control, the fucking awful referee?
 
You can say the same, I'm saying he should have brought Kilkenny on but I am saying that in hindsight and I am not going to use it as a weapon to beat the man because I know he isn't going to get every game right.

He will be ostracised for his substitutions in this game and it will be constantly used against him, but its very quickly forgotten how his ambitious halftime subs against Bradford won us the games 3-0. (Bet someone says they weren't ambitious).

I just feel some PNE fans and posters complain then get there own way, then move onto the next complaint and then get their own way and then move onto the next complaint.

Humphrey for me nullified the threat of there winger that was really growing into the game.

Is no one going to mention the factor which is out of Graysons control, the fucking awful referee?

Humphrey was brought on to stop their 20 but that was soon nullified because he swapped sides! Grayson has obviously got a fair bit right over the last few months but he got tonight wrong.

I would suggest trying to stop one of the opposition's players instead of going for it when you're playing ten men is a little negative.

Out of interest, what did the referee do particularly wrong tonight?
 
Humphrey was brought on to stop their 20 but that was soon nullified because he swapped sides! Grayson has obviously got a fair bit right over the last few months but he got tonight wrong.

I would suggest trying to stop one of the opposition's players instead of going for it when you're playing ten men is a little negative.

Out of interest, what did the referee do particularly wrong tonight?

3 fouls that were not fouls leading up to their penalty.

Constantly giving everything there way, 50's 50's and not giving fouls against Garner got ridiculous at times.

For me as well the 1st pen was not a pen because the ball was about 2 metres over Pope, he was never getting to it.

You have to adapt to different situations and players during a football game that is management 101, there player was getting time and space and had 2 shots to get his eye in and your telling me that we don't try and stop that?
 
3 fouls that were not fouls leading up to their penalty.

Constantly giving everything there way, 50's 50's and not giving fouls against Garner got ridiculous at times.

For me as well the 1st pen was not a pen because the ball was about 2 metres over Pope, he was never getting to it.

You have to adapt to different situations and players during a football game that is management 101, there player was getting time and space and had 2 shots to get his eye in and your telling me that we don't try and stop that?

I honestly didn't think the referee got much wrong but we all see decisions differently. I do think the penalty was correct though - he wouldn't have got the ball but that is totally irrelevant. The ball was in play and Clarke ridiculously fouled him.

My main gripe at the time about the substitution to be honest wasn't Humphrey coming on (although I would have still brought Kilkenny on) it was taking Robinson off - unless of course there was a knock. You can't argue with the logic of trying to stop a player who is looking dangerous but arguably it would have been better to try and make us more dangerous rather than less dangerous. Humphrey didn't stop their 20 as he changed sides and again contributed nothing himself going forward.

Anyway, three games to go and nine points needed at this stage. It's in our hands and I'm actually still confident - I must be mad!
 
Their first penalty looked soft to me. Not bringing on Kilkenny, after the job he did at Bradford, was baffling tonight.
 
Their first penalty looked soft to me. Not bringing on Kilkenny, after the job he did at Bradford, was baffling tonight.

Just seen it on Sky - not changed my view from 9:00 or whenever it was, still the right decision.

Wish I hadn't just watched it though, its wound me up all over again 🙂
 
I honestly didn't think the referee got much wrong but we all see decisions differently. I do think the penalty was correct though - he wouldn't have got the ball but that is totally irrelevant. The ball was in play and Clarke ridiculously fouled him.

My main gripe at the time about the substitution to be honest wasn't Humphrey coming on (although I would have still brought Kilkenny on) it was taking Robinson off - unless of course there was a knock. You can't argue with the logic of trying to stop a player who is looking dangerous but arguably it would have been better to try and make us more dangerous rather than less dangerous. Humphrey didn't stop their 20 as he changed sides and again contributed nothing himself going forward.

Anyway, three games to go and nine points needed at this stage. It's in our hands and I'm actually still confident - I must be mad!

I am also still confident, Notts County is a massive game now.
 
Back
Top