Skip to main content

Supporters Groups.

Supporters Groups.

Joined
Apr 27, 2006
Messages
17,335
Location
Lurking in the shadows
Got to thinking after recent events just what is the role of the supporters groups at North End in the current climate.

Essentially the groups only represent their members and probably only a majority of those at that - however if they don't demand answers from the club when times are tough who does? Both PNESR and PSG are most certainly not pressure groups and both have done great work both currently and in the past raising money for the club and for various charities. The problem you have is that they are damned if they do call for action (people saying you dont represent me) and they are damned if they don`t (why dont PSG call a meeting etc)

Recently both Groups came together and presented the club with a letter asking for Westley to be removed with immediate effect and for further clatification on both Ridsdales position, the poor communication from the club and for a definitive statement from TH on how he sees the future. Now I'm sure it wasn't their letter alone that got Westley the boot but it did confirm what the huge majority of fans thought and seven days later he was gone.

PNESR had a meeting with Ridsdale yesterday and we await the outcome - PSG chose not to attend and in fact they had asked me to go with them but I declined on the grounds that it would probably be a divide and rule meeting and that statements to the masses were the way forward and not small meetings with Supporters Groups committees.

On reflection though we ask for better communication from the club and then dont attend meetings......make your own mind up !!!!

However my real point is what do the PNE-Online population think is the role of the Supporters Groups and if there was, say, a monthly get together with club representatives should this forum be involved...or does it not represent anybody?

I have a real open mind on this one but would be very interested in posters views on a subject that often rears its ugly head particularly in times of crisis.
 
Last edited:
When CAST (Club and supporters together) first came about it worked a treat.

We had such things as the loud and proud campaign which tied in with the first gentry event.Many other things also worked a treat, we had monthly meetings too.

However certain people at the football club decided that it should all be about raising funds for the club. It was also worth noting that there was many other active groups at the time too. PNEYSC, North Lancs, Official, and PNE Online also attended meetings.

To be fair at the time the club where far more open than they are now, I guess being a plc helped in that case.

It's a difficult question to answer. The only thing I will say is that in my view independence is very important, something we get slammed for if we are seen doing too many things with the club.
 
Was PSG not formed to be a pressure group ?

How many different supporters groups are there at present ?

Nope.

However the chairman at the beginning was heading in that direction. However since I have been on the committee which is coming up to 12 years we never have been.

That said I would like to think we have commented that way when required.

We were very keen at looking into a PNE trust separate to the supporters groups but for many reasons that just never tool off.

Also whilst I remember there was also NEST (North End Supporters together) which kind if faded away rather quickly.This again was with the aim of a trust I think.
 
Last edited:
Maybe pne-online should be a group as its a far bigger cross representation , select a committee of 12 good folk and true to form the committee . With as many members as we have could the club ignore us ? .
 
CAST was great as it had a cross-section of supporters' views, however would the club now it is under a private ownership be interested in re-forming it?

The Official Supporters Club had two members last time I heard.
PSG has a cross-section of members but not sure on figures of how many people it represents at present?
PNE SR is looking to be a more opinionated upcoming group.
A PNE-Online 'Club/Group' - for the paid members of the forum?

An umbrella organisation with an organised committee to voice the opinion of the 'average supporter' would be great, working independent of the club but of the same structure of the old CAST initiative.
 
The major supporters groups do tremendous work. People like the OP I take my hat off to. Without the likes of yourself there would be no PNE.

However, we cannot let Ridsdale and Hemmings off the hook simply because they have moved an unpopular manager on. The lack of engagement with the fans is quite simply intolerable. The fans are crying out a for a viable club to back, just look at the reaction at full time from the stands yesterday. You'd have thought we'd just booked a place at Wembley. We need ongoing communication and a clear plan for the future. The fans then need to be told exactly what is going on at all times, like under the golden Mr Gray era.
 
The major supporters groups do tremendous work.

However, we cannot let Ridsdale and Hemmings off the hook simply because they have moved an unpopular manager on. The lack of engagement with the fans is quite simply intolerable. The fans are crying out a for a viable club to back, just look at the reaction at full time from the stands yesterday. You'd have thought we'd just booked a place at Wembley. We need ongoing communication and a clear plan for the future. The fans then need to be told exactly what is going on at all times, like under the golden Mr Gray era.

Excellent post
 
The major supporters groups do tremendous work. People like the OP I take my hat off to. Without the likes of yourself there would be no PNE.

However, we cannot let Ridsdale and Hemmings off the hook simply because they have moved an unpopular manager on. The lack of engagement with the fans is quite simply intolerable. The fans are crying out a for a viable club to back, just look at the reaction at full time from the stands yesterday. You'd have thought we'd just booked a place at Wembley. We need ongoing communication and a clear plan for the future. The fans then need to be told exactly what is going on at all times, like under the golden Mr Gray era.

Correct, and something I've said myself since Westley was sacked.

I feel that PSG made the right decision in not meeting with Ridsdale, it's a pity that the other supporters' group mentioned (not sure who they are) haven't reported back as yet - it is to be hoped that they didn't buy Ridsdale's flannel hook, line and sinker but unfortunately this is what tends to happen in meetings.
 
If you used pne-onlne as a voice you could call them full members and affiliate members , to be able to approach the club and say we speak for 2000+ members would be quite a thing , also when there are queries you can run poles to decide the outcome .
 
Correct, and something I've said myself since Westley was sacked.

I feel that PSG made the right decision in not meeting with Ridsdale, it's a pity that the other supporters' group mentioned (not sure who they are) haven't reported back as yet - it is to be hoped that they didn't buy Ridsdale's flannel hook, line and sinker but unfortunately this is what tends to happen in meetings.

You mean like the one you went to with Degsy ?😉
 
So a letter was sent to the club from both PSG and PNESR asking for a meeting with the club and when the club responded and said said yes PSG did not attend.

Have I got this right or have I read this thread wrong?
 
So a letter was sent to the club from both PSG and PNESR asking for a meeting with the club and when the club responded and said said yes PSG did not attend.

Have I got this right or have I read this thread wrong?

PSG wanted the club to communicate with the supporters which Peter Ridsdale did with the LEP and radio Lancashire interviews.

However the main concern for us was the position of Graham Westley.

He has since been removed.

In our opinion we would like the club to speak to the fans as a whole and not to four or five us in a private meeting.

The South Ribble people decided they wished to see PR privately which is their choice.

As Danny as already alluded to not much ever comes from these meetings with many things often said too stay "between us" etc.

It is worth noting that PSG made public the offer from Peter Ridsdale and the vast majority of people who commented advised against any private meeting at this point.
 
ae5d4c1b-084d-4243-93d8-c65e7290fab5.gif
 
PSG wanted the club to communicate with the supporters which Peter Ridsdale did with the LEP and radio Lancashire interviews.

However the main concern for us was the position of Graham Westley.

He has since been removed.

In our opinion we would like the club to speak to the fans as a whole and not to four or five us in a private meeting.

The South Ribble people decided they wished to see PR privately which is their choice.

As Danny as already alluded to not much ever comes from these meetings with many things often said too stay "between us" etc.

It is worth noting that PSG made public the offer from Peter Ridsdale and the vast majority of people who commented advised against any private meeting at this point.

All very reasonable points. The pressure must stay on the owner and Board though. This situation needs a real momentum from the fans to drive us on. Having considered it in the last couple of days, Hemmings does seem to want success for the club, else why has he kept removing unsuccessful managers without giving them more than a year? As a none football man though, what he doesn't seem to grasp is that success requires at least some investment. We can't do things on a ridiculously short shoestring and expect success. And we can't keep changing manager every year and expect success.

What's the plan? Give us something we can buy into?
 
If you used pne-onlne as a voice you could call them full members and affiliate members , to be able to approach the club and say we speak for 2000+ members would be quite a thing , also when there are queries you can run poles to decide the outcome .




Glad i took the time to reply now .
 
The major supporters groups do tremendous work. People like the OP I take my hat off to. Without the likes of yourself there would be no PNE.

However, we cannot let Ridsdale and Hemmings off the hook simply because they have moved an unpopular manager on. The lack of engagement with the fans is quite simply intolerable. The fans are crying out a for a viable club to back, just look at the reaction at full time from the stands yesterday. You'd have thought we'd just booked a place at Wembley. We need ongoing communication and a clear plan for the future. The fans then need to be told exactly what is going on at all times, like under the golden Mr Gray era.

Spot on.

However, a club in private ownership isn't likely to welcome any scrutiny from supporters groups. Therefore, if any headway is to be made, the club need to be shown that it’s in everyone’s best interest for the groups to have a more hands on role. For this to be successful, the groups will need to show that there are no splits and they speak as one voice. It is also important to show that they have the support of the vast majority of fans. We are fortunate to have the individuals who run the groups giving up their free time to liaise with the club. Support them, the more members the groups have the more powerful their message will be heard. The club will have to listen. It isn’t likely to be easy getting a toe in the door, but everyone can play their part by joining one of the groups.
 
Back
Top