Skip to main content

Supporters Groups.

Supporters Groups.

The thing I don't understand is people are quick enough to say this forum, with thousands of members, doesn't represent the views of PNE fans. They are however, willing to let what is essentially a travel club, with scores of members, represent the views of the fans.

Not belittling PSG, just presenting an oddity.
 
The thing I don't understand is people are quick enough to say this forum, with thousands of members, doesn't represent the views of PNE fans. They are however, willing to let what is essentially a travel club, with scores of members, represent the views of the fans.

Not belittling PSG, just presenting an oddity.
I agree with this. I cannot see any other place that represents a broader number of Northenders than this site. Actually there is nowhere that comes close.

BUT, good on the groups for rallying and adding to the pressure regards Westley and getting the outcome the vast majority was wishing for. Maybe there is room here for a section if we ever find ourselves with another crank at the helm.

Personally I applaud the supporters groups.
 
Got to thinking after recent events just what is the role of the supporters groups at North End in the current climate.

Essentially the groups only represent their members and probably only a majority of those at that - however if they don't demand answers from the club when times are tough who does? Both PNESR and PSG are most certainly not pressure groups and both have done great work both currently and in the past raising money for the club and for various charities. The problem you have is that they are damned if they do call for action (people saying you dont represent me) and they are damned if they don`t (why dont PSG call a meeting etc)

Constructive post.

I was critical of the proposals to boycott games, and questioned how representative of Preston supporters as a whole the Sunday morning meeting was. I felt that the two groups appeared as if they were representing all supporters, when they were not.

Rightly or wrongly I have tended to view the Supporters Club as a travel club, and as I now live in Rawtenstall, and work in Manchester, it is has not seemed very relevant to me.

if you want to make it representative of all supporters, advertise it as such, and hold some meetings on a Saturday before the game. Elect a committee that represents a broad spectrum of views, and including some people with experience of operating at, or negotiating at, board level.

You make some very good points about communication and I think it would be of benefit to the club to be able to hold a dialogue with a representative group of fans ( their customers).
 
Constructive post.

I was critical of the proposals to boycott games, and questioned how representative of Preston supporters as a whole the Sunday morning meeting was. I felt that the two groups appeared as if they were representing all supporters, when they were not.

Rightly or wrongly I have tended to view the Supporters Club as a travel club, and as I now live in Rawtenstall, and work in Manchester, it is has not seemed very relevant to me.

if you want to make it representative of all supporters, advertise it as such, and hold some meetings on a Saturday before the game. Elect a committee that represents a broad spectrum of views, and including some people with experience of operating at, or negotiating at, board level.


You make some very good points about communication and I think it would be of benefit to the club to be able to hold a dialogue with a representative group of fans ( their customers).

Last time this was attempted I think people got quite stroppy.
 
Last time this was attempted I think people got quite stroppy.

It's a lot of opinions to organise! Surely it's got to be better organising issues online rather than a handful of supporters in a pub?

Again no disrespect to any supporters group as they got it bang on regards Westley!
 
PSG wanted the club to communicate with the supporters which Peter Ridsdale did with the LEP and radio Lancashire interviews.

However the main concern for us was the position of Graham Westley.

He has since been removed.

In our opinion we would like the club to speak to the fans as a whole and not to four or five us in a private meeting.

The South Ribble people decided they wished to see PR privately which is their choice.

As Danny as already alluded to not much ever comes from these meetings with many things often said too stay "between us" etc.

It is worth noting that PSG made public the offer from Peter Ridsdale and the vast majority of people who commented advised against any private meeting at this point.

Correct decision by PSG too in my view.
 
Cant believe PSG didnt attend a meeting they requested?
Am I missing something?

The meeting was requested by the club for four or five PSG committee members is as i understand it. As budgierustler says these meetings are usually about divide and rule. The vast majority of members represented by PSG voted for the committee not to attend the meeting on their behalf. So that is why no attendance. What is the point of asking for members opinions if you intend to ignore what they want?
 
PSG wanted the club to communicate with the supporters which Peter Ridsdale did with the LEP and radio Lancashire interviews.

However the main concern for us was the position of Graham Westley.

He has since been removed.

In our opinion we would like the club to speak to the fans as a whole and not to four or five us in a private meeting.

The South Ribble people decided they wished to see PR privately which is their choice.

As Danny as already alluded to not much ever comes from these meetings with many things often said too stay "between us" etc.

It is worth noting that PSG made public the offer from Peter Ridsdale and the vast majority of people who commented advised against any private meeting at this point.

Sorry about my post but then what is the worth of the PSG . Hemmings was going to get rid of Westley anyway.
 
Sorry about my post but then what is the worth of the PSG . Hemmings was going to get rid of Westley anyway.

There seems to be plenty of people making snide digs at PSG. If you don't agree with something they've done then why not ask them to call a supporters' meeting to discuss it - or, why not form your own supporters' group and see if you can do better?
 
There seems to be plenty of people making snide digs at PSG. If you don't agree with something they've done then why not ask them to call a supporters' meeting to discuss it - or, why not form your own supporters' group and see if you can do better?

Spot On DP7

Personally I'm greatful that some people are prepared to stand up for the supporters which I'm sure can't be easy at times.

Didn't PSG start from the year 2000?

So to still be going now they must have been doing something right.
 
So can anyone update what was said between the Riddler and SRSC.
I just think if you have a 'chairman' willing to meet you it would have/should have been a good oppertunity to ask about plans , investment, his role, pricing etc etc but what do I know.
 
Got to thinking after recent events just what is the role of the supporters groups at North End in the current climate.

Essentially the groups only represent their members and probably only a majority of those at that - however if they don't demand answers from the club when times are tough who does? Both PNESR and PSG are most certainly not pressure groups and both have done great work both currently and in the past raising money for the club and for various charities. The problem you have is that they are damned if they do call for action (people saying you dont represent me) and they are damned if they don`t (why dont PSG call a meeting etc)

Recently both Groups came together and presented the club with a letter asking for Westley to be removed with immediate effect and for further clatification on both Ridsdales position, the poor communication from the club and for a definitive statement from TH on how he sees the future. Now I'm sure it wasn't their letter alone that got Westley the boot but it did confirm what the huge majority of fans thought and seven days later he was gone.

PNESR had a meeting with Ridsdale yesterday and we await the outcome - PSG chose not to attend and in fact they had asked me to go with them but I declined on the grounds that it would probably be a divide and rule meeting and that statements to the masses were the way forward and not small meetings with Supporters Groups committees.

On reflection though we ask for better communication from the club and then dont attend meetings......make your own mind up !!!!

However my real point is what do the PNE-Online population think is the role of the Supporters Groups and if there was, say, a monthly get together with club representatives should this forum be involved...or does it not represent anybody?

I have a real open mind on this one but would be very interested in posters views on a subject that often rears its ugly head particularly in times of crisis.

An odd post John given that I suggested the very same thing on two separate occasions recently and you responded by saying you thought the person in liaison with the club should be an independent member of the press?

The flaw with this forum is that, although there are a great many members, it is all about the 'inner circle' who all seem to know each other beyond the silly cyber names. The same is true of the 'supporters groups'

Why is there more than one? To answer my own question it is for no other reason than to allow more 'leaders' who want to be closer to the club than a fan has a right to be.

As demonstrated by the rather silly forum awards only certain people's views seem to have any weight on here and, as you have done here, the ideas of others are held in abeyance and then reintroduced by the inner circle as their own.
 
I like any form of group (excluding extremism) - it is a good way to discuss opinion and thoughts and hopefully as a group come to a consensus - I have a tendancy to write to PNE about matters that concern me, its always as an individual as i work away and am simply not around to attend groups such as John's but if I could I would - I cannot imagine the PNE management team paying as much attention to myself when they are faced with letters from the PSG which are the voice of many
I am not aware of an inner circle but maybe I am in it without knowing ?? or maybe black balled, either way I dont care, my time on here is spent debating, discussing, sharing opinion and hopefully having a laugh along the way - maybe its easy to forget that the PSG and PNESR share one word in common - supporters.
As for awards - I like them and just see them as a chuckle as long as the Budgie never ever wins again and Gordon Bennett gets comedian of the year
 
There seems to be plenty of people making snide digs at PSG. If you don't agree with something they've done then why not ask them to call a supporters' meeting to discuss it - or, why not form your own supporters' group and see if you can do better?

Im not digging at PSG or the south ribble supporters club, but lets face it sending a letter ultimately means nothing to the club and adds no real pressure to the situation.

One thing to consider is that the media stance on these things seems to be that the people who run/organise these things are cranks almost, and I think that impression filters through to other people, rightly or ( definitely more likely) wrongly. Probably driven by the odd high profile group that give the rest a bad name. These groups do a great job engaging fans with the club I think and should be a great platform for people to voice displeasure at the club in a constructive way.

I also think its a shame the attempts to get a supporters trust going failed here, because if you really want to affect change without affecting the club financially thats the way in the current climate IMO.
 
Back
Top