Skip to main content

Supporters Groups

Supporters Groups

Joined
Apr 27, 2006
Messages
17,335
Location
Lurking in the shadows
With the sad demise of PSG this week and the dormant PNESouth Ribble group I think it begs the question -

Are Supporters Groups vital to a club or are they a thing of the past?

Along with PSG and PNESR we have little from the North Lancs Group for quite some time although I think the Whites in Exile still do a POTY Trophy... I may be wrong.


I pose the question in light of the recent discussions around the club match pricing policy and Season Ticket prices amongst other things. A club without a Supporters Group or voice can pretty much do what it wants....if there is no interaction between Club and fans I believe apathy sets in and people just vote with their feet eventually

I believe a strong Supporters Group almost acts as an opposition to the Government if you like and should challenge on issues of the day in a constructive manner.

To be fair to North End the Club and the Supporters Groups (Particularly PSG) have worked well over the years but recently PSG have been little more than a travel club and so that link is lost somewhat.

For example...who will the club discuss next years Gentry Day with ? ......perhaps it will just be a poll on the website.

I certainly see a place for a strong Supporters Group but I fear it is an age thing and that some of our younger fans don`t quite see it that way.

I would be interested in peoples thoughts.
 
Supporters Groups

With the sad demise of PSG this week and the dormant PNESouth Ribble group I think it begs the question -

Are Supporters Groups vital to a club or are they a thing of the past?

Along with PSG and PNESR we have little from the North Lancs Group for quite some time although I think the Whites in Exile still do a POTY Trophy... I may be wrong.


I pose the question in light of the recent discussions around the club match pricing policy and Season Ticket prices amongst other things. A club without a Supporters Group or voice can pretty much do what it wants....if there is no interaction between Club and fans I believe apathy sets in and people just vote with their feet eventually

I believe a strong Supporters Group almost acts as an opposition to the Government if you like and should challenge on issues of the day in a constructive manner.

To be fair to North End the Club and the Supports Groups (Particularly PSG) have worked well over the years but recently PSG have been little more than a travel club and so that link is lost somewhat.

For example...who will the club discuss next years Gentry Day with ? ......perhaps it will just be a poll on the website.

I certainly see aplace for a strong Supporters Group but I fear it is an age thing and that some of our younger fans don`t quite see it that way.

I would be interested in peoples thoughts.

From my experience of attending a supporters club it felt like it was some older generation fans very set in their ways that weren't overly welcoming of new members and their new ideas.

But I totally agree the supports club is the union that backs the fans and supports discussion with the club and it's crucial to keep these in place where possible.

More people can now voice their opinion online across a host of media forums and this over time sees the demise of the meet up of like minded fans in a set venue.
 
With the sad demise of PSG this week and the dormant PNESouth Ribble group I think it begs the question -

Are Supporters Groups vital to a club or are they a thing of the past?

Along with PSG and PNESR we have little from the North Lancs Group for quite some time although I think the Whites in Exile still do a POTY Trophy... I may be wrong.


I pose the question in light of the recent discussions around the club match pricing policy and Season Ticket prices amongst other things. A club without a Supporters Group or voice can pretty much do what it wants....if there is no interaction between Club and fans I believe apathy sets in and people just vote with their feet eventually

I believe a strong Supporters Group almost acts as an opposition to the Government if you like and should challenge on issues of the day in a constructive manner.


To be fair to North End the Club and the Supporters Groups (Particularly PSG) have worked well over the years but recently PSG have been little more than a travel club and so that link is lost somewhat.

For example...who will the club discuss next years Gentry Day with ? ......perhaps it will just be a poll on the website.

I certainly see aplace for a strong Supporters Group but I fear it is an age thing and that some of our younger fans don`t quite see it that way.

I would be interested in peoples thoughts.

This is exactly what it is and that's life today. Folk just roll over and can't be arsed to protest or the like. Look at how many turn out to vote in elections.

In any case, how does the club listen to the fans? Does it listen to social media - I doubt it. Was there any real listening by the club at the fans' forum? Is there really a culture of fans being involved with clubs anymore, or are fans just consumers?
 
With the sad demise of PSG this week and the dormant PNESouth Ribble group I think it begs the question -

Are Supporters Groups vital to a club or are they a thing of the past?

Along with PSG and PNESR we have little from the North Lancs Group for quite some time although I think the Whites in Exile still do a POTY Trophy... I may be wrong.


I pose the question in light of the recent discussions around the club match pricing policy and Season Ticket prices amongst other things. A club without a Supporters Group or voice can pretty much do what it wants....if there is no interaction between Club and fans I believe apathy sets in and people just vote with their feet eventually

I believe a strong Supporters Group almost acts as an opposition to the Government if you like and should challenge on issues of the day in a constructive manner.

To be fair to North End the Club and the Supporters Groups (Particularly PSG) have worked well over the years but recently PSG have been little more than a travel club and so that link is lost somewhat.

For example...who will the club discuss next years Gentry Day with ? ......perhaps it will just be a poll on the website.

I certainly see a place for a strong Supporters Group but I fear it is an age thing and that some of our younger fans don`t quite see it that way.

I would be interested in peoples thoughts.


We don't see it that way because we don't know what happens with it. PSG do great things but there is no relationship between them and the fans, where are they promoting themselves with fans? Getting fan feedback? Getting fans involved in PSG. Whenever i've mentioned it I always get shot down the Older ones related to PSG who seem to show the younger ones no respect at all. In a, we're older, we've seen the club through rough times, we know what we're talking about, kind of way.

PSG seriously needed to "modernise" to have any chance of surviving. Besides JK i don't even know who was involved at the top of PSG. There is no meaningful communication between PSG and the fans really.
 
We don't see it that way because we don't know what happens with it. PSG do great things but there is no relationship between them and the fans, where are they promoting themselves with fans? Getting fan feedback? Getting fans involved in PSG. Whenever i've mentioned it I always get shot down the Older ones related to PSG who seem to show the younger ones no respect at all. In a, we're older, we've seen the club through rough times, we know what we're talking about, kind of way.

PSG seriously needed to "modernise" to have any chance of surviving. Besides JK i don't even know who was involved at the top of PSG. There is no meaningful communication between PSG and the fans really.

All those are very fair comments but it`s too late for PSG now. If you go to the Fans Forums there are very few people under 30 there ..... actually I think that fans forums generally, not just at Deepdale, are just a "going through the motions exercise" that the clubs are obliged to do twice a year under EFL Rules.

Anyway I digress.....fair comments lolpop.
 
We don't see it that way because we don't know what happens with it. PSG do great things but there is no relationship between them and the fans, where are they promoting themselves with fans? Getting fan feedback? Getting fans involved in PSG. Whenever i've mentioned it I always get shot down the Older ones related to PSG who seem to show the younger ones no respect at all. In a, we're older, we've seen the club through rough times, we know what we're talking about, kind of way.

PSG seriously needed to "modernise" to have any chance of surviving. Besides JK i don't even know who was involved at the top of PSG. There is no meaningful communication between PSG and the fans really.

Agree with this. There wasn't any communication. PSG's last activity on its twitter page was in June 2015, 22 months ago, for example.

For all I know they could've been doing great things but how would I know about it.

I agree with the OP too that a club needs a strong supporters' group to push the club on certain issues.
 
We don't see it that way because we don't know what happens with it. PSG do great things but there is no relationship between them and the fans, where are they promoting themselves with fans? Getting fan feedback? Getting fans involved in PSG. Whenever i've mentioned it I always get shot down the Older ones related to PSG who seem to show the younger ones no respect at all. In a, we're older, we've seen the club through rough times, we know what we're talking about, kind of way.

PSG seriously needed to "modernise" to have any chance of surviving. Besides JK i don't even know who was involved at the top of PSG. There is no meaningful communication between PSG and the fans really.
I'm sure I'm not the only one seeing parallells between the way fans groups apparently communicate with fans, and the way the club does...
 
Whites in Exile is still going strong (I assume, I'm a member and always get a list of the meet places) but that has always been pretty much a travel club for meeting like minded fans for pre- and after game beers...we sposored Aiden McGeady this year, and have sponsored a player for as long as I've been in it but I don't think there is a POTY trophy.
 
Great topic for a debate Budge.

I think it boils down to 3 or 4 things at THIS club.

1) The club are doing really well, there is little to get worked up about! (Season ticket/crowd issues aside)
2) We are a small club with a limited number of fans.
3) People's time is very precious these days.
4) At times it isn't worth the hassle

I know the majority of the PSG members/committee. They are all very knowledgeable PNE fans who have a passion for the club. However, some of the issues that i have heard of/seen over the years have been, quite frankly ridiculous.

Fans, giving fellow fans, abuse over the most stupid of issues.

There appears to be a large disconnect between young and old football fans nowadays. I don't understand it to be honest. Cliques and factions galore but what does it achieve other than bitching.

I have already conveyed my thanks to PSG for all the initiatives, fund raising, Gentry Days, supporters nights and other such events that were organised in people's spare time often using money out of their own pocket.

When you look around football in general, i do not see very much about supporters clubs in general. The 'big' clubs like Utd, Chelsea, City, Arsenal etc have supporter's group that are well organised and have staff paid a wage because of teh desire for fans to have access etc.

We are now in an era where ArsenalFanTv and Full Time Red Devils and the now famous Andy Tate are more prevalent than good old fashioned supporters groups. Times are changing. .
 
Whites in Exile is still going strong (I assume, I'm a member and always get a list of the meet places) but that has always been pretty much a travel club for meeting like minded fans for pre- and after game beers...we sposored Aiden McGeady this year, and have sponsored a player for as long as I've been in it but I don't think there is a POTY trophy.

Thanks Walrus
 
Great topic for a debate Budge.

I think it boils down to 3 or 4 things at THIS club.

1) The club are doing really well, there is little to get worked up about! (Season ticket/crowd issues aside)
2) We are a small club with a limited number of fans.
3) People's time is very precious these days.
4) At times it isn't worth the hassle

Number 1 is a very significant point.

Supporters groups numbers and supporters increase ultimately when things are going bad on the pitch or if supporters feel their club is being run very badly.

This has led to a huge increase in the number of Supporters Trusts which have been set up at many clubs who have issues regarding the ownership of their clubs, with in effect the trusts becoming the supporters club/shareholders all in one. Most supporters groups fit in at a time when groups of fans all come together with a common aim, once that aim has been achieved it is very difficult to keep the momentum going. I would have liked there to have been a trust at PNE which ultimately could have been very strong but the interest from supporters/owners/shareholders etc over the years just was not there.

As others have noted on this thread for many years I was the main internet presence for the group I was involved in. I put my head in front of the parapet and over the years had many many things thrown at it. At first it was just on the forum but as social media emerged I would get abuse on twitter, facebook from all angles which after a while gets you down. Sadly the abuse I received over Gentry Day (which I still remain very proud about was the end with it for me).

One of the significant changes in how a supporters group works is the significance of the internet. Folk used to attend meetings, attend forums etc, it would often be the only way like minded fans could have a moan or put ideas across, however now this is usually done in a couple of tweets then people move on.

A few very critical people over the years have said they will set up their own groups.... this has let to materialise.. whilst not having the time to get involved fully I would always been willing to help them anyway I can. However the key thing I would point out is that is very easy for people to sit and moan on the internet but getting people to actually do things is far far more difficult.

Overall I think most PNE fans are happy with how the club is being run... so getting a group started could prove difficult.

What would their aims be? How would they generate interest etc?

I don't think some of the younger generation of football fans that would need to be involved would be interested to be honest.
 
Last edited:
I'm possibly the odd one out feeling the supporters should have a group, a voice and perhaps just perhaps the club may be a little more interested in concerns.
The fans forum was other than a couple of genuine concerned supporters regarding ticketing and off field issues a supporters love in from the usual few. Voldemort had a go but was duly blanked, my after the meeting comments to John Kay and Peter Ridsdale were both met with abrupt ' this is what we're doing' responses. Horrible manner from both men.
Emails to the club are fobbed off by Zoe head of business ? And I genuinely wonder if the board or certainly Kay and Ridsdale actually care.
The current season ticket concerns are genuine, or will be if they're ever actually announced, as are supporters numbers.
Love to have some supporter representation at club meetings and I and others feel more than a bit isolated from ' my club' / ' our club'
First time in years despite hearing how well we've done I may actually not buy a season ticket next time.
If a group does form it would need a front man/ woman and a good orator with great supporter roots unafrId to ask the questions and report back. Step forward Budgie man.......
 
Last edited:
With the sad demise of PSG this week and the dormant PNESouth Ribble group I think it begs the question -

Are Supporters Groups vital to a club or are they a thing of the past?

Along with PSG and PNESR we have little from the North Lancs Group for quite some time although I think the Whites in Exile still do a POTY Trophy... I may be wrong.


I pose the question in light of the recent discussions around the club match pricing policy and Season Ticket prices amongst other things. A club without a Supporters Group or voice can pretty much do what it wants....if there is no interaction between Club and fans I believe apathy sets in and people just vote with their feet eventually

I believe a strong Supporters Group almost acts as an opposition to the Government if you like and should challenge on issues of the day in a constructive manner.

To be fair to North End the Club and the Supporters Groups (Particularly PSG) have worked well over the years but recently PSG have been little more than a travel club and so that link is lost somewhat.

For example...who will the club discuss next years Gentry Day with ? ......perhaps it will just be a poll on the website.

I certainly see a place for a strong Supporters Group but I fear it is an age thing and that some of our younger fans don`t quite see it that way.

I would be interested in peoples thoughts.

I'm possibly the odd one out feeling the supporters should have a group, a voice and perhaps just perhaps the club may be a little more interested in concerns.
The fans forum was other than a couple of genuine concerned supporters regarding ticketing and off field issues a supporters love in from the usual few. Voldemort had a go but was duly blanked, my after the meeting comments to John Kay and Peter Ridsdale were both met with abrupt ' this is what we're doing' responses. Horrible manner from both men.
Emails to the club are fobbed off by Zoe head of business ? And I genuinely wonder if the board or certainly Kay and Ridsdale actually care.
The current season ticket concerns are genuine, or will be if they're ever actually announced, as are supporters numbers.
Love to have some supporter representation at club meetings and I and others feel more than a bit isolated from ' my club' / ' our club'
First time in years despite hearing how well we've done I may actually not buy a season ticket next time.
If a group does form it would need a front man/ woman and a good orator with great supporter roots unafraid to ask the questions and report back. Step forward Budgie man.......

I actually think due to the lack of genuine interaction between the club and supporters that a general apathy has set in, the club seems to accept 6,700 season ticket sales, there are no incentives to entice, new, lost, young fans, other than look how we have performed, so the 10,00 or so fans we have, just accept it is what it is ?
 
I'm possibly the odd one out feeling the supporters should have a group, a voice and perhaps just perhaps the club may be a little more interested in concerns.
The fans forum was other than a couple of genuine concerned supporters regarding ticketing and off field issues a supporters love in from the usual few. Voldemort had a go but was duly blanked, my after the meeting comments to John Kay and Peter Ridsdale were both met with abrupt ' this is what we're doing' responses. Horrible manner from both men.
Emails to the club are fobbed off by Zoe head of business ? And I genuinely wonder if the board or certainly Kay and Ridsdale actually care.
The current season ticket concerns are genuine, or will be if they're ever actually announced, as are supporters numbers.
Love to have some supporter representation at club meetings and I and others feel more than a bit isolated from ' my club' / ' our club'
First time in years despite hearing how well we've done I may actually not buy a season ticket next time.
If a group does form it would need a front man/ woman and a good orator with great supporter roots unafrId to ask the questions and report back. Step forward Budgie man.......

I think there are genuine improvements to made across the board with communication with fan ( potential fans) and certainly business.
The introduction of a business club would also be a great idea (sorry , Huddersfield great success)
Another massive miss was in March Buisness Expo Preston Guild Hall 160 local businesses represented including Preston Grasshoppers , AFC Fylde and the event caterers for Blackpool! .
No brainier for North End ,you guessed PNE not represented!
So lots to be done on and off the pitch but it all seems a bit quiet.
 
I think there are genuine improvements to made across the board with communication with fan ( potential fans) and certainly business.
The introduction of a business club would also be a great idea (sorry , Huddersfield great success)
Another massive miss was in March Buisness Expo Preston Guild Hall 160 local businesses represented including Preston Grasshoppers , AFC Fylde and the event caterers for Blackpool! .
No brainier for North End ,you guessed PNE not represented!
So lots to be done on and off the pitch but it all seems a bit quiet.

Seriously ? PNE not represented ? That's quite abysmal tbh.
 
Number 1 is a very significant point.

Supporters groups numbers and supporters increase ultimately when things are going bad on the pitch or if supporters feel their club is being run very badly.

This has led to a huge increase in the number of Supporters Trusts which have been set up at many clubs who have issues regarding the ownership of their clubs, with in effect the trusts becoming the supporters club/shareholders all in one. Most supporters groups fit in at a time when groups of fans all come together with a common aim, once that aim has been achieved it is very difficult to keep the momentum going. I would have liked there to have been a trust at PNE which ultimately could have been very strong but the interest from supporters/owners/shareholders etc over the years just was not there.

As others have noted on this thread for many years I was the main internet presence for the group I was involved in. I put my head in front of the parapet and over the years had many many things thrown at it. At first it was just on the forum but as social media emerged I would get abuse on twitter, facebook from all angles which after a while gets you down. Sadly the abuse I received over Gentry Day (which I still remain very proud about was the end with it for me).

One of the significant changes in how a supporters group works is the significance of the internet. Folk used to attend meetings, attend forums etc, it would often be the only way like minded fans could have a moan or put ideas across, however now this is usually done in a couple of tweets then people move on.

A few very critical people over the years have said they will set up their own groups.... this has let to materialise.. whilst not having the time to get involved fully I would always been willing to help them anyway I can. However the key thing I would point out is that is very easy for people to sit and moan on the internet but getting people to actually do things is far far more difficult.

Overall I think most PNE fans are happy with how the club is being run... so getting a group started could prove difficult.

What would their aims be? How would they generate interest etc?

I don't think some of the younger generation of football fans that would need to be involved would be interested to be honest.

Having set up a group I know how hard it it and how much work is needed, PSG was welcoming and helpful via the club to other groups. If PSG is to go, I would like to see a replacement set up quickly. PSG did a lot of good for fans even when things are going well. I would hope the members of PSG reconsider and revitalize PSG, making it open to all, using social media better. IE, streaming meetings live, its free over Facebook, Having a question and answer session where people put their issue's accross and PSG take them to the club. PSG has always been helpful in that sense but didn't entertain the changing world. PSG can just be a Facebook group, Stream meetings etc via it, its all free. Have a donation page to raise fund for any campaign. I really hope something happens soon because the Gentry is a fans event nd although the club has some say it should be the fans event. And I don;t want to see people snap it up and pick places like Wigan or Blackburn, just because we get more fans there. Its has to be more than, the traveling the Memories etc. I wouldn't want to see people fighting over it. PSG put in a lot of effort into it and I think without a proper supporters group like PSG it will come to an end. With the club aiming for the Prem, having a Supporters group would be important to the club to. JK did take a lot of abuse for no reason and to be honest, I think he coped with it very well, a credit to the man.

People did feel left out with PSG, because it was never promoted, never really heard anything unless it was JK, people felt it was a closed group which it wasn't. So hope a reconsideration is about and embracing social media.
 
I think it boils down to 3 or 4 things at THIS club.

1) The club are doing really well, there is little to get worked up about! (Season ticket/crowd issues aside)
2) We are a small club with a limited number of fans.
3) People's time is very precious these days.
4) At times it isn't worth the hassle

I know the majority of the PSG members/committee. They are all very knowledgeable PNE fans who have a passion for the club. However, some of the issues that i have heard of/seen over the years have been, quite frankly ridiculous.

Fans, giving fellow fans, abuse over the most stupid of issues.

Point 1 is important. The club is being run well at the moment, and we are fairly comfortable in mid table and looking good on the pitch, but don't look like troubling either end of the Championship. The fact we are bumping along, stable in mid table, is probably reflected in the enthusiasm and activity of our various supporters groups (which is absolutely fine).

Supporters groups generally form, gather interest and influence when a club is going through an extreme situation I.E. Unprecedented meteoric rise and promotion or hurtling towards relegation and financial crisis, as these tend to create interest, attention and a siege mentality among fans. In the absence of both of these at PNE for the foreseeable future, you can understand why our supporters groups are dormant at present.

It's sad to hear about PSG (the founders if Gentry Day, if I'm not mistaken?). I was not aware of their demise. Anyone who takes time and money out of their own lives voluntarily to run a supporters club for PNE fans deserves thanks and credit - more than they appear to have received over the years. These people appear to be a dying breed, sadly. Does anyone know the reason for PSG folding?
 
Last edited:
As a young PNE fan the only thing I can add to this is that I've never heard of PSG or PNE South Ribble, and only have a vague idea of what Whites in Exile are.

I reckon that this is a large part of the reason for their demise.
 
With the sad demise of PSG this week and the dormant PNESouth Ribble group I think it begs the question -

Are Supporters Groups vital to a club or are they a thing of the past?

Along with PSG and PNESR we have little from the North Lancs Group for quite some time although I think the Whites in Exile still do a POTY Trophy... I may be wrong.


I pose the question in light of the recent discussions around the club match pricing policy and Season Ticket prices amongst other things. A club without a Supporters Group or voice can pretty much do what it wants....if there is no interaction between Club and fans I believe apathy sets in and people just vote with their feet eventually

I believe a strong Supporters Group almost acts as an opposition to the Government if you like and should challenge on issues of the day in a constructive manner.

To be fair to North End the Club and the Supporters Groups (Particularly PSG) have worked well over the years but recently PSG have been little more than a travel club and so that link is lost somewhat.

For example...who will the club discuss next years Gentry Day with ? ......perhaps it will just be a poll on the website.

I certainly see a place for a strong Supporters Group but I fear it is an age thing and that some of our younger fans don`t quite see it that way.

I would be interested in peoples thoughts.

A supporters group is only as relevant as it wants to be. Unfortunately PSG had been irrelevant for probably not far off a decade, I didn't even realise they were still going until they made their announcement last week.
 
As far as I'm aware, the North Lancs Supporters Club finished a number of years ago. It's a shame as this group held some interesting fans forums. At the start of every season, the manager would attend as an example. At one forum, Billy Davies said he wanted to not start Nugent on the Play Off Final as he looked fatigued, but was scared of the backlash. At another forum, Sir Tom Finney was the club representative and it was an honour to meet him, even if it was a cold winters night.

They also arranged a coach to loads of away games, and I enjoyed them a lot. But nothing has been arranged from the Lancaster area for years either by a supporters group or by our club. For the Play Off Final, I personally ran a coach to Wembley and back. I sold 47 seats, and there was interest from others

There are a lot of people who follow the club in the Lancaster area. Yet there is nothing to try encourage people in this area to attend home or away games. The club should do more, but it would be great if some sort of supporters group could be set up again.
 
Back
Top