Skip to main content

Team for Cardiff

Team for Cardiff

Joined
May 24, 2016
Messages
5,141
Tough game, every player will probably have to play well if we are to get something out of the game.

The keeper and defence should probably stay the same. The pace of Kenneth Zohore against the likes of Huntington and Spurr is a worry but we'll have to see how they cope. He ran Huntington and Clarke ragged in January at the away game last season.

The midfield of Browne and Gallagher probably picks itself too, as Welsh probably isn't fit enough to start. Obviously the situation in the area isn't ideal. We can only hope Johnson is back, doesn't sound like Pearson will be.

Hugill was quiet on Saturday but will probably start again, that just leaves the 3 behind him to consider.

I'd start -

Barkhuizen - his crosses have lead to goals against Reading and Barnsley, we just need to get him closer to goal.

Harrop - other than some poor set pieces he looked very good as a sub on Saturday and IMHO deserves a start.

Maguire - obviously he should play after scoring and playing pretty well vs Barnsley.

How those 3 line up positionally behind Hugill I don't know. Perhaps Barkhuizen right, Harrop left, Maguire in the middle?

Mavididi looked okay to me on Saturday but didn't look natural on the right. Robinson was poor when he came on. Plus I'm not sure if I'd start Horgan over others for now. He's clearly got ability/potential but hasn't shown anything to match some of the hype coming from our fans yet.

So......

Maxwell; Fisher, Huntington, Spurr, Earl; Browne, Gallagher (Johnson if fit); Barkhuizen, Maguire, Harrop; Hugill.

Thoughts?
 
kbd_pne;2470216So...... Maxwell; Fisher said:
I've just suggested elsewhere a similar line-up but with Harrop alongside Browne and Horgan mainly for his defensive application in the '3'. If Johnson is fit then he must come back alongside Browne in which case Gallagher could be played in the '3' instead of Harrop though if Johnson is not available then the team you suggest makes sense.
 
Tough game, every player will probably have to play well if we are to get something out of the game.

The keeper and defence should probably stay the same. The pace of Kenneth Zohore against the likes of Huntington and Spurr is a worry but we'll have to see how they cope. He ran Huntington and Clarke ragged in January at the away game last season.

The midfield of Browne and Gallagher probably picks itself too, as Welsh probably isn't fit enough to start. Obviously the situation in the area isn't ideal. We can only hope Johnson is back, doesn't sound like Pearson will be.

Hugill was quiet on Saturday but will probably start again, that just leaves the 3 behind him to consider.

I'd start -

Barkhuizen - his crosses have lead to goals against Reading and Barnsley, we just need to get him closer to goal.

Harrop - other than some poor set pieces he looked very good as a sub on Saturday and IMHO deserves a start.

Maguire - obviously he should play after scoring and playing pretty well vs Barnsley.

How those 3 line up positionally behind Hugill I don't know. Perhaps Barkhuizen right, Harrop left, Maguire in the middle?

Mavididi looked okay to me on Saturday but didn't look natural on the right. Robinson was poor when he came on. Plus I'm not sure if I'd start Horgan over others for now. He's clearly got ability/potential but hasn't shown anything to match some of the hype coming from our fans yet.

So......

Maxwell; Fisher, Huntington, Spurr, Earl; Browne, Gallagher (Johnson if fit); Barkhuizen, Maguire, Harrop; Hugill.

Thoughts?

Probably play davies instead of spurr for pace against Zohore
 
I've just suggested elsewhere a similar line-up but with Harrop alongside Browne and Horgan mainly for his defensive application in the '3'. If Johnson is fit then he must come back alongside Browne in which case Gallagher could be played in the '3' instead of Harrop though if Johnson is not available then the team you suggest makes sense.

If I was given the choice of Gallagher or Harrop in the '3', I'd definitely choose Harrop. Early days and yet to prove himself but he looks a lot more mobile and energetic than Gallagher so is more suited to that position. Hopefully he can start showing his quality soon, he's already shown some decent glimpses. He deserves to start after his cameo on Saturday.

Personally I see Gallagher's role as more of an impact sub this season, if we need that quality cross or killer pass. He's never been the quickest but he looks so slow and un-atheltic nowadays.

Probably play davies instead of spurr for pace against Zohore

I don't see Spurr being dropped, but the lack of mobility vs Zohore will be an issue. We'll just have to hope that Maxwell can be extra quick off his line.
 
Personally I see Gallagher's role as more of an impact sub this season, if we need that quality cross or killer pass. He's never been the quickest but he looks so slow and un-atheltic nowadays./QUOTE]

In fairness Gallagher probably needs a bit more time after his lay-off to get back up to whatever speed he can manage these days. But whatever this is probably his last season with us and maybe he and Welsh might look to find themselves more regular football a level lower in the new Year.
 
I've no idea but AN seemed to suggest the full backs were a bit off it on Saturday and so 'maybe' he will rest Earl against a good Cardiff attack.

That could mean asking Spurr to do the LB job for a game and Davies at CB.

Agree Stephy needs time and that a fit Harrop might be better employed in a central 3 with Gally & Browne.... which leaves the front 3 as per the Reading Game ( Maguire right; TomB left and Jordan central).

So, Maxi
Fisher; Hunts; Davies; Spurr
Gally; Browne
Harrop

Maguire; Hugill; Barkhuizen
 
Why would you drop Spurr after an arguably man of the match performance?

Yes yes the pace of Zohore etc... but he's also a big lad and Spurr and Hunts are probably better equipped to handle him that Davies is.

Maxwell

Fisher
Hunts
Spurr
Earl

Gally
Welsh

Maguire
Browne
Barky

Hugill


I put Browne at 10 because I think Cardiff play a 4-1-4-1, so picking up that defensive midfielder is something Browne would do very well. Much better than Harrop anyway - seen Neil get annoyed at him for his poor defensive play numerous times.
 
Maxwell; Fisher, Huntington, Spurr, Earl; Browne, Gallagher (Johnson if fit); Barkhuizen, Maguire, Harrop; Hugill.

Thoughts?

This is probably what I'd go with as well, though after Neil criticised Earl (harsh IMO it was only really one cross and imagine what we'd say if our wingers never got past their full back once in a game?) he might move Spurr to LB and bring Davies in.

I've just suggested elsewhere a similar line-up but with Harrop alongside Browne and Horgan mainly for his defensive application in the '3'. If Johnson is fit then he must come back alongside Browne in which case Gallagher could be played in the '3' instead of Harrop though if Johnson is not available then the team you suggest makes sense.

I'd worry about Harrop and Browne as a 2. Harrop seems to come out of every challenge wincing or holding a part of his body after taking a knock.
 
I've no idea but AN seemed to suggest the full backs were a bit off it on Saturday and so 'maybe' he will rest Earl against a good Cardiff attack.

That could mean asking Spurr to do the LB job for a game and Davies at CB.

Agree Stephy needs time and that a fit Harrop might be better employed in a central 3 with Gally & Browne.... which leaves the front 3 as per the Reading Game ( Maguire right; TomB left and Jordan central).

So, Maxi
Fisher; Hunts; Davies; Spurr
Gally; Browne
Harrop

Maguire; Hugill; Barkhuizen

This for me but would also consider Horgan instead of Barky for although he set up the goal i didn't see him tracking back to support Earl enough.
 
I'd play the same side as Saturday with the exception of Johnson coming back if fit for Gallagher and Harrop coming in, probably for Mavididi, bit harsh on Mavididi as he did well but I think Harrop is a talent and we need to find room for him to start being a starter if he is now fully fit.

It would be interesting to see what we'd be like if Maguire moved up to take over Hugill's role as centre forward and we had a three behind him of Mavididi, Harrop central and Barkhuizen. I'm not suggesting dropping Hugill but Maguire looks to be a very intelligent footballer and we haven't yet seen him play that centre forward role.
 
Why would you drop Spurr after an arguably man of the match performance?

Yes yes the pace of Zohore etc... but he's also a big lad and Spurr and Hunts are probably better equipped to handle him that Davies is.

Maxwell

Fisher
Hunts
Spurr
Earl

Gally
Welsh

Maguire
Browne
Barky

Hugill


I put Browne at 10 because I think Cardiff play a 4-1-4-1, so picking up that defensive midfielder is something Browne would do very well. Much better than Harrop anyway - seen Neil get annoyed at him for his poor defensive play numerous times.

Did you go to Cardiff away? Zohore absolutely bullied Huntington. Don't think he's scored yet this season so he's bound to get off the mark tomorrow.
 
Did you go to Cardiff away? Zohore absolutely bullied Huntington. Don't think he's scored yet this season so he's bound to get off the mark tomorrow.

Scored on the first day at Burton.

Both Clarke and Huntington couldn't cope with him that night (Browning couldn't cope with Hoillett/Harris either if I recall correctly) but it was a generally poor/disorganised performance from us. If we're a bit more 'on it' tomorrow night, hopefully we should be able to shackle them a bit better.
 
Did you go to Cardiff away? Zohore absolutely bullied Huntington. Don't think he's scored yet this season so he's bound to get off the mark tomorrow.

No I didn't but I know that he also bullied Clarke as well. But he scored against Blackpool so let's not mention that....

Should be okay - either way we don't have any better options to deal with him.
 
Why would you drop Spurr after an arguably man of the match performance?

Yes yes the pace of Zohore etc... but he's also a big lad and Spurr and Hunts are probably better equipped to handle him that Davies is.

Maxwell

Fisher
Hunts
Spurr
Earl

Gally
Welsh

Maguire
Browne
Barky

Hugill


I put Browne at 10 because I think Cardiff play a 4-1-4-1, so picking up that defensive midfielder is something Browne would do very well. Much better than Harrop anyway - seen Neil get annoyed at him for his poor defensive play numerous times.

Gally and Welsh !!!! ffs they looked like a couple of oaps on saturday next to useless
 
Gally and Welsh !!!! ffs they looked like a couple of oaps on saturday next to useless

100%

theyd get raped by any half decent midfield

looks a weak selection

Funny this.

Whenever I say Hugill plays badly, for example, everyone says "Oh well Neil said he played well so I know who's right!"

Yet when Neil said Gally and Welsh both came in and did well... it doesn't matter. Because it isn't our little 8 million pound man who closes down defenders.

Gally and Welsh would provide stability, however I'm aware that they'd provide very little mobility.
 
Funny this.

Whenever I say Hugill plays badly, for example, everyone says "Oh well Neil said he played well so I know who's right!"

Yet when Neil said Gally and Welsh both came in and did well... it doesn't matter. Because it isn't our little 8 million pound man who closes down defenders.

Gally and Welsh would provide stability, however I'm aware that they'd provide very little mobility.

I have a daft dog that can close down defenders. She is good at that. Isnt the clever bit scoring the odd goal?
8 million apart I expect a lot more of mr hugill tonight. Based on Saturdays performance his first half miss was poor and it got no better but then average would have described numerous players.
One hopes to use descriptors like good or even excellent after tonight's game?
 
Did you go to Cardiff away? Zohore absolutely bullied Huntington. Don't think he's scored yet this season so he's bound to get off the mark tomorrow.

Sorry I didn't realise Zohore scored tonight. Thought we won 3-0. Infact the only person who was getting bullied tonight was Zohore, but as you said he was bound to get off the mark tonight.

Also did you go on tonight, because as you stated 'he's bound to get off the mark.'
 
Back
Top