Skip to main content

Team for Middlesbrough

Team for Middlesbrough

Seen a lot worse in a North End shirt.

In fact on this season's evidence, both deserve a chance. Wright has been poor, and Ben Davies & Laird haven't pulled up any trees at left back.

Hunts & Buchs both very dependable defenders for me, don't understand the slating they get?

Agreed.

Woods, Clarke, Huntington and Buchanan as a back 4 would be perfectly fine with me!
 
Woods, Clarke, Huntington and Buchanan as a back 4 would be perfectly fine with me!

..and it would be defensively very sound. The problem, though, is that it would also be very static and provide very little support going forward. Laird at his best can provide that link and a few goals - I agree he does not seem to have done much so far this season but what he can potentially bring to the team probably makes it worth giving him a few games to see if he can get his act together properly.
 
Jones
Woods, Clarke, Wiseman, Laird
King
Humphrey, Kilkenny, Browne, Little
Garner

Stuckmann, B. Davies, Gallagher, Welsh, Hayhurst, K.Davies, Hugill

The above is my predicted team but personally I would prefer Huntington to Wiseman and Wiseman to B. Davies on the bench.
 
I like Wiseman at right back but he would be an absolute disaster in the centre of a back 4 imo.

Huntington or King for me, although I think King struggles in a back 4 too.
 
With clubs interested in signing Buchanan & Huntington, I cant see us playing them especially if we need them off the wage bill before we can bring anyone in ?

Where have you read that they have clubs interested in signing them?
 
He only plays one forward at home, can't see him playing 2 away at a club from a higher league.

And as for Bailey Wright, his lack of height has always concerned me, to small for a CB, but his effort has got him through just.

But this season he has turned into a liability, mistake after mistake, and he doesn't look fit either.
 
Where have you read that they have clubs interested in signing them?

It was written in the LEP a few days ago talking about Nimely training with us, but it said that we would more likely need a couple of players to leave first before we can bring any new players into the squad etc. It then mention that clubs have shown Interest in both Huntington & Buchanan.
 
Where have you read that they have clubs interested in signing them?

It was written in the LEP a few days ago talking about Nimely training with us, but it also said that we would more likely need a couple of players to leave first before we can bring any new players into the squad etc. It then mention that clubs have shown some Interest in both Huntington & Buchanan.
 
It was written in the LEP a few days ago talking about Nimely training with us, but it also said that we would more likely need a couple of players to leave first before we can bring any new players into the squad etc. It then mention that clubs have shown some Interest in both Huntington & Buchanan.

Ah, ok cheers.
 
Stuckmann
Wiseman, Clarke, Huntington, Buchanan
King
Welsh, Kilkenny
Little, Garner, Hayhurst

Jones, Woods, Browne, Brownhill, Davies, Hughill, Humphrey.​
 
He only plays one forward at home, can't see him playing 2 away at a club from a higher league.QUOTE]

Which as I've tried to argue elsewhere is a false policy made even worse by the fact that the forward he uses is Garner who is just not suited to that role. But in a match like tonight's and with a player like Hugill or Kevin Davies it might make sense and with a player like that upfront using Gallagher 'in the slot' between midfield and that striker might also work.

A starting formation - with Brownhill, Hugill and Garner held back - this might make sense:

Jones,

Wiseman, Clarke, King, Laird

Humphrey, Browne, Kilkenny, Hayhurst

Gallagher

Davies
 
He only plays one forward at home, can't see him playing 2 away at a club from a higher league.QUOTE]

Which as I've tried to argue elsewhere is a false policy made even worse by the fact that the forward he uses is Garner who is just not suited to that role. But in a match like tonight's and with a player like Hugill or Kevin Davies it might make sense and with a player like that upfront using Gallagher 'in the slot' between midfield and that striker might also work.

A starting formation - with Brownhill, Hugill and Garner held back - this might make sense:

Jones,

Wiseman, Clarke, King, Laird

Humphrey, Browne, Kilkenny, Hayhurst

Gallagher

Davies

With that team, we will be over-run in central midfield, just like Saturday.

We need 1 defensive midfielder plus 2 others which means sacrificing the ineffective role played by Gallagher on Saturday.
It is unfortunate if King has to revert to central defence because of Wright's injury but, for me, the 3 central midfielders would be King, Kilkenny and Browne.
 
He only plays one forward at home, can't see him playing 2 away at a club from a higher league.QUOTE]

Which as I've tried to argue elsewhere is a false policy made even worse by the fact that the forward he uses is Garner who is just not suited to that role. But in a match like tonight's and with a player like Hugill or Kevin Davies it might make sense and with a player like that upfront using Gallagher 'in the slot' between midfield and that striker might also work.

A starting formation - with Brownhill, Hugill and Garner held back - this might make sense:

Jones,

Wiseman, Clarke, King, Laird

Humphrey, Browne, Kilkenny, Hayhurst

Gallagher

Davies

But he always used Garner last year and it worked very well. Having KD as a lone forward is just not going to produce.
 
rem - thanks, perfectly valid point but though none of the four I suggest is a 'Gregan-type' they can all put their foot including, inportantly, the wide players.

jc - ditto, in a match like tonight's I think someone like Kevin Davies could very well as a lone stiker holding the ball up to allow Gallagher playing in the only role that really seems to suit him to get up in support. Did Garner ever play as a lone striker last season - I am not certain he did - but whatever it is I believe a mistake to use him that way because he will just run himself silly against probably two defenders who will kick him every time they get the chance. Garner needs a partner to create the space in which he can thrive.
 
This team wouldn't work.

If Little stayed close by Garner and Hayhurst played wider to the left then with Wiseman getting up on the right it would have some balance. Its weakness would be a lack of lack of pace in the midfield but add Browne in place of Welsh and might start to make sense.
 
If Little stayed close by Garner and Hayhurst played wider to the left then with Wiseman getting up on the right it would have some balance. Its weakness would be a lack of lack of pace in the midfield but add Browne in place of Welsh and might start to make sense.

That would be incredibly unbalanced... We'd have two players down the left hand side and one player down the entirity of the right side.
 
I'd suggest Jones, Wiseman, Clarke, King, Davies, Kilkenny, Welsh, Browne, Hayhurst, Laird, Hugill 🙂
 
PNE have confirmed the following team, via twitter.

PNE line-up vs Middlesbrough: Jones, Wiseman, B Davies, Welsh (c), Clarke, King, Hayhurst, Browne, Hugill, Kilkenny, Laird #mfcvpne
 
Back
Top