Skip to main content

Team for Sunday

Team for Sunday

Joined
Mar 2, 2006
Messages
11,374
Location
B6243
Thought SG got the team selection spot on yesterday and made good substitutions too.

CH is a very strong player defensively and has good attacking skills. He also has plenty of experience too which is important in our situation. So I thought starting him in place of the exciting, skilful but defensively weaker Robinson was a good decision. For me the balance between defensive solidity and attacking flair was better. And CR is an excellent player to have on the bench if needed.

It's brilliant to not only have such a strong starting 11 but also, as yesterday, to be in a position to bring on 3 subs of the high calibre of KD, CR and NK.

Would be very happy with that same line up at Colchester.
 
Presuming Beckford's injury isn't too serious you'd have to assume Mr Grayson will pick the same 11. The change could be on the bench - maybe Reid for Wiseman if he feels there's no need for two full back options on the bench.
 
Presuming Beckford's injury isn't too serious you'd have to assume Mr Grayson will pick the same 11. The change could be on the bench - maybe Reid for Wiseman if he feels there's no need for two full back options on the bench.

Is Beckford injured, he didn't look injured?
 
Is Beckford injured, he didn't look injured?

About a minute before he went off he pulled up with what looked a tweak to his knee - happened right in front of us. Didn't look like much as he ran after a through ball after a few flexes but Grayson immediately got Robinson ready. Presumably a precaution and it would probably take a broken leg to stop him playing next Sunday.
 
Taking Beckford, Garner and Welsh off just looked like giving the lads a rest after a good shift and avoid injuries or in Welsh's case a second yellow....

Don't really like Clarke at right back but it's working so same again for me....

Humphrey offers more than Robinson and if stick with him to...
 
Garner, Beckford and Welsh all taken off to ensure no hiccups before next week.... I also agree that the same team and bench is the way to go.
 
Taking Beckford, Garner and Welsh off just looked like giving the lads a rest after a good shift and avoid injuries or in Welsh's case a second yellow....

Don't really like Clarke at right back but it's working so same again for me....

Humphrey offers more than Robinson and if stick with him to...

He wasn't playing right back, it was 3-5-2?

And for me Humphrey doesn't offer as much going forward as Robinson, but defensively he certainly does, and if we're playing a wing back system it's a no brainer to play Humphrey.
 
He wasn't playing right back, it was 3-5-2?

And for me Humphrey doesn't offer as much going forward as Robinson, but defensively he certainly does, and if we're playing a wing back system it's a no brainer to play Humphrey.

I think he meant the alternative would be Clarke at right back ?
 
Probably ten out of the eleven pick themselves - Johnstone, Clarke, Huntington, Wright, Laird, Welsh, Johnson, Gallagher, Beckford, Garner. The options for the other place are:

Humphrey - probably so that we can play the wing-back system which has always proved a reliable, 'safe' though rarely highly destructive formation.

Kilkenny - to form a partnership with Welsh that can provide a platform for another four players to attack but not really a proven formation.

Robinson - a reversion to the all-out attacking option that SG has used at times.

My guess is SG will go for the first of those though he may just go for broke with the third.
 
Last edited:
I thought Beckford pulled up with a muscle or knee, 2 or 3 minutes before he went off. But then he did seem to run unhibiited before being substituted. Hopefully nothing that stiffened up after the match.
 
He wasn't playing right back, it was 3-5-2?

And for me Humphrey doesn't offer as much going forward as Robinson, but defensively he certainly does, and if we're playing a wing back system it's a no brainer to play Humphrey.

It was a very fluid system yesterday and at times a definite 442.....

Robinson hasn't offered that much since he has been here and was shite at Notts County. Humphrey played well yesterday and was more advanced than a right wing back a good chunk of the game.
 
It was a very fluid system yesterday and at times a definite 442.....

Robinson hasn't offered that much since he has been here and was shite at Notts County. Humphrey played well yesterday and was more advanced than a right wing back a good chunk of the game.

Perhaps a 3-5-2 off the ball and a 4-4-2 on the ball?

Robinson's sometimes unplayable but then sometimes very quiet but he is only 20 years old. Consistency will come with age. I would stick with Humphrey for Sunday though.
 
Perhaps a 3-5-2 off the ball and a 4-4-2 on the ball?

Robinson's sometimes unplayable but then sometimes very quiet but he is only 20 years old. Consistency will come with age. I would stick with Humphrey for Sunday though.

He is the only loan signing we have I could take or leave next season.... He hasn't been very unplayable in many games and at times Humphrey is unplayable...

I saw Clarke more as a right back yesterday and got forward at times which one of three centre halves wouldn't really do...
 
He is the only loan signing we have I could take or leave next season.... He hasn't been very unplayable in many games and at times Humphrey is unplayable...

I saw Clarke more as a right back yesterday and got forward at times which one of three centre halves wouldn't really do...

I'd have him next season, will only get better. Lightyears ahead of Kyel Reid when he plays on the left hand side.

Off the ball we almost had a back five, but yes clarke was coming forward more than usual.
 
With Colchester playing a 4.3.3 formation with extremely quick wingers, I wouldn't be surprise if we matched them up & go with the same team that started V MkDons?
 
Back
Top