Skip to main content

Team for Tranmere

Team for Tranmere

Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
1,836
Location
Frankfurt
OK, so we can't cross a ball for toffee, our wingers are completely ineffectual, our middle 3 were superb tonight, and all our threat came through the middle. Having said that, would anyone be opposed to a lineup that looked something like this for Saturday?

Rudd

Wiseman Clarke Wright Laird
Welsh Kilkenny Keane
Gallagher
Garner C. Davies​
 
Would like to see how SKD and CD played together and then maybe bring Garner on if it's not going well.
 
OK, so we can't cross a ball for toffee, our wingers are completely ineffectual, our middle 3 were superb tonight, and all our threat came through the middle. Having said that, would anyone be opposed to a lineup that looked something like this for Saturday?
I would go with that winger-less eleven too.

Wiseman Clarke Wright Laird
Welsh Kilkenny Keane
Gallagher
Garner C. Davies[/CENTER]
 
Whoever lines up - the biggest challenge is to get them motivated.

A lot of players left a lot of mental and physical energy out on that pitch last night. They're very unlikely to simply pick up where they left off.
 
OK, so we can't cross a ball for toffee, our wingers are completely ineffectual, our middle 3 were superb tonight, and all our threat came through the middle. Having said that, would anyone be opposed to a lineup that looked something like this for Saturday?

Rudd

Wiseman Clarke Wright Laird
Welsh Kilkenny Keane
Gallagher
Garner C. Davies​
laird instead of buchannon?...ridiculous
 
laird instead of buchannon?...ridiculous

Buchanan was getting a lot of the ball last night and not doing much with it, hence the swap with Laird who then hardly had a kick! Shame really, could have saved the sub for Beavon / Hume to come on instead.
 
OK, so we can't cross a ball for toffee, our wingers are completely ineffectual, our middle 3 were superb tonight, and all our threat came through the middle. Having said that, would anyone be opposed to a lineup that looked something like this for Saturday?

Rudd

Wiseman Clarke Wright Laird
Welsh Kilkenny Keane
Gallagher
Garner C. Davies​

I like this because I feel we need a wingerless system because we have no wingers who pass the opposition at pace and deliver an inviting ball. Hence we pass back to a full back or welsh / kilkenny and it's too slow.
 
Buchanan was getting a lot of the ball last night and not doing much with it, hence the swap with Laird who then hardly had a kick! Shame really, could have saved the sub for Beavon / Hume to come on instead.

Laird looked much more comfortable coming forward and also got himself into more dangerous positions than Buchanan. With that close-packed midfield - which I think we should persevere with - we need attacking fullbacks like Wiseman on the right and Laird on the left. In retrospect Hume or Beavon should have been given a start alongside Davies.
 
Last edited:
Good observation OP. Definately agree that we looked good in a 4-3-1-2 formation and do have an absence of wingers. Hoping hayhurst comes back match fit as he could be useful. Holmes, to my surprise, just hasnt done enough to cement a place.
 
Buchanan all day long before laird, 3rd best pass rate last night before going off, if buchs had a final ball he'd be playing in the premier league,
 
Buchanan all day long before laird, 3rd best pass rate last night before going off, if buchs had a final ball he'd be playing in the premier league,

I agree. Sadly Laird is not the player he was before he broke his leg.
 
I agree. Sadly Laird is not the player he was before he broke his leg.

How would we know? He's been used as a wing-back, where he's not quick enough to be effective. In the positions Buchanan was in yesterday, I'm pretty sure Laird would have been a bigger threat. In my opinion Laird has admittedly been a bit rusty on the ball compared to before his injury, but that only improves with playing time which in his strongest position he's not had. Overall, with either Buchanan or Laird on the pitch I think we're very strong in the left back position, but it should be a case of choosing the correct one for the correct occasion whether the focus is more on being solid or playing attacking football.
 
Buchanan all day for me too. But...it's refreshing that we have two quality players for the left back position. I remember a time when our only option was Ray Sharp.
 
There's not much between Laird and Buchs for me, the only difference being that Laird offers more going forward; he can cross a ball and is dangerous from setpieces, whether he's in the box or taking them.
 
Think if we're going to play a formation that narrow then we need Laird instead of Buchanan as he's better going forward
 
Think if we're going to play a formation that narrow then we need Laird instead of Buchanan as he's better going forward

But with Wiseman and Laird as the fullbacks the formation isn't all that narrow. In addition Keane playing on the right of the midfield three would provide energy and pace there. A player who would do well on the left might be King. In fact you could probably pick any three of Welsh, Kilkenny, Keane, King and Brownhill (who can also of course play the Gallagher role just behind a front two) and have an effective midfield. Hayhurst might also be effective on the left of that sort of set-up.
 
Buchanan all day for me too. But...it's refreshing that we have two quality players for the left back position. I remember a time when our only option was Ray Sharp.

It depends on who's playing left midfield too, with laird going forward he leaves spaces behind him, and there's not much cover tbh it's looks like bailey-wright looks more comfortable with buchs beside him that why he's playing so well too, so it's swings and roundabouts, the scary thing is GW said Buchanan couldn't play left-back, lololololololol
 
Back
Top