Skip to main content

Team for Wednesday

Team for Wednesday

Joined
Jun 7, 2004
Messages
24,668
A number of posers for SG. Presuming we revert to the 4.3.3 we used for the last home game then a recall for Cunningham seems likely especially as Spurr seems to have got a bit of a roasting today. In midfield the platform that Pearson and Welsh give us also seems likely to be maintained but who will accompany them - Johnson did not seem to get in the game much today while both Gallagher and Pringle made a difference. Upfront if McGeady is fit then you will imagine he may come back at the expense of Humphrey but will Makienok get a start at the expense of Robinson - a dilemma that may not come to pass if McGeady is still unavailable. Also if Vermilj is fit will he resume to give us a bit more mobility at the back.

Despite our late rally today I am not convinced that Makienok and Hugill make for a good starting partnership. But let's see. My guess - not necessarily my preference - is that the team may be:

Maxwell

Baptiste, Huntington, Clarke, Cunningham

Pearson, Welsh, Gallagher

Hugill, Makienok, Robinson
 
Last edited:
Welsh won't be fit for this game according to one of the Evening Post reporters.

I would think Bailey Wright comes back into contention for a starting place, after all the travelling he's done in the previous week it was probably right that he didn't start.

I'm not sure about the front 3 you suggest. We'd pretty much have a non-existent right hand side. I really hope McGeady is fit.
 
Maxwell

Baptiste
Clarke
Wright
Cunningham

Pearson
Browne
DJ

McGeady
Hugill
Robinson

Lindegaard, Hunts, Grimshaw, Humphrey, Gally, Makienok, Doyle
 
I'm not sure about the front 3 you suggest. We'd pretty much have a non-existent right hand side. I really hope McGeady is fit.

Thanks - but as I indicated it what I think SG may go for not what I would choose. If McGeady is fit then I would go for him, Hugill and Robinson as in the last home game. If he isn't then I might switch Robinson to the right and give Pringle a start up front on the left. As for Makienok while pumping high balls up to him and Hugill may work as a last gasp tactic - as it did today - I don't think the two of them together make for the right sort of partnership for the fast, fluid, attacking game we want to play at home. So however harsh it might seem I would leave him on the bench for Wednesday. It does seem that after Hugill has run the opposition ragged with his mix of presence and pace for 70 minutes or so that Makienok's arrival really is very uncomfortable for the opposing defenders and that they cannot deal with it.
 
Last edited:
Thanks - but as I indicated it what I think SG may go for not what I would choose. If McGeady is fit then I would go for him, Hugill and Robinson as in the last home game. If he isn't then I might switch Robinson to the right and give Pringle a start up front on the left. As for Makienok while pumping high balls up to him and Hugill may work as a last gasp tactic - as it did today - I don't think the two of them together make for the right sort of partnership for the fast, fluid, attacking game we want to play at home. So however harsh it might seem I would leave him on the bench for Wednesday. It does seem that after Hugill has run the opposition ragged with his mix of presence and pace for 70 minutes or so that Makienok's arrival really is very uncomfortable for the opposing defenders and that they cannot deal with it.

I agree about the strikers.

Both Hugill and Makienok deserve to be starting right now, but as a partnership it probably just wouldn't work.

It's unfortunate but for now one has to miss out.
 
Given SG's current stance of sticking behind those with the shirt who are doing well, I suspect that he may consider keeping Spurr in the team at his preferred position of left back and benching Cunningham. However, with Gally and Pringle finishing the game strongly, I wouldnt be surprised to see the following starting 11:

Maxwell

Baptiste
Clarke
Huntingdon (wright)
Spurr

Pearson
DJ
Gallagher

Pringle (McGeady if fit)
Hugill
Robinson
 
Given SG's current stance of sticking behind those with the shirt who are doing well, I suspect that he may consider keeping Spurr in the team at his preferred position of left back and benching Cunningham. However, with Gally and Pringle finishing the game strongly, I wouldnt be surprised to see the following starting 11:

Maxwell

Baptiste
Clarke
Huntingdon (wright)
Spurr

Pearson
DJ
Gallagher

Pringle (McGeady if fit)
Hugill
Robinson

That wouldn't surprise me either. Pringle is beginning to make an impact - that Bournemouth game which so many people wrote off beforehand not merely as something we would not win but as unimportant in any case is now starting to look like a major turning point for the season. But if he is played as one of the front three then it has to be on the left with Robinson switched to the right.

But a midfield three with both Gallagher and Johnson in it is verging on being a bit lightweight. I think in Welch's absence it has to be one or other of them with Pearson and Browne. Of course if McGeady is unavailable then a midfield of Browne, Pearson and Gallagher with Johnson in a free role just behind Hugill and Robinson is another possibility - it is maybe a way to get Gallagher and Johnson on the field together at the same time without really cramping either of their styles.
 
That wouldn't surprise me either. Pringle is beginning to make an impact - that Bournemouth game which so many people wrote off beforehand not merely as something we would not win but as unimportant in any case is now starting to look like a major turning point for the season. But if he is played as one of the front three then it has to be on the left with Robinson switched to the right.

But a midfield three with both Gallagher and Johnson in it is verging on being a bit lightweight. I think in Welch's absence it has to be one or other of them with Pearson and Browne. Of course if McGeady is unavailable then a midfield of Browne, Pearson and Gallagher with Johnson in a free role just behind Hugill and Robinson is another possibility - it is maybe a way to get Gallagher and Johnson on the field together at the same time without really cramping either of their styles.

I don't see Pringle as one of a front three, he just hasn't got the pace. If Grayson goes for 4-3-3/4-5-1/4-1-4-1, I can see Doyle being brought in on the right (again, no pace) or maybe Humphrey who has played there before.

Maxwell

Baptiste
Clarke
Wright
Cunningham

Grimshaw

Humphrey
Pearson
Johnson
Robinson

Hugill
 
Last edited:
I don't see Pringle as one of a front three, he just hasn't got the pace. If Grayson goes for 4-3-3/4-5-1/4-1-4-1, I can see Doyle being brought in on the right (again, no pace) or maybe Humphrey who has played there before.

Maxwell

Baptiste
Clarke
Wright
Cunningham

Grimshaw

Humphrey
Pearson
Johnson
Robinson

Hugill

I can see the point of what you say about Pringle. As for Humphrey in a front three well I have always thought that that is the one position apart from wing-back in which he might have some effect though only as a sub late-on against tiring defenders otherwise his lack of invention will just make him too easy to contain. But at home we need to play with at last two upfront and as we saw at Brentford even before the collapse and in the first 70 minutes against Wigan a flat four-man midfield is recipe for stagnation. As such if McGeady is unavailable then I might go with the option of Johnson 'in the slot' in front of a midfield three and just behind a pair of strikers.
 
I don't see Pringle as one of a front three, he just hasn't got the pace. If Grayson goes for 4-3-3/4-5-1/4-1-4-1, I can see Doyle being brought in on the right (again, no pace) or maybe Humphrey who has played there before.

Maxwell

Baptiste
Clarke
Wright
Cunningham

Grimshaw

Humphrey
Pearson
Johnson
Robinson

Hugill

I can see the point of what you say about Pringle. As for Humphrey in a front three well I have always thought that that is the one position apart from wing-back in which he might have some effect though only as a sub late-on against tiring defenders otherwise his lack of invention will just make him too easy to contain.
But at home we need to play with at least two upfront and as we saw at Brentford even before the collapse and in the first 70 minutes against Wigan a flat four-man midfield is a recipe for stagnation. As such if McGeady is unavailable then I might go with the option of Johnson 'in the slot' in front of a midfield three and just behind a pair of strikers.
 
I agree about the strikers.

Both Hugill and Makienok deserve to be starting right now, but as a partnership it probably just wouldn't work.

It's unfortunate but for now one has to miss out.

Hugill is more mobile thus he starts.

Big Mak to come off the bench for the onslaught.
 
Back
Top