Skip to main content

Team So Far

Team So Far

Joined
Jun 7, 2004
Messages
24,667
Well if we made no more signings then a line-up for the start of next season might be:

Maxwell

Woods, Huntington, Boyle, Cunningham

Gallagher, Pearson, Harrop

Barkhuizen, Hugill, Robinson

Subs: Rudd, Vermilj, Davies, Browne, Johnson, Horgan, May/Maguire

The only obvious weakness there is a lack of real quality/experience in central defence where very obviously at least one maybe two signings are required. Add a forceful central midfielder and you-know-who upfront and we really would look like a pretty good team. So still work to do on the transfer front but things are shaping up.
 
I would see Harrop going into a forward slot like one of the wide roles there, instead of in central midfield.
 
that defence looks a little weak

Any constructive things to say other than criticising players that got us into the top half of the table for two consecutive seasons?

Should we take your advice and sign Jordan Rhodes to play him there? Moron.
 
Well if we made no more signings then a line-up for the start of next season might be:

Maxwell

Woods, Huntington, Boyle, Cunningham

Gallagher, Pearson, Harrop

Barkhuizen, Hugill, Robinson

Subs: Rudd, Vermilj, Davies, Browne, Johnson, Horgan, May/Maguire

The only obvious weakness there is a lack of real quality/experience in central defence where very obviously at least one maybe two signings are required. Add a forceful central midfielder and you-know-who upfront and we really would look like a pretty good team. So still work to do on the transfer front but things are shaping up.

It's pretty obvious to all that we probably need to make 1 permanent Centre back signing & another on a season long loan. Then hope that eventually Tom Clarke can come back as the player that we know he is.
 
It's pretty obvious to all that we probably need to make 1 permanent Centre back signing & another on a season long loan.

Indeed - I was just making the point that we already have plenty of talent in midfield and upfront even without McGeady though, as I keep saying, a combative midfielder is still required. Yes obviously the central defence needs bolstering with one or maybe two new recruits. Right the priorities are central defence and then central midfield.
 
Any constructive things to say other than criticising players that got us into the top half of the table for two consecutive seasons?

Should we take your advice and sign Jordan Rhodes to play him there? Moron.

Huntington and Boyle got us into the top half two years running? Clarke + Wright did that once and Clarke and Huntington the second time. The end of the season proved that we're not good enough at the back without Clarke, no matter how good our full backs are. I haven't seen enough of Boyle to make a decision on him but I don't think he's half the player Clarke is.

The defense does look a little weak and I'm sure it's an area we'll strengthen in.
 
Huntington and Boyle got us into the top half two years running? Clarke + Wright did that once and Clarke and Huntington the second time. The end of the season proved that we're not good enough at the back without Clarke, no matter how good our full backs are. I haven't seen enough of Boyle to make a decision on him but I don't think he's half the player Clarke is.

The defense does look a little weak and I'm sure it's an area we'll strengthen in.

Not arguing that they aren't first choice, and I agree they need competition/an upgrade if we're to progress.

Huntington is a decent defender. No nonsense, good in the air, and I'm sure he was involved in our clean sheet run in our first season back as well as being brilliant this season. He isn't easy on the eye, but he's effective. Boyle has looked decent when I've seen him and I've got a good feeling about him. Still too early to say things like he's half the player Clarke is - those are big shoes to fill and I don't think he's looked out of his depth like you're suggesting.

Baptiste I feel will come back and be a good addition, and A.N.Other coming in would be less of a bonus but more of a necessity given how thin on the ground we look there. I trust we'll get it right, just as we have in the last two summers at this level.
 
In an ideal world for me it would be...

Rudd

Woods
Baptiste
Huntington
Cunningham

Gallagher
Pearson
Johnson

McGeady
Hugill
Harrop

I think Huntington still has a big role to play, he is great in the air, a good organiser and lets not forget he has improved every year since he came here and is a model pro. He is still relatively young for a centre half that has never been blessed with pace also.
 
Id go something like this in a 3-4-1-2

Rudd

Woods Boyle Cunningham

McGeady (if we get him) Johnson Pearson Robinson

Harrop

Maguire May/Hugill

Subs:
Gallagher
Horgan
Barkhuizen
Huntington
O'Connor
Maxwell
Hugill or May

Harrop/Maguire are PROSPECTS.One has played one senior game for Man U and the other none at this level, yet some are saying they should start over players PROVEN AT THIS LEVEL.
Lets see the lads play before placing them in the messiah bracket;maybe they will adjust quickly, maybe they will need time as all players are different.

BOTH SEEMINGLY GOOD ADDITIONS NONETHELESS.

IN SG WE TRUST.
 
Harrop/Maguire are PROSPECTS.One has played one senior game for Man U and the other none at this level, yet some are saying they should start over players PROVEN AT THIS LEVEL.
Lets see the lads play before placing them in the messiah bracket;maybe they will adjust quickly, maybe they will need time as all players are different.

BOTH SEEMINGLY GOOD ADDITIONS NONETHELESS.

IN SG WE TRUST.

Maguire maybe due to the level he has come from, but Harrop? He was very highly rated at United, scored a great goal on his Premier League debut and was top scorer for their under 23's. We have also reportedly paid close to a million quid for him. He starts, simple as that.
 
Not arguing that they aren't first choice, and I agree they need competition/an upgrade if we're to progress.

Huntington is a decent defender. No nonsense, good in the air, and I'm sure he was involved in our clean sheet run in our first season back as well as being brilliant this season. He isn't easy on the eye, but he's effective. Boyle has looked decent when I've seen him and I've got a good feeling about him. Still too early to say things like he's half the player Clarke is - those are big shoes to fill and I don't think he's looked out of his depth like you're suggesting.

Baptiste I feel will come back and be a good addition, and A.N.Other coming in would be less of a bonus but more of a necessity given how thin on the ground we look there. I trust we'll get it right, just as we have in the last two summers at this level.

Sorry if I came across as a bit aggressive there. Boyle is young and will get better but I still think Clarke is the best centre half we've had here since Mawéné and is probably one of the best in the league. Boyle seemed to lack sharpness and fitness but that should come with a preseason.

Baptiste would be a good addition but where would he fit in? Huntington is crucial for his ability in the air which our defense lack without Clarke, and we want to give Boyle a chance to develop. I'd only want him to sign as cover really.
 
Id go something like this in a 3-4-1-2

Rudd

Woods Boyle Cunningham

McGeady (if we get him) Johnson Pearson Robinson

Harrop

Maguire May/Hugill

Subs:
Gallagher
Horgan
Barkhuizen
Huntington
O'Connor
Maxwell
Hugill or May

I'm not sure how I feel about playing 2 full backs in central defense with McGeady and Robinson as wingbacks. We'd be very vulnerable on the flanks. It'd have to be 4-4-2 or 4-3-3 for me.
 
Maguire maybe due to the level he has come from, but Harrop? He was very highly rated at United, scored a great goal on his Premier League debut and was top scorer for their under 23's. We have also reportedly paid close to a million quid for him. He starts, simple as that.
U23s is virtually non contact football.
We don't pick the team but if SG says he's ready and starts that will do for me.Maguire has a lot more to prove but the same applies.

IN SG WE TRUST
 
Id go something like this in a 3-4-1-2

Rudd

Woods Boyle Cunningham

McGeady (if we get him) Johnson Pearson Robinson

Harrop

Maguire May/Hugill

Subs:
Gallagher
Horgan
Barkhuizen
Huntington
O'Connor
Maxwell
Hugill or May
Woods and Cunningham can do a job at centre half in a three, but you wouldn't want either there on a regular basis - and certainly not both at once. Ahead of that you've got Pearson and six attackers. Looks like suicide to me!
 
Selecting only those confirmed as with us next year:

Maxwell

Barhuizan, Woods, Huntington, Boyle, Cunningham

Gallagher, Pearson, Harrop

Robinson, Hugill,

Subs: Rudd, Vermilj, Davies, Browne, Horgan, May, Maguire
 
I'd go with

Maxwell

Woods Huntingdon Boyle Cunningham

Pearson Gallagher

Barkhuizen Harrop Horgan

Hugill​

Fluid three behind Hugill with Barkhuizen playing as more forward than winger. Would prefer someone a bit more combative than Gallagher alongside Pearson ideally.
 
Back
Top