Skip to main content

Team So Far

Team So Far

Because he's a really good player and options at the moment with what we have got is Welsh Browne grimshaw Johnson or gally to play along side Pearson!

Gallagher regularly misses games though, and looks very un-athletic and wooden when played in a midfield 2. I don't doubt what a good player he is/has been for us but I'm not sure he'll be a regular next season.

When you break the options in central midfield down, they really aren't that great due to regular suspensions, injuries and inconsistency, and for that reason I think it's vital that another is signed.
 
Yeah agreed 100% so gally or Welsh best of a poor bunch At the moment then. Are we still not hopeful Browne or grimshaw can do the job? Or simply not good enough my guess is probably the latter
 
Because he's a really good player and options at the moment with what we have got is Welsh Browne grimshaw Johnson or gally to play along side Pearson!

Doesn't have to be the same team in every situation. A more defensive shield would include Pearson, Welsh, Browne. Other players are more offensive when we are looked to take a game on.
 
I honestly don't think we will see much of Welsh this season. He is much too slow and I was under the impression that he was not fully recovered yet.

Sent from my SM-A310F using Tapatalk
 
I honestly don't think we will see much of Welsh this season. He is much too slow and I was under the impression that he was not fully recovered yet.

Sent from my SM-A310F using Tapatalk


Welsh has been a great servant of the club but in truth it was a mistake to give him his last contract extension. But maybe we can get a few last hurrahs from him in the coming season.
 
in my opinion - I think looking at all the teams so far its quite clear to see we actually have a squad this year which if we suffer injuries and suspensions we can bring in quality players which previously we haven't had the option to do. I think the starting 11 will solely be based on the pre season fitness and performances of everyone during the friendlies. but taking that aside I would have.

Rudd
Woods - Huntington - Boyle - Cunningham
Barkhuzien - Pearson - DJ - Horgan
Harrop - Hugill

harrop isn't really a striker but should suit him if he play off hugill's knock downs and pick up any lose balls from crosses etc.
 
Pretty well my suggested team though I still think that playing Barkhuizen wide in a four-man midfield fails to make the most of him - he is much more dangerous when running at the opposition in more central positions, which is why I would go for a 4.3.3. McGeady may or may not return - if he does I suspect it might as last time be right on the deadline. But right now a commanding central defender is the absolute priority with a more mobile central defender (maybe Baptiste) and an aggressive central midfielder not too far behind in importance. McGeady would obviously still be a great boost but he is looking increasingly as if he would be an added - albeit considerable - extra rather than something absolutely essential.

I'd agree with that. Bearing in mind we also have Horgan to play wide and DJ centrally we're quite well off for creative players.
 
in my opinion - I think looking at all the teams so far its quite clear to see we actually have a squad this year which if we suffer injuries and suspensions we can bring in quality players which previously we haven't had the option to do. I think the starting 11 will solely be based on the pre season fitness and performances of everyone during the friendlies. but taking that aside I would have.

Rudd
Woods - Huntington - Boyle - Cunningham
Barkhuzien - Pearson - DJ - Horgan
Harrop - Hugill

harrop isn't really a striker but should suit him if he play off hugill's knock downs and pick up any lose balls from crosses etc.

4-4-1-1 could work but that midfield 2 looks a bit lightweight.
 
Astonished by how many on this thread opt for Rudd who played for us three years ago in league one.

You certainly follow Grayson and his nepotism for previous loanees. Would not be surprised to see maxwell kicked in the teeth.
 
Astonished by how many on this thread opt for Rudd who played for us three years ago in league one.

You certainly follow Grayson and his nepotism for previous loanees. Would not be surprised to see maxwell kicked in the teeth.

It's not a kick in the teeth, it's everyone starting with a clean slate as it should be, and Maxwell was far from perfect last season. It's just good to see we now have 2 genuine number 1 keepers.
 
not sure you could call Pearson lightweight

Rudd

Woods - Huntington - Boyle - Cunningham

Robo - Pearson - Harrop - Horgan-

Barkhieuzn

Hugill

I wouldn't to his face but I'd rather play him in a three with someone else doing the dirty work and let him play box to box instead.
 
It's not a kick in the teeth, it's everyone starting with a clean slate as it should be, and Maxwell was far from perfect last season. It's just good to see we now have 2 genuine number 1 keepers.

Love to know where maxwell was deficient...

Sticking to the point if you think teams are picked on pre season form then you have a lot of football experience to pick up. By game 2 the first choice is already playing as a priority. Other combinations are simply being tested out for future events and not the first game of the season.

if maxwell is not the club number 1 at the start of the season then prey tell why this is not a kick in the teeth?

Let's not forget -
70% save rate (check yourself against other top keepers)
Highest number of collected crosses in championship
Highest number of interceptions made in the championship
Blah blah blah!
 
Maxwell to start all day long for me.

I am 50/50 really, just down to the amount of goals we conceded near the end but admittedly the major factor there was a general end of season feeling and injuries to our back four.

I'm a fan of both and pleased we have two good keepers to fight for the place in the team.

I think a lot might see Maxwell (wrongly) as a bit dodgy due to the fact he scares them half to death with his mental charges from his goal to head things away 40 yards out!
 
Back
Top