Skip to main content

Team v Orient

Team v Orient

Joined
Oct 8, 2012
Messages
347
Location
English Riviera
With Hume and Hayhurst away on international duty and Beavon suspended we are down to 18 available players for Saturday. So the squad more or less picks itself unless we get a loan signing in this week.
What about the starting X1 ? What formation ? With the prospect of facing Lisbie and Mooney upfront I think SG will revert to the 3-4-1-2 formation. I think the team will be as follows :-
Rudd
Clarke Huntington Wright
Humphrey Keane Welsh Laird
Gallagher
Davies Garner

Subs:- Stuckmann, Buchanan, Nicholson, King, Brownhill, Byrom, Holmes
 
Rudd
Clarke Huntington Wright
Humphrey Keane Welsh Laird
Gallagher
Davies Garner

Subs:- Stuckmann, Buchanan, Nicholson, King, Brownhill, Byrom, Holmes

I'd go with that as well.

Harsh to leave out Holmes but Orient are capable of giving us a smashing so we need to focus on keeping it tight here and Humphrey does his defensive duties well.
 
With Hume and Hayhurst away on international duty and Beavon suspended we are down to 18 available players for Saturday. So the squad more or less picks itself unless we get a loan signing in this week.
What about the starting X1 ? What formation ? With the prospect of facing Lisbie and Mooney upfront I think SG will revert to the 3-4-1-2 formation. I think the team will be as follows :-
Rudd
Clarke Huntington Wright
Humphrey Keane Welsh Laird
Gallagher
Davies Garner

Subs:- Stuckmann, Buchanan, Nicholson, King, Brownhill, Byrom, Holmes
I agree with this & King as our back up striker. The only other option on the subs bench is if we bring in a loan player before Saturday, has anyone heard on whether this might happen yet Re bringing in another Loan player?
 
With Hume and Hayhurst away on international duty and Beavon suspended we are down to 18 available players for Saturday. So the squad more or less picks itself unless we get a loan signing in this week.
What about the starting X1 ? What formation ? With the prospect of facing Lisbie and Mooney upfront I think SG will revert to the 3-4-1-2 formation. I think the team will be as follows :-

Rudd
Clarke Huntington Wright
Humphrey Keane Welsh Laird
Gallagher
Davies Garner

Subs:- Stuckmann, Buchanan, Nicholson, King, Brownhill, Byrom, Holmes

I'd go with that against top of the league away definitely
 
Not sure what Holmes has done to get dropped in this fantasy line up. I know he went off with a knock. But if he's fit he plays surely?
 
Not sure what Holmes has done to get dropped in this fantasy line up. I know he went off with a knock. But if he's fit he plays surely?

Correct.

3 assists v Barnet. He does what Humphrey cannot do, play the ball into goalscoring positions.

Holmes to start every day of the week. Humphrey as a sub to come on as fresh defensive legs for the last 20 minutes if winning and under the cosh.
 
I'd go:

Rudd
Clarke Huntington Wright Laird
Humphrey Keane Welsh Holmes
Gallagher
Garner

Subs:- Stuckmann, Buchanan, Nicholson, King, Brownhill, Byrom, Davies
 
Correct.

3 assists v Barnet. He does what Humphrey cannot do, play the ball into goalscoring positions.

Holmes to start every day of the week. Humphrey as a sub to come on as fresh defensive legs for the last 20 minutes if winning and under the cosh.

Holmes is a class act but if we're playing 3-5-2 (which would be sensible against top of the league) then i don't think he is up to the job defensively. He would need to keep tabs on one of the best players in the division in Dean Cox as I can see us being on the back foot a lot on Saturday.

If we play 4-4-2 then it is Holmes all day long but Humphrey does a good job as a wing back, especially away from home.
 
Big match so big players have to play ie the experience of Kevin Davies will be invaluable.

Its a tough call Holmes or Humphrey as both give something different to the team but on a positive note.
 
Not sure what Holmes has done to get dropped in this fantasy line up. I know he went off with a knock. But if he's fit he plays surely?

Good player yes but against top of the league we need defensive cover at wing backs and unless you play him behind the front two (instead of Gallagher) where do you play him.

He would start every week in a 442 for me
 
Good player yes but against top of the league we need defensive cover at wing backs and unless you play him behind the front two (instead of Gallagher) where do you play him.

He would start every week in a 442 for me

Sounds like you're setting up for a defensive draw.

Myself?

Attack them, get the lead and then frustrate them. Make defensive subs for the last 20. (Holmes off, Humphrey on).

Southport managed to put 2 past them, everyone on here seems to think we are playing Barcelona away...hello...it's Leyton Orient, who whilst they have made a fantastic start, are not unbeatable.

I would rather lose by taking the game to them than suffer, say, a 1 - 0 away defeat like we did, as an example, away to Sheff Utd in the POs of 2009.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like you're setting up for a defensive draw.

Myself?

Attack them, get the lead and then frustrate them. Make defensive subs for the last 20. (Holmes off, Humphrey on).

Southport managed to put 2 past them, everyone on here seems to think we are playing Barcelona away...hello...it's Leyton Orient, who whilst they have made a fantastic start, are not unbeatable.

I would rather lose by taking the game to them than suffer, say, a 1 - 0 away defeat like we did, as an example, away to Sheff Utd in the POs of 2009.


I'd take a draw as I believe would our manager
 
Sounds like you're setting up for a defensive draw.

Myself?

Attack them, get the lead and then frustrate them. Make defensive subs for the last 20. (Holmes off, Humphrey on).

Southport managed to put 2 past them, everyone on here seems to think we are playing Barcelona away...hello...it's Leyton Orient, who whilst they have made a fantastic start, are not unbeatable.

I would rather lose by taking the game to them than suffer, say, a 1 - 0 away defeat like we did, as an example, away to Sheff Utd in the POs of 2009.

I like this plan, but Grayson plays it safe
 
The problem with reverting to the Humphrey, Welsh, Keane, Laird midfield in a 3.4.1.2 is that in previous matches it has been utterly uncreative and has left our strikers high and dry. I can see that we need a couple of defensive players on the flanks to make the formation work but there is little reason to suppose it would work any better than it has before with those four on the field. Moreover it seems to me that Humphry wasn't rested on Saturday but comprehensively dropped - so why would he be restored so quickly?

What might work would be to use Keane on the right and find a new partner for Welsh in the centre - maybe Brownhill, maybe King, maybe even Holmes. But perhaps we will have a completely new player by the week-end. However good Gallagher may have been on Saturday SG must surely have realised by now that a new central midfielder remains a priority.
 
Last edited:
Team v Orient

Whatever the team, I expect an easy 3 points and a carnival atmosphere akin to the Serie A Town End days, when our fans were in the ascendance, and anything seemed possible because of Johnny Beck, the hero, the saviour, the greatest manager we have ever had.
 
Whatever the team, I expect an easy 3 points and a carnival atmosphere akin to the Serie A Town End days, when our fans were in the ascendance, and anything seemed possible because of Johnny Beck, the hero, the saviour, the greatest manager we have ever had.

Dear me. Johnny Beck the biggest clown who ever managed North End. He took a team down that should never have got relegated the season he took over and failed to get them back up. The nearest I ever came to giving up on North End something I never considered during the re election season. Truly dreadful football under Beck. A really happy day Beck got potted.
Only Westley ever came close to taking Becks worst ever manager at PNE title off him
 
Dear me. Johnny Beck the biggest clown who ever managed North End. He took a team down that should never have got relegated the season he took over and failed to get them back up. The nearest I ever came to giving up on North End something I never considered during the re election season. Truly dreadful football under Beck. A really happy day Beck got potted.
Only Westley ever came close to taking Becks worst ever manager at PNE title off him

Shut it, you got a day out didn't you?
 
Back
Top