Skip to main content

Team Vs Forest

Team Vs Forest

Joined
Dec 18, 2004
Messages
19,671
What do we think then? Gallagher to come back in? Clarke to remain at right back? Hugill to keep his place?

Anyone know what formation Forest have been using recently?

I think I'd go for:

Maxwell
Clarke - Huntington - Boyle - Cunningham
McGeady - Gallagher - Pearson - Horgan
Makienok - Barkhuizen

Subs: Lindegaard, Baptiste, Browne, Johnson, Robinson, Hugill, Beckford
 
Agree but with Hugill for Mak, though seeing how Mak does from the off might be an idea, I just don't see he has the same energy levels.
 
Makienok?! Come on....

Id go for Hugil up top but I'd rest Horgan and try Barkhuizen and Robinson together, hes had a busy week. I believe Manick and Baps are back arent they? Clarke is much better off as CB its just who do you drop out of Boyle and Hunts?
 
Maxwell

Clarke, Boyle, Huntington, Cunningham

Horgan, Pearson, Gallagher, McGeady

Barkhuizen, Hugill
 
---------------Maxwell-------------
-Baptiste, Clarke, Boyle, Cunningham
Horgan, Pearson, Gallagher, McGeady
----------Hugill, Barkhuizen---------
 
---------------Maxwell-------------
-Baptiste, Clarke, Boyle, Cunningham
Horgan, Pearson, Gallagher, McGeady
----------Hugill, Barkhuizen---------

Now if I had posted that somebody would have jumped on me for having something against Huntington. I actually don't but I agree that a central defence of either Clarke or Huntington with someone a bit more mobile - either Boyle or Baptiste - has a bit more balance and agility. With either Vermilj or Woods at right-back we would then have a defence with some pace to match our much faster midfield and attack. If come 5.00pm tomorrow we have at least kept pace with or maybe even closed the gap a bit on the play-off places then the tension really will start to ramp up.
 
I actually don't but I agree that a central defence of either Clarke or Huntington with someone a bit more mobile - either Boyle or Baptiste - has a bit more balance and agility.

Agreed, I like Huntington but against one of the division's poorer sides i'd like to see us try and play it out from the back a little, Boyle and Baptiste allow that.
 
I'd be surprised if after 3 months out Baptiste is back in after just 60 mins in a training ground match and a behind closed doors match vs Fleetwood.
 
Maxwell

Clarke
Hunts
Boyle
Cunningham

Horgan
Gallagher
Pearson
McGeady

Barkhuizen
Hugill

Lindegaard, Baptiste, DJ, Browne, Robinson, Makienok, May
 
Big Mak has only ever scored for PNE as a starter, never as a sub.

He has set up a few though when coming on late. I would start Hugill tomorrow but with a really tough series of games coming up there is probably a case for giving Makienok more time on the pitch - say 20-25 minutes rather than the 10-15 at most he has been getting lately. He and Hugill do not gel as a partnership but they do work well as a double-whammy - Hugill running the defence ragged for an hour or more and then when their legs are getting weary Makienok with his height appearing. Anyhow I think Hugill is due a goal and may well get on the scoresheet tomorrow.
 
Maxwell
Baptiste - Clarke - Huntington - Cunningham
Horgan - Browne/Gallagher - Pearson - McGeady
Barkzuizen - Hugill

Boyle doesn't deserve to be dropped to the bench but with both right backs back I'd prefer Clarke and Huntington in the centre because they have much more game time together. Clarke and Boyle haven't played in a back 4 together yet.

On the bench I want Lindegaard, Boyle, Vermijl, Gallagher, Robinson, Makienok, and May.

Hopefully we'll get to see a good 30 minutes of May. He really needs game time if he's going to find any form and I think the matches against Forrest, Bristol, and Rotherham are perfect opportunities for him
 
Hope Grayson makes his decisions a bit earlier on Sat , that was the biggest failing at ewood park , his subs made a big impact , but just came to late , ten mins earlier and we could have been celebrating a win
 
Back
Top