Skip to main content

Team vs Orient

Team vs Orient

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
Rudd

Wiseman - Clarke - Wright - Laird

Holmes - Welsh - Kilkenny - Gallagher

C.Davies - Garner​

Or

Rudd

Wiseman - Clarke - Wright - Laird

Keane - Kilkenny - Welsh

Gallagher

C.Davies - Garner​

Attack Them From The Off
 
Ron Burgundy;18424 [CENTER said:
Rudd

Wiseman - Clarke - Wright - Laird

Keane - Kilkenny - Welsh

Gallagher

C.Davies - Garner[/CENTER]

QUOTE]

This - the other formation leaves only Welsh and Kilkenny to win the midfield battle, whatever their other merits neither Gallagher nor Holmes are players who can get stuck in and win the ball, and all any opposition would have to do is put three men in the centre of midfield and then get all the possession. That is the battle that has to be won first of all and that needs Welsh, Kilkenny and Keane to ensure that Gallagher, Garner and Davies are not reduced to being spectators. It is the starting formation we now need to stick with - with Brownhill and King as back-up for the midfield trio and Brownhill also as the reserve option for the Gallagher role behind the front two. Wiseman and Laird are both adventurous enough to provide some attacking width. Holmes is an option for later on.
 
Subs: Stuckmann, King, Buchanan, Holmes, Brownhill (if fit) or Humphrey, Beavon or Hume (there really is no need for both of them), K Davies
 
Buchs for Lairdy for me, otherwise that's bob-on. The midfield is picking itself at the minute, particularly in the middle. Where's Brownhill? Injured?
 
Why do people want Buchanan in for Laird?

Laird is twice the player and played really well at Tranmere.
 
Prefer Buchs myself, cha. Think he offers more defensively.

Fair enough, I don't dislike Buchanan but i'm not one of his biggest fans either, he's generally solid at home but he's been absolutely ripped apart in some games on the road this season, Coventry and wolves spring to mind.

He's Laird's understudy for me.
 
Fair enough, I don't dislike Buchanan but i'm not one of his biggest fans either, he's generally solid at home but he's been absolutely ripped apart in some games on the road this season, Coventry and wolves spring to mind.

He's Laird's understudy for me.

True if he comes up against anyone with a bit of skill and pace he is bollocks, the thing is those sort of players are few and far between in this league. Notts county at home he had a torrid first half with Campbell-Ryce.
 
True if he comes up against anyone with a bit of skill and pace he is bollocks, the thing is those sort of players are few and far between in this league. Notts county at home he had a torrid first half with Campbell-Ryce.

I still don't understand why people think Laird offers significantly less defensively than Buchanan.

Just becasue Laird likes to attack doesn't mean he can't defend either!

Second formation for me - I think the way the midfield three worked against Forest was highly encouraging and it makes best use of Gallagher as well who is more of a forward than a winger.
 
Rudd

Wiseman - Clarke - Wright - Buchanan

Holmes - Welsh - Kilkenny - Gallagher

C.Davies - Garner

or

Rudd

Wiseman - Clarke - Wright - Buchanan

Gally - Keane - Welsh - Kilkenny - Laird

Garner
 
if all we can argue about is whether Laird or Buchanan is the better choice, we must be in a good way.

The only difference for me is that Laird tends to come in field more when attacking, whereas Buchanan tends to go to the outside and get to the by-line before crossing.

Both lack a bit of pace, and Laird is probably a bit stronger. But, both very good options!
 
Back
Top