Skip to main content

Team vs Port Vale

Team vs Port Vale

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
Rudd

Clarke - King - Wright

Humphrey - Kilkenny - Welsh - Laird

Gallagher

Garner - Hume​

Davies needs a rest for me, great link up play but my Grandma could have scored some of the chances that fell his way yesterday.
 
Rudd

Clarke - King - Wright

Humphrey - Kilkenny - Welsh - Laird

Gallagher

Garner - Hume​

Davies needs a rest for me, great link up play but my Grandma could have scored some of the chances that fell his way yesterday.

Humphrey to start? You cannot be serious. 😱
 
Rudd

Wright
King
Huntington
Laird

Holmes
Keane
Kilkenny
Hayhurst

Gallagher

Garner
 
Last edited:
Rudd

Clarke - King - Wright

Humphrey - Kilkenny - Welsh - Laird

Gallagher

Garner - Hume​

Davies needs a rest for me, great link up play but my Grandma could have scored some of the chances that fell his way yesterday.

Clarke looked like he'd done his calf to me and I would never leave out Davies unless he lost a leg.
 
We must not revert to three at the back with Humphrey and Laird wide - it is a recipe for utter sterility. Whatever we do let's stick with four at the back. As for Tuesday if all the players who started on Saturday are fit then give the same formation another chance. If one or other of Clarke and Welsh are not fit then slot Keane in in their place. If both are unfit then Keane should go in central midfield and I would give the lad Nicholson, who is a right-back after all, a chance to show what he can do in a proper game. I suppose there might be a case for restoring Humphrey at right midfield if only for his defensive capabilities though I did wonder earlier whether he might actually make a better right back than midfielder. Despite his misses on Saturday Davies has played well away from home and should start. But if we play with four at the back and Gallagher behind a front two then a balanced three-man midfield might comprise Kilkenny, Welsh or Keane and Brownhill.
 
Rudd

Clarke - King - Wright

Humphrey - Kilkenny - Welsh - Laird

Gallagher

Garner - Hume​

Davies needs a rest for me, great link up play but my Grandma could have scored some of the chances that fell his way yesterday.

I wouldn't have Humphrey anywhere near the squad, never mind the starting 11
 
Humphrey ducked out of a 60/40 on Saturday................in his favour for crying out loud!!!!

How do you measure the mathematic ratio of a challenge? For instance, if a challenge is 53/47 do you need to round it up/down to the closest multiples of 10?
 
How do you measure the mathematic ratio of a challenge? For instance, if a challenge is 53/47 do you need to round it up/down to the closest multiples of 10?

I think you know what I mean without the benefit of scientific explanation. Going off your (slightly) pedantic point, every time anyone quotes a 50/50 challenge, one could pose your question because there isn't anyone with a tape measure checking at the point of the challenge. But I do see your point, do you see mine?? 🙂
 
I think you know what I mean without the benefit of scientific explanation. Going off your (slightly) pedantic point, every time anyone quotes a 50/50 challenge, one could pose your question because there isn't anyone with a tape measure checking at the point of the challenge. But I do see your point, do you see mine?? 🙂

Not really. 😉
 
Not really. 😉


OK, the point being Humphrey often ducks out of challenges/tackles. I was using the benefit of exaggeration to illustrate how "soft" he is when faced with the possibility of having to make a challenge in which he could get hurt. Compare the 50/50 made by Clarke in the second half to the one that Humphrey "avoided" and you will see clearly the point I am (somewhat badly perhaps) trying to make.
 
OK, the point being Humphrey often ducks out of challenges/tackles. I was using the benefit of exaggeration to illustrate how "soft" he is when faced with the possibility of having to make a challenge in which he could get hurt. Compare the 50/50 made by Clarke in the second half to the one that Humphrey "avoided" and you will see clearly the point I am (somewhat badly perhaps) trying to make.

I distinctly remember Hump ducking out of a 59/41, but it definitely wasn't a 60/40 so we may be referring to different challenges.

What ratio is acceptable to duck out of? 40/60? 45/55?

I'm confused.
 
I distinctly remember Hump ducking out of a 59/41, but it definitely wasn't a 60/40 so we may be referring to different challenges.

What ratio is acceptable to duck out of? 40/60? 45/55?

I'm confused.

He! He! very good, very good......nice try! May I say, you are easily confused? 🙂
 
We must not revert to three at the back with Humphrey and Laird wide - it is a recipe for utter sterility. Whatever we do let's stick with four at the back. As for Tuesday if all the players who started on Saturday are fit then give the same formation another chance. If one or other of Clarke and Welsh are not fit then slot Keane in in their place. If both are unfit then Keane should go in central midfield and I would give the lad Nicholson, who is a right-back after all, a chance to show what he can do in a proper game. I suppose there might be a case for restoring Humphrey at right midfield if only for his defensive capabilities though I did wonder earlier whether he might actually make a better right back than midfielder. Despite his misses on Saturday Davies has played well away from home and should start. But if we play with four at the back and Gallagher behind a front two then a balanced three-man midfield might comprise Kilkenny, Welsh or Keane and Brownhill.

It's got to be 352 after the LO result and not 4 at the back. For that reason Humphrey will start for Holmes and I expect that to be the only change if Davies can manage a second game in 3 days and if Welsh and Clarke are fit.

Forget Nicholson. He is nowhere near a first team place.
 
I though Holmes missed his opportunity on Saturday. Good player but for the amount of ball he had there was a lack of quality crosses.

As we are away from home, and given recent performances and results away, Humphreys hasnt done anything to warrant being dropped.
 
Back
Top