We must not revert to three at the back with Humphrey and Laird wide - it is a recipe for utter sterility. Whatever we do let's stick with four at the back. As for Tuesday if all the players who started on Saturday are fit then give the same formation another chance. If one or other of Clarke and Welsh are not fit then slot Keane in in their place. If both are unfit then Keane should go in central midfield and I would give the lad Nicholson, who is a right-back after all, a chance to show what he can do in a proper game. I suppose there might be a case for restoring Humphrey at right midfield if only for his defensive capabilities though I did wonder earlier whether he might actually make a better right back than midfielder. Despite his misses on Saturday Davies has played well away from home and should start. But if we play with four at the back and Gallagher behind a front two then a balanced three-man midfield might comprise Kilkenny, Welsh or Keane and Brownhill.