Skip to main content

That decision..

  • Thread starter Thread starter JK
  • Start date Start date

That decision..

He allowed an extra 30 seconds for the substitution so I've no grouse about time added on at the end. However as you said ddreamer virtually all the 50:50s went the away side and Clarke booked for absolutely no reason. Blowing up as Robinson was it? put that cross in was one of the most unbelievable decisions I have seen.
 
He allowed an extra 30 seconds for the substitution so I've no grouse about time added on at the end. However as you said ddreamer virtually all the 50:50s went the away side and Clarke booked for absolutely no reason. Blowing up as Robinson was it? put that cross in was one of the most unbelievable decisions I have seen.

Yep agree- the Clarke booking was ridiculous - they were trying to get him sent off as last Man when he was no where near the last Player between the goal.
It was a 'cute' run into the Player to gain a foul, so should not have been given as a foul or a booking.

At some stages of the game it seemed like every time THEY claimed for something he gave it to them.
For what its worth I often defend the Refs and 'try' to be unbiased. Today I was a little 'disappointed' to say the least!!
 
Just when you think referees can't get any worse, another incumbent steps up to the plate. I thought the refereeing in the Championship would be far better than L1, but that does not seem to be the case.
 
When the referee played on when a Brighton player fell over, then waited for us to centre it, then stopped the game...

Has to go down as one of the most ridiculous decisions I've ever seen.

Must admit I thought there would be a huge difference between officials in league one and the championship. Sadly there really isn't.
Correct, JK. A right fucking stinker of a decision.
 
As bad as the decision was the resulting drop ball added insult to injury (no injury) why Why why do we not have a proper drop ball anymore?
Exactly. The ref needlessly stopped it, so it should have been a contested drop ball on the 6yd line, surely?
 
I think both Hughton and Grayson thought the ref was a clown, you could see them shaking their heads at each other at some of the decisions.

From my perspective, he was intimidated by Dunk and Goldson and let them manage the game. A weak referee.
 
Half what through the first half I thought the ref was having a good game (I sit miles away from the Clarke booking and took the view their lad was always going to go down in that position). It went massively downhill. The Brighton centre backs seemed determined to get garner booked. He handled himself well yesterday and was a credit to the team. Being kicked and contestant play acting from the pair he stayed well out of it.

I was in front of knockheart retalliating against Bailey Wright though right in front of the linesman who did nothing.

Considering their last results they didn't really seem to want to beat us rather disrupt our game and Nick one.

Both offsides seemed clear the first the liners flag was up before he hit the ball the second I was in line with and even the Brighton player paused knowing he was off.

I can imagine the Brighton fans taking the view that they were on the rough end of the ref for not getting more north Enders in the book
 
Half what through the first half I thought the ref was having a good game (I sit miles away from the Clarke booking and took the view their lad was always going to go down in that position). It went massively downhill. The Brighton centre backs seemed determined to get garner booked. He handled himself well yesterday and was a credit to the team. Being kicked and contestant play acting from the pair he stayed well out of it.

I was in front of knockheart retalliating against Bailey Wright though right in front of the linesman who did nothing.

Considering their last results they didn't really seem to want to beat us rather disrupt our game and Nick one.

Both offsides seemed clear the first the liners flag was up before he hit the ball the second I was in line with and even the Brighton player paused knowing he was off.

I can imagine the Brighton fans taking the view that they were on the rough end of the ref for not getting more north Enders in the book

I thought BW conducted himself really well at times as Knockeart was a cheating irritating little shite and for a large part of the game Brighton just tried to get our players in trouble dropping like flies. I like Chris Hughton but I didn't like the way they played with their constant diving. From what I saw yesterday I hope they dont get promoted and let's be honest the referee just fuelled their play acting which certainly didn't help things and just encouraged them to keep trying it on. On a positive note I thought our players dealt with it well and barring the first 25 mins I thought we played well yet again against a top four side.
 
Yesterdays referee certainly seemed to favour the Seagulls.
Throughout the course of the game he seemed hell bent on giving every decision to Brighton and was determined that Garner would have to have his head kicked off before he would give him a free kick.
Was quite strange to watch what should be a neutral party being so subtly biased toward one team , is was almost as if he had a secret admiration for Brighton and was trying to disguise it whilst giving them a helping hand towards 3 pts.

Wouldn't go as far as cheating but strongly biased certainly.
 
I was at the game yesterday and although I agree with the majority of the observations I am puzzled that no one has mentioned the one when Huntingdon pulled their chap to the ground. I was at the half way line but it looked a clear foul to me and the ref was right there. I would like to see it again though just to be sure.

What I dont get is this, head injuries you stop play immediately we all accept that but when they receive treatment the ref should keep an eye on it as clearly yesterday godson did not get a head injury and so he should have booked him. That said that ref was similar to kettle, friend and Barry knight in his incompetence.

Roll on Tuesday can't wait for notlob and the plastics who should have won yesterday
 
Last edited:
Just had a text from the mate I was drinking with before the game who was in the BHA end. They were all amazed that they were not down to 10 men for the kick at Garner.
It's one thing not giving free kicks to someone that may be thought to fall down easily, but to ignore thuggery on such a player is refereeing incompetence.
 
Early in the first half down by the TE tunnel there was the most blatant dive from I think it was number 7. He fell like he'd been shot after he had looked back to where the Ref was. Basically he had been caught out slightly and it was his way out. Cheat
 
Early in the first half down by the TE tunnel there was the most blatant dive from I think it was number 7. He fell like he'd been shot after he had looked back to where the Ref was. Basically he had been caught out slightly and it was his way out. Cheat

No 17 Goldson. He was at it all afternoon.
 
I like Chris Hughton but I didn't like the way they played with their constant diving. From what I saw yesterday I hope they dont get promoted and let's be honest the referee just fuelled their play acting which certainly didn't help things and just encouraged them to keep trying.

Considering the abuse we used to get for gamesmanship under GW from away fans (some justified some uninformed) would be interested to know what the rest of the championship thinks of Brighton because that was as bad as I've seen. Diving, kicking, shouting at officials for decisions not even contentious, a horrible team of whiners and cheats.

It would never get in the closed shop media because Chris Hughtons "a nice guy" etc etc.
 
True as some of these observations may be I feel we have surrendered our right to be outraged at diving given the way we back Garner.
 
There was no reason for this inept official to stop play as it wasn't even a head injury and then the cheat wasn't even injured. Too many of Brighton's players were Premiership pretenders, wannabees, fakers, simulators and cheats.

And that's the reason why I am not bothered about PNE getting in the Premier league and why I very rarely watch the overpaid Premier league tossers.
 
When a player goes down holding his head and then gets treatment on his foot he should be booked.
When aplayer goes down injured but suddenly jumps up when he doesn't get the free kick,he should be booked.
When is a dive not a dive,when the ref doesn't book him like he is supposed to.

Until refs give out the cards for any sort of cheating it will never end and it is only the referee's higher archy that can stop the cheats.
 
Back
Top