Skip to main content

That decision..

  • Thread starter Thread starter JK
  • Start date Start date

That decision..

JK

In my mind, my dreams are real ...
Staff member
Joined
May 7, 2004
Messages
44,272
Location
Catterall
When the referee played on when a Brighton player fell over, then waited for us to centre it, then stopped the game...

Has to go down as one of the most ridiculous decisions I've ever seen.

Must admit I thought there would be a huge difference between officials in league one and the championship. Sadly there really isn't.
 
When the referee played on when a Brighton player fell over, then waited for us to centre it, then stopped the game...

Has to go down as one of the most ridiculous decisions I've ever seen.

Must admit I thought there would be a huge difference between officials in league one and the championship. Sadly there really isn't.

SG said on RL that the 4th official told him that it was a poor decision, he told Simon that he told the Ref through his mic to stop straight away, but he didn't & the 4th official said that it was wrong to stop it while we were crossing the ball.
 
That was just one of many poor decisions. The main problem was he was too weak to deal with their play acting and cynical fouling. Goldson, Hemed, Stephens, Knockaert should all have been booked. How many times did he call Goldson over to talk to him after he'd flattened garner, but he just ignored the ref and got away with it. Players know when a ref is weak and take advantage.
 
What about when the ref gave a goal kick and Dunk ran after Garner and kicked him on the back of his leg, right in front of the ref? He called Dunk over to the side of the box and told him not to do it again. It was violent conduct. The ball was dead, Garner was trotting away and had his back to Dunk, who chased after him and kicked him. Not even a yellow. Absolutely abysmal refereeing.
 
And he only booked Clarke when one of their players went complaining to him. Weak all game.
 
When the referee played on when a Brighton player fell over, then waited for us to centre it, then stopped the game...

Has to go down as one of the most ridiculous decisions I've ever seen.

Must admit I thought there would be a huge difference between officials in league one and the championship. Sadly there really isn't.

There was no reason for this inept official to stop play as it wasn't even a head injury and then the cheat wasn't even injured. Too many of Brighton's players were Premiership pretenders, wannabees, fakers, simulators and cheats.
 
Genuinely awful refereeing today, I think the crowning moment was when Goldson flattened Garner and then he calls Dunk over for a word. The guys have different skin colour, how can you possibly confuse the two?

Also he seemed to really care for Goldson, catered to that cheating beggar at every occasion. The shame for them was their persistent feigning of injury detracted from the fact they had a few players of real quality- Kayal, Hemed and Knockaert in particular.
 
Terrible decision. How can the guy stop play when we could have had a goal scoring opportunity. The Brighton player tripped Garner up right in front of his nose and he didn't book him. I also see Trevor Kettle has been at it again in Accringtom this time.
 
There was no reason for this inept official to stop play as it wasn't even a head injury and then the cheat wasn't even injured. Too many of Brighton's players were Premiership pretenders, wannabees, fakers, simulators and cheats.
That's why they won't get promotion.
 
The referee should have stopped play as soon as the Brighton player went down clutching his head. We all know he wasn't hurt anywhere near as badly as he was making out but the instructions to referees are clear with regards to head injuries.

He then stopped play with the ball in the air around the edge of the 6 yards area yet chose to drop the ball on the edge of the penalty area.

Having said that, seeing the Brighton deliberately kick Garner as Garner ran away from goal and only having a quick chat with the defender was as bad as anything Kettle did.
 
Another one that puzzled me, we fouled a Brighton Player, he gave the advantage, (well it looked like he did) Brighton Player then proceeds to put his hand on the ball to steady it then took a free kick? Would hav though that was handball, then he blew and Brought it back? Or did I miss something?
 
Another one that puzzled me, we fouled a Brighton Player, he gave the advantage, (well it looked like he did) Brighton Player then proceeds to put his hand on the ball to steady it then took a free kick? Would hav though that was handball, then he blew and Brought it back? Or did I miss something?

Not as much as the ref did.
 
As bad as the decision was the resulting drop ball added insult to injury( no injury) why Why why do we not have a proper drop ball anymore?
Clown bloody nonesense refereeing
 
Although having just seen the disallowed goal for Sheffield Wednesday, where the linesman flagged about a minute after the goal was given, Im not complaining as much against today's ref
 
PNE fans who are angered by players pretending to be mortally wounded, ought to temper their tempers with the acknowledgement that Garner is the master at the art.
Personally I think Garner got under their skin and turned it into a scrap, which probably suited North End better.
Great to see Gallagher getting right in there at the end.
They have great heart, this North End team. Loving this team at the moment.
 
PNE fans who are angered by players pretending to be mortally wounded, ought to temper their tempers with the acknowledgement that Garner is the master at the art.
Personally I think Garner got under their skin and turned it into a scrap, which probably suited North End better.
Great to see Gallagher getting right in there at the end.
They have great heart, this North End team. Loving this team at the moment.

I'm not that sure that Garner is a master at the art, although he seems to wind every other Team and their fans up every game, its largely giving what he gets, yet in all the Home Games I've seen the opposition have 2, 3 or 4 Players that seem to dive, cheat and play act.
This has happened Today, against Brighton, Shef Wed and Brentford to name just recent games.
The Referee today was awful gave virtually every 50/50 to Brighton which as 50-50's you would think they would go to the Home Team (after all they do when we are away!)
Aside from the ridiculous blowing up when we were attacking and a sham injury occurred, he also let play continue well into injury time after the 4 minutes because Brighton were attacking, he even let them take a Corner to allow them to score and only blew after we cleared it!
Don't know about referees being 'Homers' this one was an 'Awayer'
 
Back
Top