Skip to main content

The defence?

The defence?

Joined
Sep 22, 2004
Messages
13,704
Location
PR4 cha
No, not the defence of the team, the management or Nugent after Saturday, but more importantly, the back 4.

I have said all along that this is our real weakness and it showed on Saturday. Yes the forwards had an off day, but considering Brum only had probably 5/6 chances and scored three shows that Simpson really needs to look at tightening things up. We have no pace, the organisation is at times worse than a Sunday league team and Nash has no confidence, no matter what he says, in the two lads in front of him. We showed on Saturday then we can get at teams when we go forward and after the goals feasts against Leeds, Sunderland, Ipswich I am prepared to accept it as a bad day at the office, and those buffoons who want Nugent dropped want to have a day off and realise where our real issues lie, the back 4.

Hill has no/little confidence, he did ok on Saturday, but put him under pressure he is all over the show.
Alexender, who use to find a team mate with 90% of his passes is now finding the opposition with 90% of his passes.
St Ledger looks a good prospect, but sometimes a bit lightweight and his discipline and positioning at times is diabolical.
Chilvers, shown up at Wolves from the half way line and it happened again on Saturday, once someone runs at him he is 9 times out of 10 out of the game.

I am not interested in excuses like we have done superbly considering the loss of Youl and Claude and we have one of the best defences in the league, the problem right now is if you look at the four games we have lost in the league they have all come about from very poor defending, and its something Simpson needs to sort come the 1st January.
 
No, not the defence of the team, the management or Nugent after Saturday, but more importantly, the back 4.

I have said all along that this is our real weakness and it showed on Saturday. Yes the forwards had an off day, but considering Brum only had probably 5/6 chances and scored three shows that Simpson really needs to look at tightening things up. We have no pace, the organisation is at times worse than a Sunday league team and Nash has no confidence, no matter what he says, in the two lads in front of him. We showed on Saturday then we can get at teams when we go forward and after the goals feasts against Leeds, Sunderland, Ipswich I am prepared to accept it as a bad day at the office, and those buffoons who want Nugent dropped want to have a day off and realise where our real issues lie, the back 4.

Hill has no/little confidence, he did ok on Saturday, but put him under pressure he is all over the show.
Alexender, who use to find a team mate with 90% of his passes is now finding the opposition with 90% of his passes.
St Ledger looks a good prospect, but sometimes a bit lightweight and his discipline and positioning at times is diabolical.
Chilvers, shown up at Wolves from the half way line and it happened again on Saturday, once someone runs at him he is 9 times out of 10 out of the game.

I am not interested in excuses like we have done superbly considering the loss of Youl and Claude and we have one of the best defences in the league, the problem right now is if you look at the four games we have lost in the league they have all come about from very poor defending, and its something Simpson needs to sort come the 1st January.


WIBG - aka - Kelvin Wilson lol
 
We should try this i think-

St. Ledger------Chilvers---Wilson------Grezza

I think this would really tighten things up, and give us a more solid base.

Every goal we concede nash has no chance with, so the defence must be at fault.
 
No, not the defence of the team, the management or Nugent after Saturday, but more importantly, the back 4.

I have said all along that this is our real weakness and it showed on Saturday. Yes the forwards had an off day, but considering Brum only had probably 5/6 chances and scored three shows that Simpson really needs to look at tightening things up. We have no pace, the organisation is at times worse than a Sunday league team and Nash has no confidence, no matter what he says, in the two lads in front of him. We showed on Saturday then we can get at teams when we go forward and after the goals feasts against Leeds, Sunderland, Ipswich I am prepared to accept it as a bad day at the office, and those buffoons who want Nugent dropped want to have a day off and realise where our real issues lie, the back 4.

Hill has no/little confidence, he did ok on Saturday, but put him under pressure he is all over the show.
Alexender, who use to find a team mate with 90% of his passes is now finding the opposition with 90% of his passes.
St Ledger looks a good prospect, but sometimes a bit lightweight and his discipline and positioning at times is diabolical.
Chilvers, shown up at Wolves from the half way line and it happened again on Saturday, once someone runs at him he is 9 times out of 10 out of the game.

I am not interested in excuses like we have done superbly considering the loss of Youl and Claude and we have one of the best defences in the league, the problem right now is if you look at the four games we have lost in the league they have all come about from very poor defending, and its something Simpson needs to sort come the 1st January.

I agree with much of what you say, althoguh I thought Hill had an excellant game on Saturday and Brum did not look treatening down their right. All their good chances came from the right where they kept going through Alexander and St Ledger like a dose of salts.
Chilvers had a relatively poor game but still did OK. I'd like to see Wilson and Chilvers given a run in the center. I think St Ledger is probably the best defender of the 3 but he needs to work on his positioning and concentration. Also in every game he seems to be pulling up with some sort of strain type of injury so a rest may not do him any harm.
Although being a big fan of Alexander I agree that he is starting to get done for pace too often. A new right back must be Simpsons premier target for the transfer window.
 
people say we lost the game cos we didn`t take our chances, but I trully beleive we lost it thanks to the bad defending of St Ledger. OK, maybe you can excuse him for his slip for the first goal and I don`t think he did much wrong with the penalty, as it was a BAD decision from Riley, but the most important moment was the second goal and there can`t be any excuse for St Ledger`s possitioning and the way he allowed Shefrey to go past him. We had three defenders to two strikers, their seemed no danger in the possition they were, but instead of St Ledger standing to Shefrey, he just ran away and allowed him to get inside the area!? Very strange piece of defending. So, when you put all 3 incidents for the goals together, St Ledger was unfortuantelly at the heart of every and each of them. That`s where we lost the game IMO.
 
He's learning on the job, but I guess that's inevitable.

Looks like McSheffery gave him almost as much trouble as Steve Howard did.

There's no shame in that, but I feel that a more seasoned centre half could be a very good acquisition for us in January....
 
Although I agree with you on the abilities of the back four, the midfield failed to either cover back, or block the supply route to the Brum forwards.
Whaley only does half a job, he lacks the commitment to track back, and Pugh was often dragged into a central position, leaving Hill on his own, (Hill still had a decent game imho)
Chilvers lack of pace was all to obvious again, and both centre backs lost the battle in the air with the Brum forwards, this leaves Nash not knowing what is best to do, and with the current goalkeeping coach having little or no league experience, our defensive unit looks well short of the required ability to bring promotion.
We have to defend from the front, and only Ormerod showed the willingness to constantly track back, maybe Simpson's attacking systems need to also provide proper defensive plans.
For as long as Simpson ignores the ability of Wilson, we are not fielding our best back four, this coupled with Alexanders regular isolation (no support from Whaley), Chilvers lack of pace and Matty having a dip in form, means that more teams with powerfull forwards WILL score against us.

You have to look at the coaching, last season Nash was in complete control, great confidence as a unit, and yes we have lost Davis and Mawene for different reasons, but the manager has bought defensive players, brought in his own team of specialist coaches, and its not pretty defensively.

I think that the defense is a much greater problem than Nugents missed chances on Saturday, we are creating chances, and he will come good.

We have played very well against Cardiff, Southampton, Sunderland, Leeds, WBA and been very average against Barnsley, Shef Wed, QPR, Southend, Hull, Crystal Palace, Norwich, Luton and Port Vale, and its onlt the topsy turvy nature of the teams arround us that keeps PNE in the play off places.

Just how much does the chairman want promotion, the opportunity to play against the very best, full houses each home game, a complete ground and maxismise the dormant local support. This is as big a test for the manager as it is the board, too many times recently Simpson had been trotting out the old small club clap trap, and this has not been countered by the chairman expressing a total desire to reach the prommised land, and before the blind faithers point to our financial short commings and Leeds, shall we keep on being a slightly bigger Crewe, and accept that it will never happen.
 
I dont think the back 4 have done that badly to be honest, my main worry after Saturdays game is this; If we get into the play offs whilst I would back us to beat most teams at home quite comfortably, what chance have we got of shutting out a team like Brum, West Brom, Derby, or any other "big" club in front a full house when they are going for it?
 
I agree with much of what you say, althoguh I thought Hill had an excellant game on Saturday and Brum did not look treatening down their right. All their good chances came from the right where they kept going through Alexander and St Ledger like a dose of salts.
Chilvers had a relatively poor game but still did OK. I'd like to see Wilson and Chilvers given a run in the center. I think St Ledger is probably the best defender of the 3 but he needs to work on his positioning and concentration. Also in every game he seems to be pulling up with some sort of strain type of injury so a rest may not do him any harm.
Although being a big fan of Alexander I agree that he is starting to get done for pace too often. A new right back must be Simpsons premier target for the transfer window.


I disagree regards St Ledger who I feel reads the game really well, has pace and his positioning is good.
For the second goal, had the Saint blocked McSheffery off then he could of got sent off, as Riley had already given him an dubious yellow card earlier.
Theres still along way to go in the Championship, how many of us would of taken 4th place at this stage of the season, stay strong back the team and come May we will be there.
 
I dont think the back 4 have done that badly to be honest, my main worry after Saturdays game is this; If we get into the play offs whilst I would back us to beat most teams at home quite comfortably, what chance have we got of shutting out a team like Brum, West Brom, Derby, or any other "big" club in front a full house when they are going for it?

Seriously? Slim to nil, I'm afraid. Whats the latest news on youl?
 
Although being a big fan of Alexander I agree that he is starting to get done for pace too often. A new right back must be Simpsons premier target for the transfer window.

Something that, in fact, has been obvious for some time. Alexander was once the best right back in this division, but that was several seasons ago. More to the point while Alexander has lost his pace he hasn't really compensated for the fact with any increase in his tactical sense or postioning. Hence the fact that he is slowly becoming a weakpoint in the defence and why we need a fast, agile right back also able to provide support for the attack by overlapping at speed. I got some flak for pointing this out just a few weeks ago but it seems that some more people are finally beginning to appreciate it as well. As for Alexander I still think that we would make the best of him as he is now by freeing him up from primary defensive responsibilities and turning him into a right-centre midfielder with a brief to drive things on and have a crack at goal whenever he gets a chance - the shooting from distance of Sedgwick and McKenna (especially) is pretty woeful and not the least of the things Alexander could contribute in a midfield role would be something to make up for that.
 
Mears could be available now Pards has got the sack Ernest !

I'm not sure that Simmo telling Whaley not to defend as much was a good idea. He took it to heart for the second goal on Saturday.
 
yes GA is not as quick as we would like him to be, but he is a must in defence until we have someone else with experience in there.

I think our exposer down the right is as much to do with whalley not playing his part defensively as it is to do the GA's pace.

I am also happy with GA's attacking support.
 
I agree with much of what you say, althoguh I thought Hill had an excellant game on Saturday and Brum did not look treatening down their right. All their good chances came from the right where they kept going through Alexander and St Ledger like a dose of salts.
Chilvers had a relatively poor game but still did OK. I'd like to see Wilson and Chilvers given a run in the center. I think St Ledger is probably the best defender of the 3 but he needs to work on his positioning and concentration. Also in every game he seems to be pulling up with some sort of strain type of injury so a rest may not do him any harm.
Although being a big fan of Alexander I agree that he is starting to get done for pace too often. A new right back must be Simpsons premier target for the transfer window.


And who allows them through .Yes are absolutely,fantastic midfield.🙄 Whalley offers alexander nothing in terms of protection.Our midfield is our weak spot.
 
St Ledger has played an awful lot of games...in fact ALL the games....for a young and relatively inexperienced player playing at a higher level. He has done very well and could well go to the very top but young players will be caught out from time to time. I recall seeing Sol Campbell play for Spurs at Blackburn as a youngster and he had a nightmare. St Ledger is struggling a bit with his fitness too and is in need of a rest. Personally, I think we need an experienced CH to steady things. If Davidson had been fit, he would have provided the experience from LB but we badly need another 'old head' in there. Someone like Pressley or Unsworth would be ideal.
 
Back
Top