Skip to main content

The loan system

The loan system

Joined
Jun 8, 2004
Messages
2,096
Location
Ashton
Speaking to Peter Risdale the other day and he mentioned how well the loan system has served North End last season and this to cope with injuries.

He went on to say that wont be an option from August next year as loans will only be available during the transfer windows.

The smaller the budget the greater the problem clubs with smaller budgets will only be able to have a certain size of squad injuries could decimate a small club.

If a couple of strikers or defenders had serious injuries it could finish a small clubs season whilst the biggest clubs in the division could and would carry bigger squads. There is danger for even for some of the bigger clubs is they carry too many players putting the financial viability of those clubs at risk.

If it aint broke why oh why do FIFa want to stick their oar in?
 
If it aint broke why oh why do FIFa want to stick their oar in?
This isn't really Fifa sticking their oar in - the emergency loan system contravenes Fifa's whole international transfer window system, but Fifa has allowed it to continue with several extensions over the last few years - but it seems this season will finally be "it".

Whether Fifa's transfer window system itself is any good is another subject - but the emergency loan system has always seemed a bit of a farce to me, with nothing "emergency" about it.

It is really just a convenient mechanism for bloated Prem squads to park some of their fringe players lower down the leagues to get some game-time.

Whether or not a lower-league club picks up one or two of these plum loans has often meant the difference between success and failure in their respective leagues, distorting the whole competition.

With this loophole closed, and with Prem clubs doubtless still dithering over settling their 25-man squads each year (see Sam Johnstone this summer for a prime example of their dithering), maybe these fringe Prem players will finally realise that their best chance of playing football (assuming they're not just in it for the money) might be to secure a permanent contract lower down the pyramid in the first place, rather than earning that coveted number 56 shirt at Stoke?
 
This isn't really Fifa sticking their oar in - the emergency loan system contravenes Fifa's whole international transfer window system, but Fifa has allowed it to continue with several extensions over the last few years - but it seems this season will finally be "it".

Whether Fifa's transfer window system itself is any good is another subject - but the emergency loan system has always seemed a bit of a farce to me, with nothing "emergency" about it.

It is really just a convenient mechanism for bloated Prem squads to park some of their fringe players lower down the leagues to get some game-time.

Whether or not a lower-league club picks up one or two of these plum loans has often meant the difference between success and failure in their respective leagues, distorting the whole competition.

With this loophole closed, and with Prem clubs doubtless still dithering over settling their 25-man squads each year (see Sam Johnstone this summer for a prime example of their dithering), maybe these fringe Prem players will finally realise that their best chance of playing football (assuming they're not just in it for the money) might be to secure a permanent contract lower down the pyramid in the first place, rather than earning that coveted number 56 shirt at Stoke?

+1

One of the positives of this change is it might stop big Premier League clubs stockpiling players.

Hopefully the talent will filter down as a result, with more youngsters moving for permanent first team football rather than loan after loan after loan.
 
This is also likely to place an added premium on versatile players.

A player such as Gallagher for example, capable of covering a number of attacking positions, will likely become more sought after.
 
Jack Kings will also be sought after, able to play in defence, midfield, and attack. Or serve as a builder, or royalty.
 
I never understood why premier league teams were allowed to loan players to each other. Surley the modern loan system was to allow players to get game time at lower level clubs. All it's done is allow clubs like Chelsea to stockpile players who in all likelihood will never make the first team as expensive foreign imports will always be brought in ahead of them. Johnstone at utd a prime example.
 
Back
Top