For me there’s no way back. Whatever happens, for too long now we have had:
1) A manager who, on appointment, stated that he had a squad that was ‘fantastic’, full of good players and would play attractive, attacking football. He now says we ‘lack quality’. If after 2 years, the quality has gone down, who’s responsible for that?
2) A manager who contradicts himself so much in press conferences, he could join the Tory government. Lies and spin. I don’t like that. He’s disingenuous at best.
3) A manager who quite simply doesn’t get the best out of players and flip flops around. Remember him bringing O Neill into the squad and going on about how good he was? Where’s he now? Southport? Players like Hughes, Whiteman, McCann (and many others!) have become really inconsistent over time. That may not be entirely Ryan’s fault, but when it appears players don’t know what their role is on the pitch, it suggests a lack of preparation. Some players have actually gone backwards in the last two years, and not just in a Ched Evans, should have retired way.
4) A manager who after two years has a team who are so poor at defending set pieces. This is coaching and preparation and is unforgivable. Every time we concede a corner, or a free kick around our box, I think we will concede. Some will point the finger at Freddie as he generally stays at home. But if you’ve got a keeper who cannot dominate his area due to lack of size and physicality, that should help the defenders as they will know what he’s going to do. Again, this is about team set up and coaching. Whose responsibility? The manager.
5) A manager who doesn’t just believe his own hype. He set’s it. The team wins? It’s because they follow his instructions. They lose? Individual errors or not following the game plan. This is linked to number 2 in a way, as it’s the way he deals with media. He has also openly criticised individual players publicly as well. Having worked in leadership for nearly 30 years, done massive amounts of training in this area (yes I have my badges), I know that this very rarely works. For Lowe it deflects attention… Mr Teflon.
6) In game management. We often have a decent first half. This is followed by a second half where the opposition makes changes to overcome this. We rarely, if ever, then make similar tactical adaptations during the game to negate this. Substitutions that need to be made are usually made reactively after we’ve conceded rather than pro actively when we can all see what the other team are doing. The players seem to know this…but that is conjecture.
7) The passive aggressive digs at the supporters. ‘When they back us, and get behind us, they’re amazing’… the sly suggestions that we have failed to turn up when the team have played badly. As I’ve said before, I generally think the home crowd are very quick to moan, and berate misplaced passes. I’ll applaud if the pass attempted is the correct one, and encourage the players to keep trying those things. If you don’t, you end up with Josh Earl, scared to cross the ball in case he messes up, so constantly cuts back inside to look for the easy pass. This season, however, I think the home support has been much more positive than in recent years. When the match is deathly dull (most weeks) the crowd has tried to spark something… which has rarely, but on occasions, helped the team over the line. We can be, and should be, the 12th player, but please Ryan, stop suggesting that we don’t back you!
8) The ‘side to side’ passing. Now I don’t actually mind a patient build up. Keep the ball is ok by me, and if we try to go down the right and get blocked off, why not switch and go left? My issue is what happens next, which is the pass ends up with a centre half or the keeper who, seeing nothing else on, has no option to to lump it. We then lose the ball…so while it can be dull, I would prefer us to keep passing, rather than keep passing and then lump it long. That’s just a complete waste of time and gives the opposition encouragement to press. Again, this comes down to coaching. When the opposition press Whiteman and/or cut off his passing lines to the Wing Backs, he has no other options. Tactically, surely one of the Centre halves could in those situations step into the midfield to receive a pass? Give us the extra body we need? Pass and move? Hardly revolutionary is it?
9) In game rigidity. Too many players seem scared to make individual decisions in the game, especially when a team is attacking us with pace. Again, the backing off is often needed, dive in and leave someone in a one on on me with the keeper is. Ever a good idea and I’m not one to shout ‘get into them’ or ‘get a tackle in’, but sometimes we see all the midfield in position but simply jockeying the players until they get to the edge of the box, then close them down. Team instructions clearly and happens too often for this to be otherwise. We were a bit like that under Moyes, but the imaginary line seemed to be 35 yards from goal. Back off, get everyone in position quickly, then make the tackle before they’re in a position to hurt you. I think this is why he didn’t like DJ, and seems to not like Mads. They’re not robots and play with instinct. Some may say ‘what about Millar?’ Watch Millar without the ball. He’s awful but is always where Lowe wants him to be, phenomenal work rate. Rigid. How Ryan likes them… and let’s not forget, he was on the bench most weeks until Brady got injured. Millar. On the bench… a sackable offense on its own!
10) Too many embarrassing performances. Too many 4-0 games. Like Burnley last season where we turned up with no plan, no clue how to play.
There are more aspects to Ryan’s leadership that I feel are failing but these are all variations on the same theme. If we win the next 6 games, we will probably be in the top 6. If it happened, would I still be in the Lowe Out camp? Absolutely- and none of this is personal, or what Ryan loves to call ‘slander’ in the media, my view is that the manager. All the above is based on watching PNE home and away under the current regime and change is well and truly overdue.