Welcome! Apologies if your earnest question feels like it's being dismissed but as others have indicated it's become quite a pattern with fans of other teams asking why we want Lowe gone. Although they often come with a lecture about how we shouldn't aspire to any better (a talking point that completely ignores the likes of Luton and Brentford from the past few years and Ipswich's successes from this season).
Just to bullet point the main talking points. Those who want Ryan gone want him gone for any of the following reasons:
- We have been playing poorly for a long time. This includes when we were top of the league (23rd for chance creation, only three clean sheets all season, meaning we can't attack or defend)
- His failure to play the attacking football he promised on his arrival (see chance creation data)
- The lack of improvement in anything he's promised (set pieces are no better, youth players don't get more game time etc)
- His inability to take responsibility (see soundbites about players not following the plan)
- His tactics (Norwich and Swansea were two leaky sides and we went to park the bus, our constant crosses against Sheffield Wednesday)
- Bizarre team selections (e.g. Swansea away)
- Bizarre substitutions (pretty much most games, especially how late they are)
- His recruitment despite being the most backed manager since our return to the Championship (Mads Frøkjaer Jensen barely plays despite the money we paid, Calvin Ramsay signed injured and doesn't make the squad when fit, still no proper wingbacks despite his main formation being 5-3-2/3-5-2)
- The appearance he has favourites (Robbie Brady, Ryan Ledson and Ben Woodburn keep getting minutes despite not being rated)
- The players getting contract extensions who don't add much value (Brady and Woodburn aren't rated, Cunningham is nearly always injured)
- His dismissal of fan opinions (openly implying Chelsea on Saturday doesn't matter and suggesting your opinions are irrelevant if you don't have coaching badges)
- Players seemingly not being fit
- There are unemployed managers who probably would improve us
- Players seemingly going backwards as footballers (Ali McCann, Mads Frøkjaer, Freddie Woodman, Ryan Ledson) and very few getting better (maybe Brad Potts)
We could talk about expectations, about if the squad is good enough for top six etc, the crux of the matter is nothing has improved in his time here. While that's not entirely his fault, there isn't much reason to keep him. I would genuinely like to hear the argument to keep him. In a perfect world he turns the form around and the club doesn't have to pay money to remove him and his backroom staff. However at present the argument to keep him is little more than the squad (that he's had a big role in assembling) isn't good enough but we shouldn't expect much better anyway.
I guess all I'm doing though is articulating a series of points you and your fellow Plymouth fans are already aware of. The fact you wouldn't want him back despite him managing a team that's higher in the table than you and has got them topping the league this season deep down highlights exactly why we want him gone. He simply isn't cut out to be a Championship manager.