Skip to main content

These refs

These refs

Bottom line is he's a human-being. He will miss things that we see. He will see things that we miss. Sky instant replays are wonderful, but unfortunately the Ref doesn't have access to them. Then when you throw personal opinion and reasoning into the equasion, it becomes a proper mixed bag.

Personally I thought he had a decent first half. I like it when Refs let things go (for BOTH sides!!), but the second half was poor and pretty frustrating.

But to say it's just League 1 Refs that are poor/debatable isn't fair. Most games these days end up with a discussion about the Ref.

Why would he need a replay for the handball when he was staring right at the incident. He even went to whistle, but for some reason decided not to. He was a complete twat.
 
Why would he need a replay for the handball when he was staring right at the incident. He even went to whistle, but for some reason decided not to. He was a complete twat.

Just because the ball hits a players arm/hand, doesn't mean it's an offence.

This is where 'opinion' comes into it, and until robots are officiating the games, there will be debate afterwards.
 
Just because the ball hits a players arm/hand, doesn't mean it's an offence.

This is where 'opinion' comes into it, and until robots are officiating the games, there will be debate afterwards.

His arm was stuck out and it saved the ball from going in. Whether he meant it or not is irrelevant. Fact is his outstretched arm has stopped a goal bound shot, unlike earlier where the ball hit their defenders hand completely unintentionally not affecting the play whatsoever.

It was a clear penalty and there's nothing to debate.
 
"It was a clear penalty and there's nothing to debate."

This site would be shit without it, so let it flow!!!!!

Well I'm not saying debate isn't allowed. Just that it was without question a stonewall penalty.
 
Completely agree, standard of reffing is appauling at our level. Since seeing at first hand Dean Whitestone's arrogant approach against Orient I've been watching out for him. On Saturday he took a dislike to Burton and despite 5 mins going up, he decided to play on until Wimbledon equalised in the 9th minute of added time.
 
Once again last night the ref wasn't great. Missed Humphrey clearly being taken out in the box and Beavon being cynically hacked down after he'd done his man all ends up with a great touch. I was a long way away in the AKTE but the lad who went smashing through the back of Garner in the first half looked like he could have been shown a red as well.

What worries me is that these men have teams whole season in their hands.
 
Once again last night the ref wasn't great. Missed Humphrey clearly being taken out in the box and Beavon being cynically hacked down after he'd done his man all ends up with a great touch. I was a long way away in the AKTE but the lad who went smashing through the back of Garner in the first half looked like he could have been shown a red as well.

What worries me is that these men have teams whole season in their hands.
I was right next to the Garner incident, the Posh player and Garner actually got to the ball at the same time, hard tackle from the pair of them, doubtful it was even a foul, if im honest.

Weve had a lot worse refs than that, if im honest. He tried to let the game flow.
 
I was right next to the Garner incident, the Posh player and Garner actually got to the ball at the same time, hard tackle from the pair of them, doubtful it was even a foul, if im honest.

Weve had a lot worse refs than that, if im honest. He tried to let the game flow.

That was the way I saw the Garner incident. However, once he'd given it as a foul he could easily have shown the red - which probably sounds a bit strange!

He did let it flow but had an unusual habit of waiting for a few seconds after an incident and then waving advantage rather than waving play on straight away, maybe giving himself more thinking time - no bad thing.

It is funny how the better refs tend to referee our better results 🙂
 
Thanks for clearing up the Garner one.

Missing blatant penalties though needs to be sorted out. He had a good view of it and the linesman was also looking straight at it.
 
Just a point about last nights ref, now I am usually their biggest critic, however following Garners third goal and birdman celebration the ref ran over and said ' you were offside' Garner looked astounded surrounded by celebrating teammates at which point the ref ran off laughing back to the half way line. GSOH?
 
Just a point about last nights ref, now I am usually their biggest critic, however following Garners third goal and birdman celebration the ref ran over and said ' you were offside' Garner looked astounded surrounded by celebrating teammates at which point the ref ran off laughing back to the half way line. GSOH?
🙂 Is that true? Back to old fashioned reffing, if so when refs bantered with the players
 
Its true, check out his after goal celebration on one of Mackens videos I was sat in the Invincibles just near it, the ref was laughing his head off.
 
I noticed something had gone on and found it quite strange that the ref was having a good laugh in Garners face but from my vantage point on the Town End we couldn't work out what it was all about!
 
Back
Top