Skip to main content

Thoughts from the Game

Thoughts from the Game

Joined
Jun 7, 2004
Messages
24,671
A massive result gained through a battling, determined performance in which every player gave everything they had - though with varying degrees of effectiveness. The formation looked more like a 4.4.2 to start with but for much of the match it was a sort of 5.2.2.1 with Humphrey dropping right back and Clarke moving a bit more in-field and then Welsh and Keane and then Gallagher and Davies or Garner - the latter two seemed to alternate as lone strikers. Gallagher in fact drifted across to a sort of centre right position for much of the game.

Our opponents started briskly and in truth early on they passed and moved quicker than we did. In contrast we were trying to keep possession and slow the game down. They almost broke through on our right after a few minutes but Humphrey - in his most important contribution of the game - got back to intercept after their left winger got past Clarke. After that we began to settle with King looking very good at centre back - he gave us the ability to play long balls from the back with some accuracy. Gallagher almost scored with a dipping volley and then they almost caught us with a long through ball down our left but though they continued to be energetic we kept closing them down and they just could not get a sight of goal.

Then we did. Davies got possession in the centre and pushed the ball to Humphrey who got past the fullback - really the only time he did so all afternoon - before putting in a cross that was cleared but Clarke (well I thought it was, someone else says Keane) dinked a lovely little cross in again which Garner simply lashed in with a brilliant hooked volley. It was a stunning finish.

So to the second half which followed a slightly perverse pattern with them spending more time in our half battering against us without effect but us creating real chances when we did get into the final third in their half. A lovely flick from Davies sent Garner clean through but he was caught before he could shoot, Gallagher tried to lob their keeper from 30 yards and then Garner had enough time again from about 30 yards to pick his spot but put it wide. At one point we forced three corners in succession but the final 15 minutes saw them more or less camped in our half and I was starting to get an awful feeling they would nick an equaliser. We got another corner but wasted it - just punted it into the six yard box for their keeper to catch. That was poor - I hope SG noticed it - but then Garner had a run at their goal and elected to try another long range effort when Davies to his right was unmarked. We then almost paid the penalty for failing to kill the game off. With almost the last move of the match they got clean through and Rudd made a brilliant save from the first shot and also a follow-up.

In summary we won this match because we stifled and frustrated our opponents to the extent that they created only one chance for themselves whilst we actually got several sights of goal. We could have won 3-0. We might at the end have only drawn. The team selection was good but my overall impression was that it worked because our opponents fell into the trap of constantly trying to run at us and when they lost possession - which we made them do through our defensive work - we could hit them on the break. Oddly against less energetic opposition we might have had more problems - this was a team set up for a smash-and-grab away performance and it worked a treat, but we would need to be more creative and inventive to break down a side sitting back and defending.

Marks for individual players:

Rudd 8 - didn't have a lot to do but when he had to act he was decisive.

Clarke 8 - determined and resolute in defence.

King 9 - man-of-the-match composed and dominant.

Wright 7 - made some good tackles but occasionally a bit untidy when trying to play the ball.

Laird 7 - as for Wright.

Humphrey 5 - don't get me wrong I can see this fellow tries his best and as I said above he made a crucial interception early on, but he lacks invention and without any service from midfield be he simply cannot get past a fullback.

Welsh 8 - really put himself about.

Keane 7 - energetic and committed.

Gallagher 8 - had a lot of possession and did what was necessary to keep the ball and then play simple short passes.

Garner 8 - ran a lot, should have done better with second half chances but finish for the goal was stupendous.

Davies 8 - battled all the game.
 
A massive result gained through a battling, determined performance in which every player gave everything they had - though with varying degrees of effectiveness. The formation looked more like a 4.4.2 to start with but for much of the match it was a sort of 5.2.2.1 with Humphrey dropping right back and Clarke moving a bit more in-field and then Welsh and Keane and then Gallagher and Davies or Garner - the latter two seemed to alternate as lone strikers. Gallagher in fact drifted across to a sort of centre right position for much of the game.

Our opponents started briskly and in truth early on they passed and moved quicker than we did. In contrast we were trying to keep possession and slow the game down. They almost broke through on our right after a few minutes but Humphrey - in his most important contribution of the game - got back to intercept after their left winger got past Clarke. After that we began to settle with King looking very good at centre back - he gave us the ability to play long balls from the back with some accuracy. Gallagher almost scored with a dipping volley and then they almost caught us with a long through ball down our left but though they continued to be energetic we kept closing them down and they just could not get a sight of goal.

Then we did. Davies got possession in the centre and pushed the ball to Humphrey who got past the fullback - really the only time he did so all afternoon - before putting in a cross that was cleared but Clarke (well I thought it was, someone else says Keane) dinked a lovely little cross in again which Garner simply lashed in with a brilliant hooked volley. It was a stunning finish.

So to the second half which followed a slightly perverse pattern with them spending more time in our half battering against us without effect but us creating real chances when we did get into the final third in their half. A lovely flick from Davies sent Garner clean through but he was caught before he could shoot, Gallagher tried to lob their keeper from 30 yards and then Garner had enough time again from about 30 yards to pick his spot but put it wide. At one point we forced three corners in succession but the final 15 minutes saw them more or less camped in our half and I was starting to get an awful feeling they would nick an equaliser. We got another corner but wasted it - just punted it into the six yard box for their keeper to catch. That was poor - I hope SG noticed it - but then Garner had a run at their goal and elected to try another long range effort when Davies to his right was unmarked. We then almost paid the penalty for failing to kill the game off. With almost the last move of the match they got clean through and Rudd made a brilliant save from the first shot and also a follow-up.

In summary we won this match because we stifled and frustrated our opponents to the extent that they created only one chance for themselves whilst we actually got several sights of goal. We could have won 3-0. We might at the end have only drawn. The team selection was good but my overall impression was that it worked because our opponents fell into the trap of constantly trying to run at us and when they lost possession - which we made them do through our defensive work - we could hit them on the break. Oddly against less energetic opposition we might have had more problems - this was a team set up for a smash-and-grab away performance and it worked a treat, but we would need to be more creative and inventive to break down a side sitting back and defending.

Marks for individual players:

Rudd 8 - didn't have a lot to do but when he had to act he was decisive.

Clarke 8 - determined and resolute in defence.

King 9 - man-of-the-match composed and dominant.

Wright 7 - made some good tackles but occasionally a bit untidy when trying to play the ball.

Laird 7 - as for Wright.

Humphrey 5 - don't get me wrong I can see this fellow tries his best and as I said above he made a crucial interception early on, but he lacks invention and without any service from midfield be he simply cannot get past a fullback.

Welsh 8 - really put himself about.

Keane 7 - energetic and committed.

Gallagher 8 - had a lot of possession and did what was necessary to keep the ball and then play simple short passes.

Garner 8 - ran a lot, should have done better with second half chances but finish for the goal was stupendous.

Davies 8 - battled all the game.

IMHO Davies was very very poor today. I'd of given him a 5.
 
A massive result gained through a battling, determined performance in which every player gave everything they had - though with varying degrees of effectiveness. The formation looked more like a 4.4.2 to start with but for much of the match it was a sort of 5.2.2.1 with Humphrey dropping right back and Clarke moving a bit more in-field and then Welsh and Keane and then Gallagher and Davies or Garner - the latter two seemed to alternate as lone strikers. Gallagher in fact drifted across to a sort of centre right position for much of the game.

Our opponents started briskly and in truth early on they passed and moved quicker than we did. In contrast we were trying to keep possession and slow the game down. They almost broke through on our right after a few minutes but Humphrey - in his most important contribution of the game - got back to intercept after their left winger got past Clarke. After that we began to settle with King looking very good at centre back - he gave us the ability to play long balls from the back with some accuracy. Gallagher almost scored with a dipping volley and then they almost caught us with a long through ball down our left but though they continued to be energetic we kept closing them down and they just could not get a sight of goal.

Then we did. Davies got possession in the centre and pushed the ball to Humphrey who got past the fullback - really the only time he did so all afternoon - before putting in a cross that was cleared but Clarke (well I thought it was, someone else says Keane) dinked a lovely little cross in again which Garner simply lashed in with a brilliant hooked volley. It was a stunning finish.

So to the second half which followed a slightly perverse pattern with them spending more time in our half battering against us without effect but us creating real chances when we did get into the final third in their half. A lovely flick from Davies sent Garner clean through but he was caught before he could shoot, Gallagher tried to lob their keeper from 30 yards and then Garner had enough time again from about 30 yards to pick his spot but put it wide. At one point we forced three corners in succession but the final 15 minutes saw them more or less camped in our half and I was starting to get an awful feeling they would nick an equaliser. We got another corner but wasted it - just punted it into the six yard box for their keeper to catch. That was poor - I hope SG noticed it - but then Garner had a run at their goal and elected to try another long range effort when Davies to his right was unmarked. We then almost paid the penalty for failing to kill the game off. With almost the last move of the match they got clean through and Rudd made a brilliant save from the first shot and also a follow-up.

In summary we won this match because we stifled and frustrated our opponents to the extent that they created only one chance for themselves whilst we actually got several sights of goal. We could have won 3-0. We might at the end have only drawn. The team selection was good but my overall impression was that it worked because our opponents fell into the trap of constantly trying to run at us and when they lost possession - which we made them do through our defensive work - we could hit them on the break. Oddly against less energetic opposition we might have had more problems - this was a team set up for a smash-and-grab away performance and it worked a treat, but we would need to be more creative and inventive to break down a side sitting back and defending.

Marks for individual players:

Rudd 8 - didn't have a lot to do but when he had to act he was decisive.

Clarke 8 - determined and resolute in defence.

King 9 - man-of-the-match composed and dominant.

Wright 7 - made some good tackles but occasionally a bit untidy when trying to play the ball.

Laird 7 - as for Wright.

Humphrey 5 - don't get me wrong I can see this fellow tries his best and as I said above he made a crucial interception early on, but he lacks invention and without any service from midfield be he simply cannot get past a fullback.

Welsh 8 - really put himself about.

Keane 7 - energetic and committed.

Gallagher 8 - had a lot of possession and did what was necessary to keep the ball and then play simple short passes.

Garner 8 - ran a lot, should have done better with second half chances but finish for the goal was stupendous.

Davies 8 - battled all the game.

Glad to see that your views are finally based on actually seeing a game for a change. To give Humphrey a 5 and everybody else at least 7, including 9 for King, is rather weird!
 
IMHO "I'd OF given ........" is very very poor.

It's have.

Good report Ernest. Thanks.

And that makes his comment less valid how? Harry rednapp (who i think is a terrible c***) can by his own admission, barley read or write. He has done ok in football aint he?

You dont need to have read tolstoy to have thoughts on a football match
 
A massive result gained through a battling, determined performance in which every player gave everything they had - though with varying degrees of effectiveness. The formation looked more like a 4.4.2 to start with but for much of the match it was a sort of 5.2.2.1 with Humphrey dropping right back and Clarke moving a bit more in-field and then Welsh and Keane and then Gallagher and Davies or Garner - the latter two seemed to alternate as lone strikers. Gallagher in fact drifted across to a sort of centre right position for much of the game.

Our opponents started briskly and in truth early on they passed and moved quicker than we did. In contrast we were trying to keep possession and slow the game down. They almost broke through on our right after a few minutes but Humphrey - in his most important contribution of the game - got back to intercept after their left winger got past Clarke. After that we began to settle with King looking very good at centre back - he gave us the ability to play long balls from the back with some accuracy. Gallagher almost scored with a dipping volley and then they almost caught us with a long through ball down our left but though they continued to be energetic we kept closing them down and they just could not get a sight of goal.

Then we did. Davies got possession in the centre and pushed the ball to Humphrey who got past the fullback - really the only time he did so all afternoon - before putting in a cross that was cleared but Clarke (well I thought it was, someone else says Keane) dinked a lovely little cross in again which Garner simply lashed in with a brilliant hooked volley. It was a stunning finish.

So to the second half which followed a slightly perverse pattern with them spending more time in our half battering against us without effect but us creating real chances when we did get into the final third in their half. A lovely flick from Davies sent Garner clean through but he was caught before he could shoot, Gallagher tried to lob their keeper from 30 yards and then Garner had enough time again from about 30 yards to pick his spot but put it wide. At one point we forced three corners in succession but the final 15 minutes saw them more or less camped in our half and I was starting to get an awful feeling they would nick an equaliser. We got another corner but wasted it - just punted it into the six yard box for their keeper to catch. That was poor - I hope SG noticed it - but then Garner had a run at their goal and elected to try another long range effort when Davies to his right was unmarked. We then almost paid the penalty for failing to kill the game off. With almost the last move of the match they got clean through and Rudd made a brilliant save from the first shot and also a follow-up.

In summary we won this match because we stifled and frustrated our opponents to the extent that they created only one chance for themselves whilst we actually got several sights of goal. We could have won 3-0. We might at the end have only drawn. The team selection was good but my overall impression was that it worked because our opponents fell into the trap of constantly trying to run at us and when they lost possession - which we made them do through our defensive work - we could hit them on the break. Oddly against less energetic opposition we might have had more problems - this was a team set up for a smash-and-grab away performance and it worked a treat, but we would need to be more creative and inventive to break down a side sitting back and defending.

Marks for individual players:

Rudd 8 - didn't have a lot to do but when he had to act he was decisive.

Clarke 8 - determined and resolute in defence.

King 9 - man-of-the-match composed and dominant.

Wright 7 - made some good tackles but occasionally a bit untidy when trying to play the ball.

Laird 7 - as for Wright.

Humphrey 5 - don't get me wrong I can see this fellow tries his best and as I said above he made a crucial interception early on, but he lacks invention and without any service from midfield be he simply cannot get past a fullback.

Welsh 8 - really put himself about.

Keane 7 - energetic and committed.

Gallagher 8 - had a lot of possession and did what was necessary to keep the ball and then play simple short passes.

Garner 8 - ran a lot, should have done better with second half chances but finish for the goal was stupendous.

Davies 8 - battled all the game.



Nice 1 Fettler. Good read...... Don't forget to mention the fans though... They sounded fantastic on the " player" commentary.
 
Humphrey is a weird one. Looking at the report above it suggests that he had a poor game. Listening to McInally on Sky yesterday it sounded as though he provided a bit of thrust in the first half and did ok. Similarly, SG (a man that many of us trust 100%) picks him for every away game.

I think as fans we have to accept that Humphrey will play in the vast majority of games, largely due to his defensive qualities. We should try to encourage him, rather than being negative (I don't mean on here - if he reads this then he is asking for trouble), as this could have a positive effect on his attacking performances.

Personally, I would pick him away, but play either Holmes or Jeff at home (in a 4-4-2). However, SG has forgotten a lot more about football than I know, and if he wants to go with Humphrey then so be it.
 
IMHO Davies was very very poor today. I'd of given him a 5.

Davies was one of our best players today IMO. He has brought a senses of calm and control to our game. Always in the right place, holds the ball up well and wins most balls in the air. Also good at defending set pieces.
 
Anyone else worried our away performances are much stronger than those at home? I dont travel away but attend all the home games and probably been treated to one excellent performance this season against Swindon.

Is there a reason for that? Is it the added pressure or maybe the poor and sometimes negative atmosphere?
 
And that makes his comment less valid how? Harry rednapp (who i think is a terrible c***) can by his own admission, barley read or write. He has done ok in football aint he?

You dont need to have read tolstoy to have thoughts on a football match

Possessing spellcheck or a dictionary would be a start though.
 
Humphrey was never as low as 5 - that's ridiculous. If people expect Ryan Giggs at his best from Humphreys they will be disappointed. He played in a midfield or back 5 and the game was won in midfield.
It was clearly Keane who crossed for the goal.
 
And that makes his comment less valid how?

You tell me?

Has somebody said he's not entitled to an opinion?

The point regarding the incorrect use of the word "of" in place of "have" is also a valid point wouldn't you say. It benefits every single person if everybody makes an effort with correct grammar and spelling doesn't it?

For what it might be worth my opinion of Davies is that he makes a massive contribution. Apart from his undoubted skill and strength he normally keeps both opposition centre backs fully occupied and thereby frees up space for our other attackers to exploit. He's effective at defensive set plays and no doubt his vast experience and knowledge has a big positive effect on the rest of our players especially the younger ones.
 
Glad to see that your views are finally based on actually seeing a game for a change. To give Humphrey a 5 and everybody else at least 7, including 9 for King, is rather weird!

Well he wasn't very good.

His much vaunted defensive qualities weren't up to looking after Batt, that's for sure (hence the substitution and Clarke and Keane doubling up for the last 5).
 
Thanks for the comments. Rem - I've never said anything other than that most of my comments are based on feedback and video highlights but I said before yesterday's game that if we could close down our opponents when they tried their inevitable early assault then we could get something and that is exactly what happened.

Re Humphrey he is fast, committed and has a very good attitude - he tracks back well and that interception he made early on yesterday, even if he fell over doing so, was crucial, but as an attacker he is very limited. He has no real vision and no trickery either - faced with a defender in front of him all he can do is either pass the ball sideways or push it past the defender and run after it. He needs the pass to beat the defender - remember that ball Holmes played inside the fullback against MK Dons at our place for Humphrey to run onto - and until we have someone else in midfield able to play those sort of balls for him he will never make much impact on the opposition as an attacker. Perhaps 6 would have been a fairer mark for him but I would replace him with Holmes for the next home game when we may well find ourselves trying to unpick a team trying to do to us what we did yesterday.
 
Thanks for the comments. Rem - I've never said anything other than that most of my comments are based on feedback and video highlights but I said before yesterday's game that if we could close down our opponents when they tried their inevitable early assault then we could get something and that is exactly what happened.

Re Humphrey he is fast, committed and has a very good attitude - he tracks back well and that interception he made early on yesterday, even if he fell over doing so, was crucial, but as an attacker he is very limited. He has no real vision and no trickery either - faced with a defender in front of him all he can do is either pass the ball sideways or push it past the defender and run after it. He needs the pass to beat the defender - remember that ball Holmes played inside the fullback against MK Dons at our place for Humphrey to run onto - and until we have someone else in midfield able to play those sort of balls for him he will never make much impact on the opposition as an attacker. Perhaps 6 would have been a fairer mark for him but I would replace him with Holmes for the next home game when we may well find ourselves trying to unpick a team trying to do to us what we did yesterday.

What about the fans yesterday ernest, what mark would you give them out of 10 ? 😉
 
What about the fans yesterday ernest, what mark would you give them out of 10 ? 😉

Oh yes 10 - even though I was right behind some fellow who spent most of the match on his feet making it difficult for the youngster at my side, the son of the friend who came along with me, to see at times. We need to start creating that sort of atmosphere at our place. The goal looked sharp and well-taken live, but not as spectacular as it looks on video. A great shame there were no league highlights yesterday - it would have been a great opportunity for the some coverage of the lower divisions.
 
Oh yes 10 - even though I was right behind some fellow who spent most of the match on his feet making it difficult for the youngster at my side, the son of the friend who came along with me, to see at times. We need to start creating that sort of atmosphere at our place. The goal looked sharp and well-taken live, but not as spectacular as it looks on video. A great shame there were no league highlights yesterday - it would have been a great opportunity for the some coverage of the lower divisions.

The atmosphere sounded superb on the radio and we do need to try to recreate some of this back at Deepdale, it would im sure help the team and also make for better watching for the fans ?
Hope the youngster with you enjoyed the game and the match experience and atmosphere, have you converted him in to a North Ender !
 
Back
Top