time for boyle?
Only thing can pick out of the CBs is their distribution is spotty, but at the end of the day we don't concede
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2005
- Messages
- 111,076
Have to say, what games are you watching?Really? Hunts gettin skinned over & over.. is good?
I've never seen Boyle play, so I can't comment on whether he should be in the team. Simon Grayson has, and presumably sees him every day in training. If he looked better than Clarke and Hunts then he'd be in. S G didn't mess about with new boy Horgan and soon had him in. I know we're all keen to see him but whilst the others are doing so well, it's a case of -leave well alone.
Only thing can pick out of the CBs is their distribution is spotty, but at the end of the day we don't concede
Clarke's distribution can be OK, Huntington's is often more or less non-existent. Both also lack a degree of agility and pace - if a forward gets past them anywhere near goal they are unlikely to be able to retrieve the situation. It is no coincidence that it was Cunningham who made that crucial last ditch interception yesterday. But both are strong, committed and characterful at present those attributes are serving us well. But if we want to progress then at some point we are going to need to import some of those currently missing attributes into the heart of the defence.
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
Both also lack a degree of agility and pace - if a forward gets past them anywhere near goal they are unlikely to be able to retrieve the situation.
This is utter bollox. IMO like.
This is utter bollox. IMO like.
See video of Aston Villa's first goal a few weeks back.
See video of Aston Villa's first goal a few weeks back.
Ernest, you're obsessed with centre backs having pace/being agile. These are very rare in today's game, even at the top level.
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2004
- Messages
- 10,645
After watching today i think its time we put boyle in. Thoughts?
On what basis?
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
That's a failure of defence due to positioning, not a lack of pace. The idea is to cut out those mistakes with consistently good organisation and positioning, which Clarke and Huntington are good at when they play together.See video of Aston Villa's first goal a few weeks back.This is utter bollox. IMO like.
However, they will eventually concede a chance (a chance the keeper could have dealt with in Villa's case, let's not forget).
Thought Huntington had a great game on Saturday, no problems with the defence.
Agreed. No nonsense defender
- Joined
- May 24, 2016
- Messages
- 5,141
Thought Huntington had a great game on Saturday, no problems with the defence.
We aren't as solid as last season and are conceding more but I think there are a few factors in that.
Opening up a bit and playing a bit more, we were very defensive last season.
Not having Pickford for half a season like last season.
Lindegaard pretty much not saving anything in the first batch of games.
Being unsettled by losing two mainstays in Woods (injury) and Wright (transfer).
The Woods thing in particular has been really bad. Been chasing tails since with loan deals and etc. I'd probably strengthen again at right back in the summer because who knows if he'll return the same player.
We aren't as solid as last season and are conceding more but I think there are a few factors in that.
Opening up a bit and playing a bit more, we were very defensive last season.
Not having Pickford for half a season like last season.
Lindegaard pretty much not saving anything in the first batch of games.
Being unsettled by losing two mainstays in Woods (injury) and Wright (transfer).
The Woods thing in particular has been really bad. Been chasing tails since with loan deals and etc. I'd probably strengthen again at right back in the summer because who knows if he'll return the same player.
Agree, i've no problem with conceding goals if it means were attempting to score more ourselves.
We've got some good attacking players, we don't need to rely on grinding out 1-0s and going safety first.
Our 'against column' has been a bit skewed by that collapse at Brentford and the Leeds game when they were clinical.
Conceded 1 less than Reading who sit 4th. Barnsley and Norwich both conceded more too.
Ernest, you're obsessed with centre backs having pace/being agile. These are very rare in today's game, even at the top level.
They are not all that rare - we had one in the form of Sean St Ledger and all I am saying is that if we could find ourselves another one that would give us something that we do not currently possess the lack of which is sometimes evident. That is not to disparage either Clarke or Huntington - but it was precisely to give us that extra bit of mobility in central defence, remember, that Baptiste was brought in because he was only switched to right-back when Vermilj was injured, so presumably SG thinks so as well.
Last season's champions had Hugh and Morgan !
We aren't as solid as last season and are conceding more but I think there are a few factors in that.
Opening up a bit and playing a bit more, we were very defensive last season.
Not having Pickford for half a season like last season.
Lindegaard pretty much not saving anything in the first batch of games.
Being unsettled by losing two mainstays in Woods (injury) and Wright (transfer).
The Woods thing in particular has been really bad. Been chasing tails since with loan deals and etc. I'd probably strengthen again at right back in the summer because who knows if he'll return the same player.
I'd actually forgotten about Calum Woods, hopefully he will return that injury, sounded to be a pretty bad one. We've definitely missed him this season and I think we'd have conceded fewer goals, also agree we should strengthen that position in summer because it's been a faff for us over the season so far really.
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2012
- Messages
- 4,112
Whilst the playoffs remain a faint possibility I don't think we should be experimenting - all it takes is a good run from us and we could be in the thick of it. As a result, we should try and win every game and not be changing the defence which was solid on Saturday.
Boyle will get his chance, and hopefully he'll grab it with both hands like Horgan has.
Boyle will get his chance, and hopefully he'll grab it with both hands like Horgan has.
Hunts looked like he was really enjoying the tussle with Bogle at the weekend. Didn't put a foot wrong as far as I could see and Clarke was arguably our best player.
I think the problem with the weekend is that I would have like to see Spurr on the bench then they could have moved Cunningham to a back three and wing backs rather than swopping the forwards for some long ball hold it up stuff. Considering switching the formations has been effective this season I was a bit surprised with our predictable back 4.
I would rather have Spurr on the bench at the moment than one of the strikers for a bit of variety.
I think the problem with the weekend is that I would have like to see Spurr on the bench then they could have moved Cunningham to a back three and wing backs rather than swopping the forwards for some long ball hold it up stuff. Considering switching the formations has been effective this season I was a bit surprised with our predictable back 4.
I would rather have Spurr on the bench at the moment than one of the strikers for a bit of variety.
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
Hunts looked like he was really enjoying the tussle with Bogle at the weekend. Didn't put a foot wrong as far as I could see and Clarke was arguably our best player.
I think the problem with the weekend is that I would have like to see Spurr on the bench then they could have moved Cunningham to a back three and wing backs rather than swopping the forwards for some long ball hold it up stuff. Considering switching the formations has been effective this season I was a bit surprised with our predictable back 4.
I would rather have Spurr on the bench at the moment than one of the strikers for a bit of variety.
Not sure about right now but Spurr has been injured.