Skip to main content

Time for Rudd?

Time for Rudd?

S

Stanneswhite

Joined
Dec 16, 2017
Messages
341
Don’t get me wrong, Maxwell is one of the best shot stoppers in this division. However, I feel that Rudd might perhaps be more reliable and deserves a chance given the excellent service he provided in his loan spell a few years back.
 
I seriously do despair, sometimes. Weve come out of our bad run, playing well, winning matches, conceding very few and here we go!

What is it with "Some," PNE fans?

Or was JD correct about this poster?
 
raefil said:
I seriously do despair, sometimes. Weve come out of our bad run, playing well, winning matches, conceding very few and here we go!

What is it with "Some," PNE fans?

Or was JD correct about this poster?
Click to expand...
Bloody hell someone has an agenda
 
Stanneswhite said:
I merely stated that it might be time to give Rudd a chance, and got hammered for it based on a misconception from a post a few weeks ago. Seems like an agenda to me.
Click to expand...

You've made the (some might say understandable) mistake of coming onto a football forum and EXPRESSING AN OPINION. You shouldn't really be doing that until you have at least 5,000 posts to your name. Now think on!
 
Stanneswhite said:
I merely stated that it might be time to give Rudd a chance, and got hammered for it based on a misconception from a post a few weeks ago. Seems like an agenda to me.
Click to expand...

Not really an agenda. Whatever that is. Just a spotlight on really really really bad threads.
What about a Welsh for captain thread? He's equally not had a look in this season.
I wonder why.
 
Schemer said:
You've made the (some might say understandable) mistake of coming onto a football forum and EXPRESSING AN OPINION. You shouldn't really be doing that until you have at least 5,000 posts to your name. Now think on!
Click to expand...

That is a fair point though.
 
California_PNE said:
Not really an agenda. Whatever that is. Just a spotlight on really really really bad threads.
What about a Welsh for captain thread? He's equally not had a look in this season.
I wonder why.
Click to expand...

That’s a ridiculous comparison. We have Pearson,Gally,Browne,Johnson ahead of Welsh compared to solely maxwell in goal. Rudd hasn’t had a chance to prove himself whilst here due to injury- Welsh has been here for years and is in his 30’s.
 
Stanneswhite said:
That’s a ridiculous comparison. We have Pearson,Gally,Browne,Johnson ahead of Welsh compared to solely maxwell in goal. Rudd hasn’t had a chance to prove himself whilst here due to injury- Welsh has been here for years and is in his 30’s.
Click to expand...

You can't be fuckin serious?
Are you serious?
Drop Maxwell for Rudd?

Based on what? Not had a chance? This my stupid suggestion Welsh should be captain cause he hasn't had a chance...

Look. Really, Maxwell has flaws and detractors, fucked up at Fulham without question, but let's be realistic, he has no doubt won us more points than lost, Christ it doesn't need an explanation.

C'mon.
 
California_PNE said:
You can't be fuckin serious?
Are you serious?
Drop Maxwell for Rudd?

Based on what? Not had a chance? This my stupid suggestion Welsh should be captain cause he hasn't had a chance...

Look. Really, Maxwell has flaws and detractors, fucked up at Fulham without question, but let's be realistic, he has no doubt won us more points than lost, Christ it doesn't need an explanation.

C'mon.
Click to expand...

I have no problem with Maxwell, he had near misses ( Burton, Sheff U) but yes has also had some excellent performances. Just stated that Rudd perhaps deserves a chance at some point,not suggesting maxwell should be dropped permanently or for a prolonged period. We have two great keepers and it makes sense to keep them both happy
 
Stanneswhite said:
I have no problem with Maxwell, he had near misses ( Burton, Sheff U) but yes has also had some excellent performances. Just stated that Rudd perhaps deserves a chance at some point,not suggesting maxwell should be dropped permanently or for a prolonged period. We have two great keepers and it makes sense to keep them both happy
Click to expand...

But your exact same argument applies to spurr Pringle Welsh O'Connor boyle etc. Not worth a thread. Really.
 
Stanneswhite said:
I have no problem with Maxwell, he had near misses ( Burton, Sheff U) but yes has also had some excellent performances. Just stated that Rudd perhaps deserves a chance at some point,not suggesting maxwell should be dropped permanently or for a prolonged period. We have two great keepers and it makes sense to keep them both happy
Click to expand...

I'm sure he will get his chance and that will be in the cup.
That's the dilemma with keepers in comparison with outfield players, barring injury or a serious drop in form you don't get a look in.
 
Back
Top