Skip to main content

Today

Today

Well not really, playing Clarke there enables us to switch to 3-5-2 very easily if required and also gives Laird more freedom to attack knowing that Clarke will be sitting in.

Agreed and it also allows us to play our three best out and out defenders.
 
Here are a few of my thoughts from yesterday.

Barnsley were very organised and stopped us playing. We let them have too much of the ball and hardly pressured them. Beckford did well he tried to chase them down a few times but nobody else got involved.

I think we were lucky to get a goal as we didn't really have much driving force up front and didn't look like scoring too much. It wasn't a good game for any of our players really.

Barnsley used the wings, Clarke nor Laird could keep up and it wasn't a surprise they scored from a cross from the wing. I think Humphrey helped a little defensively just because he was fast enough to get back and be an extra man and his speed also helped going forward but that came to nothing in the final third. We were a little wasteful.

There were a couple of issues today but I think all in all a good point. I don't see us winning every game so as long as we continue to pick up points and keep ahead of the opposition, that'll see us through.
 
Or both could play.

Which means dropping Huntington or Wright. Again I wouldn't have Wiseman in ahead of them.

Seems Wiseman is in the same group as Woods in they seem to become better players the longer they're out of the side.
 
Which means dropping Huntington or Wright. Again I wouldn't have Wiseman in ahead of them.

Seems Wiseman is in the same group as Woods in they seem to become better players the longer they're out of the side.

Wiseman/Woods shouldn't really have anything to do with Wright/Hunts when it comes to selection.

The right backs, Wiseman and Woods, should fight for right back.

The centre backs, Clarke, Huntington and Wright, should fight for centre back.

Play players in the correct position.
 
Wiseman/Woods shouldn't really have anything to do with Wright/Hunts when it comes to selection.

The right backs, Wiseman and Woods, should fight for right back.

The centre backs, Clarke, Huntington and Wright, should fight for centre back.

Play players in the correct position.

Clarke is the best right-back in League One. Just shut up and accept that.
 
Wiseman/Woods shouldn't really have anything to do with Wright/Hunts when it comes to selection.

The right backs, Wiseman and Woods, should fight for right back.

The centre backs, Clarke, Huntington and Wright, should fight for centre back.

Play players in the correct position.

I'd prefer to play my 4 best defenders which are the moment can't be argued Grayson is doing. Dropping Clarke now for Wiseman would be a mistake, and for what, the fact he might get a couple more crosses in during a game? Don't make out as though Wiseman was creating loads of chances and scoring loads of goals. And as mentioned previously having Wright, Huntington and Clarke on the pitch enables us to switch to 3-5-2.

Is Clarke a better CB than Wiseman? Yes
Is Clarke a better RB than Wiseman? It's very close, I'd say on a par
Does playing Clarke over Wiseman allow more flexibility formation wise? Yes
Have we been a great run with goals conceded? Yes

Wiseman and Woods, becoming better players by not playing.
 
As a right-back Clarke is solid - maybe a bit stolid - defensively but not as mobile going forward as Wiseman. That deficiency is probably aggravated by the fact that with Robinson playing on the left and Gallagher seemingly more inclined to move left than right we probably lack a bit of attacking balance. Could Robinson play on the right?
 
As a right-back Clarke is solid - maybe a bit stolid - defensively but not as mobile going forward as Wiseman. That deficiency is probably aggravated by the fact that with Robinson playing on the left and Gallagher seemingly more inclined to move left than right we probably lack a bit of attacking balance. Could Robinson play on the right?

At a push maybe but he's at his best when he's coming inside, I wouldn't play him there at the expense of Humphrey.

The current team needs no tinkering, unless it's forced. 10 unbeaten, winning 8, 4 goals conceded, 22 scored.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
SG likes 3 tall good headers to attack and defend set pieces. Clarke, Wright and Huntington.

Wiseman and Woods do not go up for set pieces as their heading ability is not good.
 
SG likes 3 tall good headers to attack and defend set pieces. Clarke, Wright and Huntington.

Wiseman and Woods do not go up for set pieces as their heading ability is not good.

Wiseman offers a lot more attacking-wise from right back than Clarke though.
 
I'd prefer to play my 4 best defenders which are the moment can't be argued Grayson is doing. Dropping Clarke now for Wiseman would be a mistake, and for what, the fact he might get a couple more crosses in during a game? Don't make out as though Wiseman was creating loads of chances and scoring loads of goals. And as mentioned previously having Wright, Huntington and Clarke on the pitch enables us to switch to 3-5-2.

Is Clarke a better CB than Wiseman? Yes
Is Clarke a better RB than Wiseman? It's very close, I'd say on a par
Does playing Clarke over Wiseman allow more flexibility formation wise? Yes
Have we been a great run with goals conceded? Yes

Wiseman and Woods, becoming better players by not playing.

Having Wiseman on also allows us to switch to 3-5-2 as he can play at the right side of the back 3 but yes I understand your point.

By the way I wouldn't drop him for Clarke I'd drop him for Wright.

Agree he doesn't create a load of chances but he does give us a threat from deep like Laird does sometimes.
 
At a push maybe but he's at his best when he's coming inside, I wouldn't play him there at the expense of Humphrey.

The current team needs no tinkering, unless it's forced. 10 unbeaten, winning 8, 4 goals conceded, 22 scored.

Arguably Robinson is really a striker being asked to play in a wider role because Reid has so far proved a bit of a misfire and Humphrey though hard-working and pacy is only intermittently effective as an attacker. Mind you looking at the highlights from Saturday he certainly turned their defender inside out before setting up the goal. If we are forced to alter the line-up on Sunday because of Wright being absent then with Wiseman also on international duty I would just shift Clarke back to the centre and slot Woods in at right-back. The absolute no-no as far as I am concerned is using Garner as a lone striker.
 
As a right-back Clarke is solid - maybe a bit stolid - defensively but not as mobile going forward as Wiseman. That deficiency is probably aggravated by the fact that with Robinson playing on the left and Gallagher seemingly more inclined to move left than right we probably lack a bit of attacking balance. Could Robinson play on the right?

ernest, have you ever heard of the saying "if it ain't broke don't fix it"?
 
Arguably Robinson is really a striker being asked to play in a wider role because Reid has so far proved a bit of a misfire and Humphrey though hard-working and pacy is only intermittently effective as an attacker. Mind you looking at the highlights from Saturday he certainly turned their defender inside out before setting up the goal. If we are forced to alter the line-up on Sunday because of Wright being absent then with Wiseman also on international duty I would just shift Clarke back to the centre and slot Woods in at right-back. The absolute no-no as far as I am concerned is using Garner as a lone striker.

I reckon Woods for Wright will be the only change on Sunday.
 
ernest, have you ever heard of the saying "if it ain't broke don't fix it"?

Indeed I have. But there is also 'it is doing OK but it could be a bit better'. As it is I wouldn't change the starting line-upfrom the last couple of games unless forced to do so - something which it seems will be necessary this week-end and which will give us the opportunity to give us an extra bit of attacking width.
 
Back
Top