Skip to main content

Todays Ref, bottled it.

Todays Ref, bottled it.

Re the challenge by ayling on Pearson....I've never seen a ref talk to a player for so long without showing a card. Bartley should have gone for the challenge on Beckford but he got distracted by the Beckford red card. The challenge on Johnson in the first half was disgraceful, how he failed to show a card for that as unbelievable. The handball against Robinson was one of the worst decisions I've ever seen
 
At half time, I thought we were still in the game, and the next goal was all important. We should really have got a second if Robbo had some power in his shot, and Browne, well let's not go there, enough said!!!

Robinson flatters to deceive. He beats two or three players, then there's no end product.

Browne, he got caught out on more than one occasion, Robinson needs to beef up, decent player, but needs some muscle.
 
Also how the feck him and the linesman missed the stamp on the back of Makienok leg by Jansson is beyond me. Was a horrible challenge.
 
Let's get it right, we didn't lose yesterday because of the referee - we were poor and Leeds (unfortunately) were better than us. Poor choice of formation and tactics also cost us again IMHO.

BUT the referee clearly DID put in an extremely poor and inconsistent performance. Within the first few minutes of the game that Bartley (no.5) tucked the referee in his back pocket when he made his feelings known to the referee after a 50/50 challenge with Makienok. After that, the ref gave every challenge in Bartleys favour. He was clearly blinkered, missed all sorts of other incidents and made a lot of mistakes. Very poor, weak refereeing.
 
Last edited:
Let's get it right, we didn't lose yesterday because of the referee - we were poor and Leeds (unfortunately) were better than us. Poor choice of formation and tactics also cost us again IMHO.

BUT the referee clear DID put in an extremely poor and inconsistent performance. Within the first few minutes of the game that Bartley (no.5) tucked the referee in his back pocket when he made his feelings known to the referee after a 50/50 challenge with Makienok. After that, the ref gave every challenge in Bartleys favour. He was clearly blinkered, missed all sorts of other incidents and made a lot of mistakes. Very poor, weak refereeing.

Agree totally but I'd add Gary Monk set up to win the game whilst Grayson lined up to be hard to beat.
 
Agreed. That lad was at it all game, barging, elbowing and going through and over players. Makienok got one down the back of his calf (that might have been the other centre half). But yes, poor referee.

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk
That was a bad foul and could have caused a serious injury and went un - punished by the ref, the Leeds player made no attempt to play the ball. It was the other centre back as you stated the Number 5 Barkley went over and congratulated him on the tackle and shook his hand 😡
 
Last edited:
Should have had a penalty for hand ball at the start of the second half.

Crunching late challenge on Pearson was a yellow minimum.

Jumping into the back of Beckford knee first is a yellow and off.

Hauling Hugill down on the left wing should have been a yellow and off.

Yep he was bloody awful and whilst we didn't play well, these are huge decision that he got wrong and could have seriously affected the end result.

Nice One.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Browne, he got caught out on more than one occasion, Robinson needs to beef up, decent player, but needs some muscle.
I agree and think young Callum will beef up with age and maturity. My problem with him is his first touch - he always seems to first touch it nearer to his opponent than himself and then ends up having to scrap to get it back under control.
 
We were better than Newcastle but lost the game, do you think ref's don't have an influence on results?
Yes but poor reffing is often an excuse that gets trotted out too often, and only when we lose. Whenever we win, you rarely get posters saying 'thank god the ref was in our favour, otherwise we might have lost that match.' Unless it's marsbars of course.
 
Thought that the ref did ok. The free kick that lead to the first goal was given by the linesman, but he didn't know we weren't going to jump to head the ball! Beckford 's reaction to being crunched by the 2 Leeds players changed the dynamics of the game. Instead of booking the aggressors, and making them have 10 men, he sent off the aggrieved Beckford and killed our potential comeback.
 
Yes but poor reffing is often an excuse that gets trotted out too often, and only when we lose. Whenever we win, you rarely get posters saying 'thank god the ref was in our favour, otherwise we might have lost that match.' Unless it's marsbars of course.

Just because we criticise a ref doesn't mean it's being used as an excuse, people give their opinions on the games and inevitably the refs performance is part of that. Unfortunately it's usually negative because they make so many mistakes. I still criticise them when we win if it's appropriate, let's face it when was the last time we had a ref in our favour?
 
Thought that the ref did ok. The free kick that lead to the first goal was given by the linesman, but he didn't know we weren't going to jump to head the ball! Beckford 's reaction to being crunched by the 2 Leeds players changed the dynamics of the game. Instead of booking the aggressors, and making them have 10 men, he sent off the aggrieved Beckford and killed our potential comeback.
Just contradicted yourself there....he did ok but got the most important decision wrong!
 
We were better than Newcastle but lost the game, do you think ref's don't have an influence on results?

Of course they do, and in the Newcastle case it was blatant, to the point where the Ref issued an 'apology' after the game. Yesterday, Leeds deserved to win. Had nothing to do with the Ref.
 
Thought that the ref did ok. The free kick that lead to the first goal was given by the linesman, but he didn't know we weren't going to jump to head the ball! Beckford 's reaction to being crunched by the 2 Leeds players changed the dynamics of the game. Instead of booking the aggressors, and making them have 10 men, he sent off the aggrieved Beckford and killed our potential comeback.

Eh? The aggrieved Beckford? Are you suggesting he shouldn't have been sent off?
 
Slagging the Ref off is always an easy excuse. They were better than us, simple as that.

Hate it when managers use the referee an excuse for results , but yesterday he was poor and inconsistent in his handling of the game especially the physical side, that said Leeds were better than us in all departments and deserved to run out winners.
 
Hate it when managers use the referee an excuse for results , but yesterday he was poor and inconsistent in his handling of the game especially the physical side, that said Leeds were better than us in all departments and deserved to run out winners.

I think the days of managers slagging off the Refs are over. They're too wary of being fined over it, and choose to very much sit on the fence (or just refuse to comment). It's just left to folk like you and me these days. And for what it's worth, I agree with what you said.
 
Back
Top