Skip to main content

Tom Clarke

Tom Clarke

jcfartpants

Chief Anal Acoustician
Joined
Feb 6, 2013
Messages
19,527
Location
Rutland
I take cover as I write, being at the risk of being hit on from every side on here. Solid though he is and committed to the cause that he is and thus may make a good captain, his distribution seems to consist of long speculative balls on 90% of occasions.

It may be a case of manager instructions, but I don't see Bailey Wright doing the same and Larry seems to want the team to be playing the ball on the deck through Browne, Brownhill and Kilkenny.
 
May I say this. We drew 1-1. We didn't lose and we apparently played well first half. Now people need to stop thinking they are football managers and just wait until atleast mid season to judge the team and players, not one game against a team who obviously didn't want to play football let alone let us pass the ball.
 
I take cover as I write, being at the risk of being hit on from every side on here. Solid though he is and committed to the cause that he is and thus may make a good captain, his distribution seems to consist of long speculative balls on 90% of occasions.

It may be a case of manager instructions, but I don't see Bailey Wright doing the same and Larry seems to want the team to be playing the ball on the deck through Browne, Brownhill and Kilkenny.

I don't think Wright's distribution is any better to be honest. The only centre back who does distribute quite well is King, but he can be suspect defensively. Apart from the odd one, like Tarkowski who was at Oldham, there aren't many centre backs in League 1 who are great at passing the ball out.

Personally, I think Clarke is more of a 2nd centre back, the type who used to wear no.6 in the old days. We desperately need a dominant centre back, a real no.5, at the heart of our defence. Myself, I would rather have Huntington in there alongside Clarke at the moment. He has his limitations but is the best we have in the air and I can't recall him ever really letting the side down.
 
May I say this. We drew 1-1. We didn't lose and we apparently played well first half. Now people need to stop thinking they are football managers and just wait until atleast mid season to judge the team and players, not one game against a team who obviously didn't want to play football let alone let us pass the ball.

People who went and payed for the privilege are entitled to voice an opinion on what they saw and second half was not good.I am not writing the manager/team off but am entitled to say that.
Professional sport is extremely well payed even at our level and so must expect to be judged with a critical eye regarding performance.
 
May I say this. We drew 1-1. We didn't lose and we apparently played well first half. Now people need to stop thinking they are football managers and just wait until atleast mid season to judge the team and players, not one game against a team who obviously didn't want to play football let alone let us pass the ball.

Come on mate, it's a forum and that's what we discuss. I'm not judging him based on one game -having seen him play all last season as well - for me, it is one of the downsides of his game.

And they did let us pass the ball.
 
May I say this. We drew 1-1. We didn't lose and we apparently played well first half. Now people need to stop thinking they are football managers and just wait until atleast mid season to judge the team and players, not one game against a team who obviously didn't want to play football let alone let us pass the ball.

I've been playing Football management games since 1989 pal, since the days of Football Director on the Spectrum Plus 2.

I think I know more than Grayson. Let's look at the facts - Grayson has loaned out Beavon to another club. Did we win yesterday? No. What would have made us win? A goal from Beavon, or a pass from Beavon leading to a goal. 2-1 North End. Boom.

SO who looks foolish now?
 
I thought Wright was more suspect than Clarke yesterday. Woods was poor too. But should we ring the changes already? No. It's one game and the only problem we had at half time was that we hadn't stuck the ball in the net yet. It's early days, teams grow into a season. There's much more to come from this group of players. In Grayson we trust.
 
Not sure why some people are obsessed with centre backs being good passers.

Apparently that's King, but he can't defend and was caught napping on the ball a few times last season. I know which style and who I'd prefer in what Clarke does and what King does.

3 new members of the back 5 yesterday, and Wright struggling to find the form of early in last season it will take a few games for it to settle down.
 
from a game in which the opposition had few attempts at goal it is curious that we are finding faults in the back 4....none of whom came out well yesterday. The full-backs will improve and have cover. the centre-backs both made mistakes and there is no real cover. Hunts is not a strong defender and king is good back up when needed. I think its been said many times but we need a commanding centre back. ben Davies is a ball-playing centre back but not with the others currently playing that position.
 
didn't think he was a slouch...maybe in his younger days...or maybe memory has faded such that these defenders of the past now just seem awesome heroes. I think mawene, davis and Lucketti were better than league 1 defenders and I'm not sure you can say that about the current selection
 
didn't think he was a slouch...maybe in his younger days...or maybe memory has faded such that these defenders of the past now just seem awesome heroes. I think mawene, davis and Lucketti were better than league 1 defenders and I'm not sure you can say that about the current selection

Oh he wasn't slow by any means, not until after his bad injury.

Even then he was still a solid CB.
 
May I say this. We drew 1-1. We didn't lose and we apparently played well first half. Now people need to stop thinking they are football managers and just wait until atleast mid season to judge the team and players, not one game against a team who obviously didn't want to play football let alone let us pass the ball.

Sanity begins to break out
 
Back
Top