Skip to main content

Tom Clarke

Tom Clarke

Joined
Jan 17, 2015
Messages
13,443
Location
Preston
Early days I know, but long term, is he going to successfully make the step up in this league ?

The last couple of games in particular, he has looked very poor and slow, and even at times, out of his depth.

The crosser of the ball tonight for their goal seemed to have the freedom of Preston, on Clarke's side.

One thing's for sure, he's definitely not a right back imo.

Grayson needs to pick which 2 centre backs to play and have the bollocks to drop one of them. 3 at the back clearly isn't working.
 
I don't think we have benefited from playing a 3 in def, most home games it ends up being a 5 anyway! drop one, play a natural right and left back, 4-4-2 or similar and lets start having a go at teams. We should have lost the game tonight really, they had 3 golden opportunities - we created nothing and had it not had been for a wonder goal, we would have been well out of the game.
 
Probably because he's not a right back and Vermijl is garbage?

Hasn't he mainly been playing as one of 3 centre backs ? That position on the right of a back 3 isn't exactly right back, otherwise it could be said bailey Wright has been playing left back.

That said, I agree he's not a right back. Their goal came from his side once he had been moved there tonight, once we'd changed to a back 4 when Humphrey was bizarrely subbed.
 
Early days I know, but long term, is he going to successfully make the step up in this league ?

The last couple of games in particular, he has looked very poor and slow, and even at times, out of his depth.

The crosser of the ball tonight for their goal seemed to have the freedom of Preston, on Clarke's side.

One thing's for sure, he's definitely not a right back imo.

Grayson needs to pick which 2 centre backs to play and have the bollocks to drop one of them. 3 at the back clearly isn't working.
Nail on head.To be fair,it's a tough decision to make.Who would you drop?
 
Nail on head.To be fair,it's a tough decision to make.Who would you drop?

At this moment in time Tom Clarke.

I think we need to go back to a back 4, with a proper RB, a proper LB, and let the CBs fight it out for those 2 positions.

Clarke is probably best at CB in a back 4. He is struggling in this position on the right of a back 3, and I think most people now accept that at this level, he cannot play at RB in a back 4, largely due to lack of pace.
 
Huddersfeild fans say that Clarke's best games for them in the Championship was as a DCM, so maybe we could try him there in a 4.1.4.1 formation?

Pickford
Woods
Wright
Huntington
Cunningham

Clarke

Humphrey
Browne
Johnson
Doyle

Garner
 
Last edited:
Nail on head.To be fair,it's a tough decision to make.Who would you drop?

Been rock solid since he signed but getting found out too often in this league & needs playing at CB. Having said that of the 3 he would be the most likely to get dropped.
 
Clarke was average last season.

He escapes a lot of criticism due to that goal v Lashers which in itself is wrong. Had he not scored, he'd be getting the stick that he warrants.

Needs benching.
 
Clarke was average last season.

He escapes a lot of criticism due to that goal v Lashers which in itself is wrong. Had he not scored, he'd be getting the stick that he warrants.

Needs benching.
Funnily enough, almost exactly the same could be said about Huntington, just switch "that goal v Lashers" with "those goals last season".

Decisions, decisions, who'd be a manager.
 
He certainly wasn't average last season, especially not when playing CB. I believe he could play RB in league 1 fairly successfully as the pace and trickery isn't the standard of the Championship.

Get him back to his natural CB position, and play Woods/Vermjil at RB
 
Clarke seems to be be suffering as a right-back in the way Laird would have done at left-back if he had stayed. At Championship level Clarke is just about serviceable as one of a back three and might or might not be the same in the middle of a back four. The same seems to be true of Huntington. If we do sign another central defender and they are a cut above what we have now then they have to go straight into the side. Frankly SG may have to start making some harsh decisions about players who were heroes last season - Clarke, Huntington, Kilkenny, maybe even Welsh. They are all players who showed they can be good a level lower and you imagine that if they were told they were free to look for other clubs then there are outfits at the level who ought to be interested in them.
 
Clarke seems to be be suffering as a right-back in the way Laird would have done at left-back if he had stayed. At Championship level Clarke is just about serviceable as one of a back three and might or might not be the same in the middle of a back four. The same seems to be true of Huntington. If we do sign another central defender and they are a cut above what we have now then they have to go straight into the side. Frankly SG may have to start making some harsh decisions about players who were heroes last season - Clarke, Huntington, Kilkenny, maybe even Welsh. They are all players who showed they can be good a level lower and you imagine that if they were told they were free to look for other clubs then there are outfits at the level who ought to be interested in them.

Agree with this, Kilkenny and Huntington are not up to scratch in the Championship simple but I trust Grayson to slowly improve the squad bit by bit like he has done since he got here.
 
Clarke has been exposed the last two games with having Vermijl and Humphrey as wing backs. Both have not been deep enough on several occasions and Clarke is getting pulled wide. The only genuine wing back we have is Cunningham.....who is getting better and fitter by the game.
 
early days i know, but long term, is he going to successfully make the step up in this league ?

The last couple of games in particular, he has looked very poor and slow, and even at times, out of his depth.

The crosser of the ball tonight for their goal seemed to have the freedom of preston, on clarke's side.

One thing's for sure, he's definitely not a right back imo.

Grayson needs to pick which 2 centre backs to play and have the bollocks to drop one of them. 3 at the back clearly isn't working.
didnt get a regular game with grayson in this league before and its easy to see why, too slow and out of his depth....along with huntingdon
 
Clarke has been exposed the last two games with having Vermijl and Humphrey as wing backs. Both have not been deep enough on several occasions and Clarke is getting pulled wide. The only genuine wing back we have is Cunningham.....who is getting better and fitter by the game.

Agree that Vermijl left him exposed on Saturday, but I don't think Humphrey did yesterday.

As for Cunningham, he looks a very good defender but doesn't seem up to much when it comes to the attacking side of playing wing back.
 
Back
Top