Skip to main content

Tonights referee.

Tonights referee.

raefil

Dolly Patron
Joined
Jan 11, 2005
Messages
111,063
Ive a feeling that some might not agree with me here.

I thought he was excellent. One of the few Ive seen that allowed the game the game to be played and didnt make it about himself. Yes he made the odd mistake, but that was both ways, but no daft yellows, not stopping the game for petty fouls he just let the players slug it out. first class for me.

Tin Hat on 🙂
 
It's not often I disagree with you raefil, but I thought he was the worst.

He was lucky that he had very few little decisions to make. He wasn't biased, he was just a idiot.

EDIT: NO DAFT YELLOWS? AT WHAT POINT DOES A LATE DANGEROUS CHALLENGE GETTING IGNORED BECOME NEGLIGENT REFEREEING? IT'S EXACTLY WHAT RESULTED IN LAIRD HAVING HIS LEG BROKEN.

Sorry.
 
I just feel that if it had been a different ref he would have dished out a few more cards.

No real problems with the way he refereed it as long as all the other refs do so in a similar manner. Too much inconsistencies between refs is the problem.
 
Ive a feeling that some might not agree with me here.

I thought he was excellent. One of the few Ive seen that allowed the game the game to be played and didnt make it about himself. Yes he made the odd mistake!!

Tin Hat on 🙂

Biggest load of horse shit I've read today.

He was so far up his own arse it was unreal.

Perfect example of small man syndrome!
 
I haven't seen a good referee this season, and after tonight, I still haven't. He should have booked a few of there players to start with. Then booked Garner at the end when he did nothing. Thank fuck that in the play offs we will get a top flight ref.
 
agree with OP probably best this season, let the game flow...other refs would have stopped both garner and davies from roughing them up as much as they did.

edit: garner rightly booked at end, cheating sod 🙂
 
What were you watching? He had a shocker. Numerous clear bookings went unpunished, especially when the lad went through the back of Wright, Garner was booked for absolutely nothing, how he thought that was a dive is beyond me. Stopped the game for a head injury as Claude Davis was getting to his feet, stopped the game when the lad fell over by the touchline, wasn't a head injury, but wouldn't stop it when Wiseman was clearly struggling. He was even petty enough to take the extra ball off the ballboy, but since he's never played football, he wouldn't kick it over, he had to run right the way across the pitch. The few decisions he had to make, he got wrong.
 
agree with OP probably best this season, let the game flow...other refs would have stopped both garner and davies from roughing them up as much as they did.

edit: garner rightly booked at end, cheating sod 🙂
Garner fell over after sprinting to beat the keeper to it, late in the game and he probably thought he was about to get clattered, made no attempt to claim a penalty, just looked frustrated that he'd missed.
 
Garner was correctly booked. He over hit the ball and when he realised he wasn't going to catch it he went down.
 
Ive a feeling that some might not agree with me here.

I thought he was excellent. One of the few Ive seen that allowed the game the game to be played and didnt make it about himself. Yes he made the odd mistake, but that was both ways, but no daft yellows, not stopping the game for petty fouls he just let the players slug it out. first class for me.

Tin Hat on 🙂

specsavers.jpg
 
Ive a feeling that some might not agree with me here.

I thought he was excellent. One of the few Ive seen that allowed the game the game to be played and didnt make it about himself. Yes he made the odd mistake, but that was both ways, but no daft yellows, not stopping the game for petty fouls he just let the players slug it out. first class for me.

Tin Hat on 🙂

I was in the Sumners after the game and a few Rotherham fans were saying he was our 12th man.
 
Biggest load of horse shit I've read today.

He was so far up his own arse it was unreal.

Perfect example of small man syndrome!


Ha ha ha! Practically everyone I sit near with on the IP were saying the same thing!

I thought he was very weak and got several decisions wrong - the yellow card in particular for Garner was an absolute joke!
 
He tripped up. Didn't appeal for a penalty?

He'd been going down easily all game and made a rod for his back in my opinion.

At the end of the day, not enough of these are given. Too many players are given the benefit of the doubt when simulating. I can't moan too much whatever Garner had in his head.

He was like a man possessed in the second half though. Brilliant.
 
Garner was correctly booked. He over hit the ball and when he realised he wasn't going to catch it he went down.

He stumbled from our view getting to the ball then held his he'd in his hands in disappointment. Mr Garner is a bit of a so and so but I thought he was badly done to tonight.
 
Back
Top