Skip to main content

Utter Garbage

Utter Garbage

His ability to keep possession is useful when he plays as a wing-back in away games but in home games he needs to have a fullback behind him so that he can be freed up to run at the opposition defence.

I said last night that I just can't decide what sort of player Reach is. He's neat and tidy, efficient and his positional play seems very good - but I'm not sure what his best position is. He's not playing badly but on the whole that's something you could say about most of the team. There is one big issue IMO and he shows no signs of having anything other than a Plan A.

If Mr Hemmings could have heard the rumblings on the way home last night he'd have been worried. No matter how many times white123 says our aim is to just stay up this year it absolutely isn't. Mr Hemmings wants mid table and to build for next season, a skin of the teeth safety season with one real chance in 90 minutes against a relegation rival is not going to persuade the 6,000 or so people with heavily discounted season tickets to renew next season - when they'll have to pay a lot more.
 
Just answered your question oooo,you asked if it was my first game and I replied, no reference to our 'election' Season, that was bad yes and If you think its bad now you clearly wasn't around under Chapman ! Look, im not having a go,I to an extent agree with you,its pretty shit a lot of the time, however the players have to take some of the responsibility and last night was one of them occasions.

I agree the players have to take responsibility but our strikers won't score when the ball is pinged at their head and for me the tactics were all wrong.

Woods, Cunningham, Reach and Gally were all out of position and yes that is OK to stifle the opposition but it also stifles our attacking options and last night we should have gone out their with the attention to win.

We have 5 defenders at times against what looked like Ameobi up top on his own
 
Exactly. His starting position last night was too deep. I also rate Cunningham going forward which is also wasted as part of 3 centre halves

Both did well in the same type of formation as last night in the previous two away games but it must be obvious to SG by now that we need to set ourselves up differently for home games. But I don't think a flat 4.4.2 would necessarily be the answer - a key to our solidity is having Browne, Gallagher and Johnson close together as a central midfield trio. I've said what I think might work elsewhere.
 
I said last night that I just can't decide what sort of player Reach is. He's neat and tidy, efficient and his positional play seems very good - but I'm not sure what his best position is. He's not playing badly but on the whole that's something you could say about most of the team. There is one big issue IMO and he shows no signs of having anything other than a Plan A.

If Mr Hemmings could have heard the rumblings on the way home last night he'd have been worried. No matter how many times white123 says our aim is to just stay up this year it absolutely isn't. Mr Hemmings wants mid table and to build for next season, a skin of the teeth safety season with one real chance in 90 minutes against a relegation rival is not going to persuade the 6,000 or so people with heavily discounted season tickets to renew next season - when they'll have to pay a lot more.

Reach is indeed supposed to be a winger. But Grayson being Grayson believes wingers should be wing backs or even full backs rather than anything remotely resembling attacking.
 
Both did well in the same type of formation as last night in the previous two away games but it must be obvious to SG by now that we need to set ourselves up differently for home games. But I don't think a flat 4.4.2 would necessarily be the answer - a key to our solidity is having Browne, Gallagher and Johnson close together as a central midfield trio. I've said what I think might work elsewhere.

I think Gally offers more to the strikers a bit wider. Garner is good in the air attacking crosses but we have a very narrow central midfield which is great when Beckford is playing on the last man but the other strikers don't play like that
 
I think Gally offers more to the strikers a bit wider. Garner is good in the air attacking crosses but we have a very narrow central midfield which is great when Beckford is playing on the last man but the other strikers don't play like that

He is not a winger and would be wasted out wide all the time but if he can get into positions from he can cross the ball a bit more often then yes that could add to our attacking threat.
 
He is not a winger and would be wasted out wide all the time but if he can get into positions from he can cross the ball a bit more often then yes that could add to our attacking threat.

Playing off the front two allows him more freedom to do this. This sitting back role allows him very little freedom and will stop him getting in goal scoring positions. Yes he scored two at Charlton playing there but one was a free kick and the other directly after a corner
 
Ok, Grayson tactics are shit. We are already relegated (according to some people.) Lets sack Grayson and bring king Billy back.

(but you pin all of it on grayson when players should just take as much accountability as the players should.) Reach, browne, doyle, garner where all equally poor as hugill, but hugill is an idiot for blowing that chance.
Some people have to pin it all on Grayson - they can't forgive him for winning promotion and proving them wrong back in January.

So we get people telling us Grayson's signings are a waste of money and loans in one breath, but in the next telling us these same players would be capable of playing exciting, attacking Championship-level football if it wasn't for Grayson's tactics.
 
Playing off the front two allows him more freedom to do this. This sitting back role allows him very little freedom and will stop him getting in goal scoring positions. Yes he scored two at Charlton playing there but one was a free kick and the other directly after a corner

Indeed it does. But if we are going to play him there then SG has to find a formation that allows him to do so while still giving us a midfield that can get a grip on a game. With four at the back that would be a trio of Browne, Johnson and someone else but who - I would like to see Brownhill get a go. With three at the back then Browne and Johnson in the centre with Reach to the left would make sense but we have no really obvious candidate for the right. We need a new Gareth Ainsworth.
 
Some people have to pin it all on Grayson - they can't forgive him for winning promotion and proving them wrong back in January.

So we get people telling us Grayson's signings are a waste of money and loans in one breath, but in the next telling us these same players would be capable of playing exciting, attacking Championship-level football if it wasn't for Grayson's tactics.

Either way that boils down to Grayson then
 
Indeed it does. But if we are going to play him there then SG has to find a formation that allows him to do so while still giving us a midfield that can get a grip on a game. With four at the back that would be a trio of Browne, Johnson and someone else but who - I would like to see Brownhill get a go. With three at the back then Browne and Johnson in the centre with Reach to the left would make sense but we have no really obvious candidate for the right. We need a new Gareth Ainsworth.

For me that's an area we could have spent the wasted £800k on.... but we bought a 6th choice striker instead
 
I agree the players have to take responsibility but our strikers won't score when the ball is pinged at their head and for me the tactics were all wrong.

There was very little movement by our forwards. Despite having 6 of them, Beckford is the only one who offers pace on the shoulder/in behind. We are far too slow up front. Also, there were a few times when Reach/Vermijl were about to put balls into the box and the strikers were on the edge of the penalty area for some reason.
 
No it doesn't.

You need to get your story straight, and not try having it both ways - because some of us notice the glaring inconsistency there.

He bought the players including 3 strikers this summer and he picks the tactics. Either one they aren't good enough or two his tactics are causing us some issues to the point not one has scored in 14 league games....

Either way it's a failing of the manager. Inconsistency, or can't figure out for sure which of these two things Grayson is to blame for if not a bit of both ....
 
There was very little movement by our forwards. Despite having 6 of them, Beckford is the only one who offers pace on the shoulder/in behind. We are far too slow up front. Also, there were a few times when Reach/Vermijl were about to put balls into the box and the strikers were on the edge of the penalty area for some reason.

Probably use to us not beating the first man and gave up ?
 
He bought the players including 3 strikers this summer and he picks the tactics. Either one they aren't good enough or two his tactics are causing us some issues to the point not one has scored in 14 league games....
Well, come on - which one is it? Surely you must know? It's crucial to your whole argument.

Either way it's a failing of the manager.
Remind us, who signs the players?
 
Well, come on - which one is it? Surely you must know? It's crucial to your whole argument.

Remind us, who signs the players?

Who picks the players they want? Grayson has picked the players other than Wright, Huntington, Welsh, Garner, Brownhill and Browne.... The rest will have come from Grayson and the financials tied up from someone higher up.

My argument is Grayson is too blame for our wasted signings and his tactics also cause us problems.
 
Back
Top