Skip to main content

Vale View

Vale View

They can't score while we keep the ball...

Admittedly that's not working because we've conceded loads this season, but I'd rather keep the ball than see it hoofed long and invariably straight to the opposition who can then attack us.

Still think we concede too many goals because we lack a dominant goalkeeper & Centre half.. The final pieces in the jigsaw if you will.. Maybe a recall for Huntingdon would be a start?
 
Its called posession football & I like it

Some were moaning in the Sir Tom Finney about the tippy Tappy but then PNE scored , the argument for it is if Port Vale are chasing after the ball they can't score and / or PNE can't get caught out by long through balls , remember the Rotherham goal in the play off semi final first leg ? …also you can tire the opposition out and one or two of their players could lose their discipline and be out of position ruining the team shape .

Liverpool used to do that all the time to the opposition in their heyday , probing ..a more continental style but it tended to be around the centre circle / opposition half …more waves of attacks , European teams can play quite slowly then speed it up in the final third

Just need a bit of patience .
 
The nature of the game changed on Tuesday when Welsh was taken off, we lost some bite in the midfield and with Holmes, Brownhill and Kilkenny we had nobody to put a tackle in.
 
The nature of the game changed on Tuesday when Welsh was taken off, we lost some bite in the midfield and with Holmes, Brownhill and Kilkenny we had nobody to put a tackle in.

Which I would like to think wouldn't happen in a league game. I think Welsh was only taken off due to him not being fully fit yet.
 
They can't score while we keep the ball...

Admittedly that's not working because we've conceded loads this season, but I'd rather keep the ball than see it hoofed long and invariably straight to the opposition who can then attack us.

3 things of keeping the ball like that....

They haven't got it so can't hurt us / score
Our players are having a breather whilst theirs are running after the ball - it's much easier with it than without
Probing for a space, moving the ball around and from side to side could open up spaces

It does my nuts in when someone randomly shouts "forward" when its passed from the midfield to the defence as though it's as simple as that.
 
3 things of keeping the ball like that....

They haven't got it so can't hurt us / score
Our players are having a breather whilst theirs are running after the ball - it's much easier with it than without
Probing for a space, moving the ball around and from side to side could open up spaces

It does my nuts in when someone randomly shouts "forward" when its passed from the midfield to the defence as though it's as simple as that.

I agree totally. People are missing the point regarding this possession football for the reasons you state.

If it is frustrating for some of our unappreciating supporters you can imagine how frustrating it is for the opposition. The longer we keep the ball, the more frustrated they get which often leads to them making mistakes from losing their shape and composure.
 
It does my nuts in when someone randomly shouts "forward" when its passed from the midfield to the defence as though it's as simple as that.


I honestly think we have some of the thickest fans in the country.

If there was a nationwide exam I think the only teams we could finish above would be Burnley, Shitpool, West Ham and Leeds.
 
I agree totally. People are missing the point regarding this possession football for the reasons you state.

If it is frustrating for some of our unappreciating supporters you can imagine how frustrating it is for the opposition. The longer we keep the ball, the more frustrated they get which often leads to them making mistakes from losing their shape and composure.

I think it was Brian Clough who once said that the ball can move faster than any player can run. Unfortunately the likes of Charles Hughes took that to extremes but it's the basic premise behind possession football.
 
Your being facetious jc.

Common sense would know that if hemmings wanted to he could afford tom pope.

I was, sorry.

But you seem to be one of a small band on here constantly calling for more signings.

Firstly, the depth of Hemmings' pockets is not correlated to the likelihood of signings because it's about the solvency of the club and secondly, we have Garner, Hugill, Little and Davis, plus young Robinson (possibly for the season). We play one up front, so why would SG be looking for another striker?

You're likely to be continuously disappointed if you keep thinking that we are going to get (expensive) strikers in.
 
Did we or did we not bid a considerable amount for Stevie May? I believe we did, & if so that would indicate that TH is prepared to release funds for team strengthening. At the moment I feel we have enough options in the team & we are obviously doing well. Will these funds be made available in January for the run in?
 
I was, sorry.

But you seem to be one of a small band on here constantly calling for more signings.

Firstly, the depth of Hemmings' pockets is not correlated to the likelihood of signings because it's about the solvency of the club and secondly, we have Garner, Hugill, Little and Davis, plus young Robinson (possibly for the season). We play one up front, so why would SG be looking for another striker?

You're likely to be continuously disappointed if you keep thinking that we are going to get (expensive) strikers in.
Im not calling for any signings, where have I stated this?

I said to another poster in here that I wouldnt mind pope in our team, thats when you came in with flipant remarks.

If anything its me who realises how much hemmings has already put into the club.
 
Im not calling for any signings, where have I stated this?

I said to another poster in here that I wouldnt mind pope in our team, thats when you came in with flipant remarks.

If anything its me who realises how much hemmings has already put into the club.

I took the below as meaning calling for more signings - does it not mean that?

And my deliberately flippant remark was deliberately flippant, as IMNTHO, the "Hemmings dig in your pocket" line isn't a good argument. I don't mean to single you out by the way. 🙂

Its frustrating because we can affors him. Out of the two players clubs I reckon port vale would be more open to offers.

Its all hyperthetically speaking but.......
 
I took the below as meaning calling for more signings - does it not mean that?

And my deliberately flippant remark was deliberately flippant, as IMNTHO, the "Hemmings dig in your pocket" line isn't a good argument. I don't mean to single you out by the way. 🙂
Nah, the below remark was a hypothetical situation. if we was to bid for him, it would be great and I reckon hemmings could afford it.

Little hasnt been great so far abd hugill who showed great promise is out for 5 months, kevin davies is shot at tbh and has had little effect. a tad more strength in depth up front wouldnt go a miss and I think pope and garner would make a pretty lethal partnership.

However, we could probably do with anothee centre half so pope wouldnt happen anyway.
 
They can't score while we keep the ball...

Admittedly that's not working because we've conceded loads this season, but I'd rather keep the ball than see it hoofed long and invariably straight to the opposition who can then attack us.
So what i am being told is that all off our passing sideways and backwards and onto the goalie is tactics aimed at frustrating the opposition?
I am not a tactition by any stretch of the imagination but i know what i see and unfortunately i see players who have no (or very little) forward thinking or vision.

But then that is why we are in the 3rd tier.
 
Last edited:
So what i am being told is that all off our passing sideways and backwards and onto the goalie is tactics aimed at frustrating the opposition?
I am not a tactition by any stretch of the imagination but i know what i see and unfortunately i see players who have no (or very little) forward thinking or vision.

But then that is why we are in the 3rd tier.

I think that it is you who don't have any forward thinking or vision! You must be one of the supporters who shout that we should hoof it forward to our sole striker

If you can't understand the purpose of possession football as an alternative to hoofball and losing possession, then I am sorry to say that you must be tactically inept.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top