Vermijl?
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2004
- Messages
- 995
1) I think Woods should be back in when available, though there is not a lot in it.
2) The difficulty with a question like this is that we do not know what the realistic alternative options are, wouldn't be a bad signing but we could potentially do better.
2) The difficulty with a question like this is that we do not know what the realistic alternative options are, wouldn't be a bad signing but we could potentially do better.
Woods should be straight back in.
Marnick has done quite well after a slow start, but with Humphrey and Grimshaw returning next season we are well stocked down that side of the pitch, so maybe we could use his wage elsewhere.
Marnick has done quite well after a slow start, but with Humphrey and Grimshaw returning next season we are well stocked down that side of the pitch, so maybe we could use his wage elsewhere.
Woods should be back in, he is in good form.
Vermijl is a better player though.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Vermijl is a better player though.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Both are decent players at this level IMO. They have different attributes but could both be regular starters. Like nobleroman said, there's not a lot in it.
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2005
- Messages
- 111,057
If, within our budget, we can do it, Vermijl is an absolute shoe in for me.Woods should be back in, he is in good form.
Vermijl is a better player though.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Darikwa who?
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
Keep him. No emergency loans next season so bigger squads are required. Marnick has done a couple of times in a few appearances what Humphrey hasn't done in 3 years.
Woods should be straight back in.
Marnick has done quite well after a slow start, but with Humphrey and Grimshaw returning next season we are well stocked down that side of the pitch, so maybe we could use his wage elsewhere.
Grimshaw may be more of a central midfielder while the Humphrey situation simply is not clear at all. Vermilj has the versatility to play both right-back and right wing-back which is certainly a plus. But it is on the left where we are really short. It is a close call - watching the highlights of yesterday's game it does appear that Vermilj came close to scoring again.
Grimshaw may be more of a central midfielder while the Humphrey situation simply is not clear at all. Vermilj has the versatility to play both right-back and right wing-back which is certainly a plus. But it is on the left where we are really short. It is a close call - watching the highlights of yesterday's game it does appear that Vermilj came close to scoring again.
I'd say Humphrey's situation is very clear. His season was ended in October and he will be given a proper chance to prove himself at this level, like every other player was this season.
As for Grimshaw, I guess we'll just have to wait and see which position he is used most in.
Woods should be straight back in.
Marnick has done quite well after a slow start, but with Humphrey and Grimshaw returning next season we are well stocked down that side of the pitch, so maybe we could use his wage elsewhere.
Humphreys needs a one way ticket back to Motherwell.
Humphreys needs a one way ticket back to Motherwell.
Humphrey's attributes and deficiencies are well-known - speed and enthusiasm in the first case, lack of both dribbling skills and any wider 'vision' in the second. At Div 1 level the first of those made him surprisingly effective as a wing-back and the second utterly ineffective as a more attacking winger. If his recovery from injury is anything less than total - in other words if his speed is reduced - then you can't see that he has any other resources that he could use to compensate. But if he can be as fast then maybe he can bring an extra something to the side - maybe a bit more because the Championship is that bit more free-flowing.
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2006
- Messages
- 5,724
Humphrey's attributes and deficiencies are well-known - speed and enthusiasm in the first case, lack of both dribbling skills and any wider 'vision' in the second. At Div 1 level the first of those made him surprisingly effective as a wing-back and the second utterly ineffective as a more attacking winger. If his recovery from injury is anything less than total - in other words if his speed is reduced - then you can't see that he has any other resources that he could use to compensate. But if he can be as fast then maybe he can bring an extra something to the side - maybe a bit more because the Championship is that bit more free-flowing.
Some first class straw grasping going on there ernest.
Some first class straw grasping going on there ernest.
Indeed - I suspect Humphrey won't be good enough for the Championship but if SG gives him a chance then at least when we play the wing-back formation I am prepared to be surprised.
Vermijl is a better wing back than Woods but Woods is a better right back than Vermijl.
Woods is much improved this year and is also good cover at left back and centre back .
Wing back - Right back - Left back - Centre back.
Maybe this is why I'm not a Manager.............
Some first class straw grasping going on there ernest.
(couldn't resist once you mentioned straws)
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2006
- Messages
- 5,724