Skip to main content

Warnock interview

Warnock interview

A long ball, no matter who it is played by, is still a long ball. Just because he is better at it, it doesn't make the chance any easier. It is not giving our strikers a decent opportunity to score. If, as you say, we should 'make the best use of the assets we have' we ought to be creating better chances for our strikers then, surely? If Gallagher is 'the cleverest footballer in the squad', why is he forced to pass from over 40+ yards away? Why not use him more effectively? Why are all our chances half-chances? If all of our strikers have one goal between them how is this 'best use of the assets we have'? I would say it's the worst use of the assets we have.

There are, I believe, two aspects of your general line of reasoning that are incorrect, simplistic even.

First your characterisation of a style of play forces you to describe it in a negative way to support your opinion. A quality long pass is derided by you as 'hoof ball' but at what distance of pass does it turn from lovely to lumping? Is the Bob Atkins measure 5, 10 or 15 yards? Or do you measure it in metres? Do we now need a tape measure to assess the quality of a game? Ironically, with Hunts and Clarke out injured, our play during the recent period has relied much less on long balls from defence.

Secondly, when a supporter makes their mind up about a style of play and attributes this primarily to the malevolent influence of SG, they tend to see only what reinforces their opinion. The conclusion then reached is either through filtering out subconsciously the facts that don't fit or worse, making the facts fit the pre-determined analysis. If you go to watch a game convinced you won't enjoy it, the likelihood is that your prejudice will be confirmed.

Opinions don't become fact either through repetition or even strongly held belief - 'there is nothing good or bad, but thinking makes it so' is the famous line from Hamlet. And like Hamlet, the anti-SG rhetoric has the inevitability of tragedy about it.

But, having broken my own rule about repeating my argument on the same thread, I'll leave the space for others to have a word and shut up. 😱
 
If you go to watch a game convinced you won't enjoy it, the likelihood is that your prejudice will be confirmed.
A shit film is a shit film. An ugly bird is an ugly bird. Boring football is boring football. A fat arse is a fat arse.

Or are you saying calling it as it is is wrong because it is our football team and we should all clap along in delight regardless of the lack of entertainment?
 
A shit film is a shit film. An ugly bird is an ugly bird. Boring football is boring football. A fat arse is a fat arse.

Or are you saying calling it as it is is wrong because it is our football team and we should all clap along in delight regardless of the lack of entertainment?
you missed out "in my opinion". Others have opinions too.
 
you missed out "in my opinion". Others have opinions too.
Of course its my opinion..... thats why I have written 'in my opinion' on most of my other posts........ didn't see you pick up lasherbasher for not writing that specific point as well, please be more uniform in your criticism 😉
 
There are, I believe, two aspects of your general line of reasoning that are incorrect, simplistic even.

First your characterisation of a style of play forces you to describe it in a negative way to support your opinion. A quality long pass is derided by you as 'hoof ball' but at what distance of pass does it turn from lovely to lumping? Is the Bob Atkins measure 5, 10 or 15 yards? Or do you measure it in metres? Do we now need a tape measure to assess the quality of a game? Ironically, with Hunts and Clarke out injured, our play during the recent period has relied much less on long balls from defence.
I realise my initial wording was open to a negative interpretation, which is why I clarified my point. You have now ignored this in order to continue discussing the terminology I used, meaning you are deliberately missing the point. Shall I try again? Do you think ONLY using long passes is our best use of assets? Or do you think we should try other means of attack?

Secondly, when a supporter makes their mind up about a style of play and attributes this primarily to the malevolent influence of SG, they tend to see only what reinforces their opinion. The conclusion then reached is either through filtering out subconsciously the facts that don't fit or worse, making the facts fit the pre-determined analysis. If you go to watch a game convinced you won't enjoy it, the likelihood is that your prejudice will be confirmed.
Not so. If you refer back to the matchday thread from the Bolton game I was making positive comments at half time about our first half play, contrary to many other posters, and was hopeful we could build on it in the second half. As it turned out I was very wrong and they were right, sadly.

Opinions don't become fact either through repetition or even strongly held belief - 'there is nothing good or bad, but thinking makes it so' is the famous line from Hamlet. And like Hamlet, the anti-SG rhetoric has the inevitability of tragedy about it.

But, having broken my own rule about repeating my argument on the same thread, I'll leave the space for others to have a word and shut up. 😱
I am trying to discuss, rather than argue. I am entirely open other views if they convince me I am wrong, and I wish I was. After all 'When you Talk you are only Repeating what you know; but when Listen, you may Learn something new', Dalai Lama. Oh look, I can quote as well.

I like SG. I want him to succeed. My views are born of concern for the season ahead, nothing more.
 
A long ball, no matter who it is played by, is still a long ball. Just because he is better at it, it doesn't make the chance any easier. It is not giving our strikers a decent opportunity to score. If, as you say, we should 'make the best use of the assets we have' we ought to be creating better chances for our strikers then, surely? If Gallagher is 'the cleverest footballer in the squad', why is he forced to pass from over 40+ yards away? Why not use him more effectively? Why are all our chances half-chances? If all of our strikers have one goal between them how is this 'best use of the assets we have'? I would say it's the worst use of the assets we have.

Thing is Bob, you're sort of wrong here. It was proven in research (which John Beck built his long-ball philosophy around) that the more balls that get into the box, the higher the likelihood of scoring. Now I grant you that in our case this is clearly not working, but as a footballing method it's backed by the empirical evidence.
 
Thing is Bob, you're sort of wrong here. It was proven in research (which John Beck built his long-ball philosophy around) that the more balls that get into the box, the higher the likelihood of scoring. Now I grant you that in our case this is clearly not working, but as a footballing method it's backed by the empirical evidence.

It is backed by the evidence gathered - but it does depend somewhat on getting people into the box to do something with the pass ?
 
It is backed by the evidence gathered - but it does depend somewhat on getting people into the box to do something with the pass ��

Quite, and of course what the evidence also didn't make clear was that it is bloody turgid to watch if a goal doesn't come of it.
 
Quite, and of course what the evidence also didn't make clear was that it is bloody turgid to watch if a goal doesn't come of it.

Is research based on delivering a high number of balls though? Something we are not really doing. Also, a lot of the balls into the box I have witnessed this season have been into a crowded area with everyone facing away from goal. Perhaps if we can get an earlier ball into a striker running towards the goal we will give them a better chance.
 
Thing is Bob, you're sort of wrong here. It was proven in research (which John Beck built his long-ball philosophy around) that the more balls that get into the box, the higher the likelihood of scoring. Now I grant you that in our case this is clearly not working, but as a footballing method it's backed by the empirical evidence.

Too true JCF, and if you had someone like Alex Dawson there to mop up all these chances, it should....... work. However, we haven't got such an outlet, so it's not working very well. Was it Beck or Dave Bassett who coined the accompanying phrase "POMO"?
 
Too true JCF, and if you had someone like Alex Dawson there to mop up all these chances, it should....... work. However, we haven't got such an outlet, so it's not working very well. Was it Beck or Dave Bassett who coined the accompanying phrase "POMO"?

I think it was Charles Hughes - the coach Beck basically took his philosophy from.
 
It is... Not quite the " quality " division that it's made out to be is it?....... Big fat wages/ bank balances and transfer fees don't necessarily equate to better footballing standards imho...Neither do I believe that it takes massive amounts of money to be successful in the Championship..It helps of course but I think the most important attribute of a club is it's " nous "..... And ( as much as I hate to admit it ) yours appears to have it..

Thanks for the reply.

No worries 😎

I've never been a fan of this idea that the Championship is a 'quality' League. When we both came up to it in 2000 and you had teams like Fulham with players like Saha in it, maybe. Now ? Not so much. It's a competitive League, but that's not the same as quality. There are an awful lot of much-of-a-muchness bang-average teams in there, and the phrase "they're the worst team I've seen at this level" seems to trip off the tongue with increasing frequency.

Funnily enough as regards that 2000/2001 season, Bolton were one of the best teams in that League by a distance; they pitched up at the Turf the other week and had League One written all over them.
 
Back
Top