What has Jones brought to the team this season ? What are his attributes ? Serious question because i honestly don't know after watching him for the first 10 games. All i have seen is a suspect defence where panic spreads quickly stemming from a keeper constantly rooted to his line with little or no communication. Maybe I'm being ridiculously harsh as people have said but its just what I've seen and observed.
Stuckmann was poor against Port Vale,but i thought he had a very assured game in the earlier round against Shrewsbury. To Judge Stuckmann after that one game is more harsh for me than judging Jones after a good run in the side at the start of the season. Every keeper has to have a good run, we have all seen Stuckmann at his best a couple of seasons back, commanding his area, communicating with his centre halves and showing great agility for a big guy. His reward was player of the season.
Im not trying to say Stuckmann is some kind of great keeper rather that he brings more to the team than Jones. I think its only fair he gets a chance. Your point with Rudd is taken but thats just the nature of goalkeepers, the best in the world can drop it in their own net or drop huge clangers. Its the basic fundamentals i look for, commanding at least your six yard box, awareness off your line, and distribution. All these relieve pressure on the defence. All should be able to make good saves now and again when called upon at this level.
We will see what happens as the season progresses but i firmly believe Stuckmann rather than Jones will make us a more solid team. Only time will tell.