Skip to main content

Weak link?

Weak link?

I think you're way off the mark. As I commented on a similar thread, I have seen Jones play for Orient a great deal over the last four years or so as I am quite a frequent spectator, with orient supporting mates. He is nowhere near as good as Rudd but he is plenty good enough for league one. Rudd wasn't flawless but he will be a regular premiership keeper in time and we have been spoilt over the last season and a half. Comparing any keeper in league 1 to Rudd is pointless. Jones will serve our purpose IMHO.

Never compared Jones to Rudd once. Simply said we have two keepers and with a run of games Stuckmann is the better of the two.
 
How dare you talk about the Messiah like that? He was perfect and was never at fault for any goals. Indeed any that looked like he could have done better with was usually the defenders fault for giving a free kick away 35 yards from goal.


Two keeper-error goals at Peterborough and gifting the momentum to Brentford at home by a daft penalty = 6 points lost = same points as Brentford and better goal difference.
 
Two keeper-error goals at Peterborough and gifting the momentum to Brentford at home by a daft penalty = 6 points lost = same points as Brentford and better goal difference.
Think you may have missed some sarcasm there! 😉
 
Never compared Jones to Rudd once. Simply said we have two keepers and with a run of games Stuckmann is the better of the two.

I can't believe that anyone thinks that Stuckmann is better than Jones. Surely Stuckmann's performance on Tuesday night dispelled any lingering doubts.

I also don't think that Rudd was quite the messiah that people are making out. As pointed out he single-handedly cost us 6 points against Peterborough and Brentford.
 
I can't believe that anyone thinks that Stuckmann is better than Jones. Surely Stuckmann's performance on Tuesday night dispelled any lingering doubts.

I also don't think that Rudd was quite the messiah that people are making out. As pointed out he single-handedly cost us 6 points against Peterborough and Brentford.

What has Jones brought to the team this season ? What are his attributes ? Serious question because i honestly don't know after watching him for the first 10 games. All i have seen is a suspect defence where panic spreads quickly stemming from a keeper constantly rooted to his line with little or no communication. Maybe I'm being ridiculously harsh as people have said but its just what I've seen and observed.

Stuckmann was poor against Port Vale,but i thought he had a very assured game in the earlier round against Shrewsbury. To Judge Stuckmann after that one game is more harsh for me than judging Jones after a good run in the side at the start of the season. Every keeper has to have a good run, we have all seen Stuckmann at his best a couple of seasons back, commanding his area, communicating with his centre halves and showing great agility for a big guy. His reward was player of the season.

Im not trying to say Stuckmann is some kind of great keeper rather that he brings more to the team than Jones. I think its only fair he gets a chance. Your point with Rudd is taken but thats just the nature of goalkeepers, the best in the world can drop it in their own net or drop huge clangers. Its the basic fundamentals i look for, commanding at least your six yard box, awareness off your line, and distribution. All these relieve pressure on the defence. All should be able to make good saves now and again when called upon at this level.

We will see what happens as the season progresses but i firmly believe Stuckmann rather than Jones will make us a more solid team. Only time will tell.
 
Jones is in for unfair criticism really. Been part of a top league one side the past two season and hardly to blame for the indecisiveness of two relatively young centre halves and full backs that change from game to game. I'd blame any defensive frailties on our lack of control in the centre mid.

Stuckers was a hero in a shit side and looks poor in the past two seasons when given a shirt
 
What has Jones brought to the team this season ? What are his attributes ? Serious question because i honestly don't know after watching him for the first 10 games. All i have seen is a suspect defence where panic spreads quickly stemming from a keeper constantly rooted to his line with little or no communication. Maybe I'm being ridiculously harsh as people have said but its just what I've seen and observed.

Stuckmann was poor against Port Vale,but i thought he had a very assured game in the earlier round against Shrewsbury. To Judge Stuckmann after that one game is more harsh for me than judging Jones after a good run in the side at the start of the season. Every keeper has to have a good run, we have all seen Stuckmann at his best a couple of seasons back, commanding his area, communicating with his centre halves and showing great agility for a big guy. His reward was player of the season.

Im not trying to say Stuckmann is some kind of great keeper rather that he brings more to the team than Jones. I think its only fair he gets a chance. Your point with Rudd is taken but thats just the nature of goalkeepers, the best in the world can drop it in their own net or drop huge clangers. Its the basic fundamentals i look for, commanding at least your six yard box, awareness off your line, and distribution. All these relieve pressure on the defence. All should be able to make good saves now and again when called upon at this level.

We will see what happens as the season progresses but i firmly believe Stuckmann rather than Jones will make us a more solid team. Only time will tell.

If you think Stuckmann is still a good goalkeeper, I must inform you that you are in a minority. His rare appearances have shown that he would be a disaster and Tuesday night was proof of the pudding. Were you there because, if so, how can you state that he should be first choice.

I can guarantee that he will not be offered a new contract next summer.
 
Last edited:
Anyone of the same opinion that Goalkeeper is slight weak link in the side. I've not been overly impressed with Jones and I most certainly wasn't with Stuckmann tonight. I can't believe the gulf in class between them and Rudd.
One would assume that Kelly coaches them and doesn't advocate being glued to the line every time the ball is crossed into the box? Goalies nowadays, Shaky would have a field day ?
The goalkeepers postion was always going to be weaker after dec rudd left.

Some posters are saying jones is one of the worst keepers at PNE, ok not great and does look shakey coming for crosses at times and could come off his line more but he certainly isnt the worst.
 
If you think Stuckmann is still a good goalkeeper, I must inform you that you are in a minority. His rare appearances have shown that he would be a disaster and Tuesday night was proof of the pudding. Were you there because, if so, how can you state that he should be first choice.

I can guarantee that he will not be offered a new contract next summer.

In his first season Stuckmann showed that he was more than capable at this level. Its a bit unfair to judge him since then as he's barely had a look in after Westley arsed him and Simonsen around in the first part of 2012-13.

Agree that it looks unlikely he'll get a chance though - for whatever reason Grayson doesn't fancy him. Based on how rusty he looks without regular first team football its hard to imagine that he looks a lot better in training.
 
Back
Top